Requests for comment
Add a link to the proposal page or disputed page or create a new subpage requesting comments here (please use {{Rfc subpage}}). Anyone is welcome to give their opinion on the requests listed below. See also: all RfC pages and more Wiki-wide elections and votings.
- For local Meta-Wiki issues please use the local process Meta:Requests for comment instead.
Relevant policy for the opening, handling, and closure of RFCs can be found at Requests for comment/Policy.
Creating a new request
Create a subpage with a suitable name, for example Requests for comment/Reforming the RFC process
and content:
{{rfc subpage |status = |comment = |date = {{subst:CURRENTTIMESTAMP}} <!-- creation date, do **not** change --> }}
Below this describe your issue and submit the edit. Don't forget to sign your initial statement. The link to your page will automatically appear here, thus do not try to add it manually, but you may have to use the "Purge" link above, otherwise it may take some days until it happens.
Please ensure that you meet the requirements for opening a RFC, and that you notify the required parties or wikis, as per Requests for comment/Policy.
Open requests for comment
This is a list of currently opened requests for comments sorted by creation date (oldest at the bottom). This list is being updated automatically on a regular basis.
- Requests for comment/Blatant sockpuppetry in good faith
- Requests for comment/Make Commons filemovers skipcaptcha globally
- Requests for comment/Restrict non-confirmed users of all wikis from crosswiki-uploading files to Commons
- Requests for comment/Severe Problems in hewiki
- Requests for comment/Remove changetags user right from users on all wikis
- Requests for comment/Turkish Wikipedia Faulty CheckUser operation
- Requests for comment/Welcoming policy
- Requests for comment/Entire nation portrayed as fascist on Greek Wikipedia - objections are not welcomed
- Requests for comment/Extract global bot policy to own page
- Requests for comment/declared as troll for no real reason
- Requests for comment/Official complaint against a bureaucrat for defamation on Hebrew Wikipedia
- Requests for comment/GFDL to CC License Migration of files
- Requests for comment/Request for exemption, an local blocking
- Requests for comment/Blocked for no reason at Greek Wikipedia
- Requests for comment/Zhxy 519, the admin with a recording of multiple severe abuses in history, today abuses in zh.wikisource once again.
- Requests for comment/Hoaxes about Azerbaijan in Armenian Wikipedia
- Requests for comment/Abuse of power by bureaucrats in the Hebrew Wikipedia
- Requests for comment/Requesting a look into Arabic Wikipedia Bias
- Requests for comment/Unauthorized screenshots from private WhatsApp conversations
- Requests for comment/Trwiki block of RuzDD by an unproven sockpuppet claim
- Requests for comment/Gotquestions and Tektonics
- Requests for comment/threatening language and censorship by two Arabic Wikipedia admins
- Requests for comment/UPE by az.wiki admins
- Requests for comment/Authoritarian vibe on the Romanian Wikipedia
- Requests for comment/Category of non-free images in Wikipedia in Aragonese wich clearly contravenes the Wikimedia Licensing Policy
- Requests for comment/Broad IP ban on the German Wiktionary
- Requests for comment/Permanently blocked in WP in Aragonese, without right to defense, for requesting the deletion of insulting expressions
- Requests for comment/Hiding the number of Russian/Belorussian/Kazakh contributors on the statistics map
- Requests for comment/Sister Projects Committee
- Requests for comment/Bureaucrat abuse of vote in Belarusian Classical Wikipedia
- Requests for comment/Intentional disruptive editing by bnwiki admin
- Requests for comment/Ideals and realities on the ground in Norwegian Wikipedia
- Requests for comment/Discussing sources on the Croatian Wikipedia
- Requests for comment/Severe conflict involving problematic sysop on pt.Wiki
- Requests for comment/Copyright violations on Macedonian Wikibooks
- Requests for comment/Global ban requirements
- Requests for comment/Ombuds Commission inactivity
- Requests for comment/Large-scale errors at Malagasy Wiktionary
Closed requests for comment
A list of closed RFCs are kept in the archive. Below you'll find a list of the most recent closed sorted by category:
As resolved
For a full list see Category:Requests for comments (resolved). The last ten closed RFCs for this category are shown below:
- Requests for comment/Update standard license for Wikinews
- Requests for comment/Global ban for Won1017
- Requests for comment/Global account blocking practices
- Requests for comment/My voting rights were taken away without a reasonable explanation
- Requests for comment/Blocked without warning Hebrew Wiki
- Requests for comment/Blocked without breaking any rule
- Requests for comment/unexplained blockage in Hebrew wikipedia
- Requests for comment/Unjustified block in the Hebrew Wikipedia
- Requests for comment/blocked and ignored by the bureaucrats in Hebrew Wiki
- Requests for comment/KOSA
As unsuccessful
For a full list see Category:Requests for comments (unsuccessful). The last ten closed RFCs for this category are shown below:
- Requests for comment/Amend language policy to ban new conlang Wikipedias
- Requests for comment/Global ban request for POSSUM chowg
- Requests for comment/The block log lacks useful information - basic requirements for sysop/admin accountability
- Requests for comment/New global filter for "bot"
- Requests for comment/Global ban for Slowking4 (2)
- Requests for comment/Community consensus for blackouts and other advocacy
- Requests for comment/Drama created by the only active administrator of viwikipedia
- Requests for comment/Violating the Neutral point of view in Arabic Wiki
- Requests for comment/Motion of No Confidence in Some Bureaucrat and Administrators of the Chinese Wikipedia, Curbing Collective Bullying, and Foundation Action Requests
- Requests for comment/Global ban for Бучач-Львів
As invalid
For a full list see Category:Requests for comments (invalid). The last ten closed RFCs for this category are shown below:
- Requests for comment/censorship in Estonia
- Requests for comment/Global ban for Kapadohány
- Requests for comment/denial of editing in Hebrew wikipedia
- Requests for comment/blockage from activity in Hebrew wiki
- Requests for comment/unjustified block by Hebrew bureaucrat
- Requests for comment/Banned without any explanation
- Requests for comment/Redesigning Wikipedia brand text font
- Requests for comment/Uncleared sockpuppet claim in viwiki
- Requests for comment/Should a global ban be issued for User:Stanistani
- Requests for comment/AnToni and his administratorship abuse on Bosnian Wikipedia
As inactive
For a full list see Category:Requests for comments (inactive). The last ten closed RFCs for this category are shown below:
- Requests for comment/Abuse of power by sysops in Russian Wikinews
- Requests for comment/Abuse of power by sysops in Spanish Wikipedia
- Requests for comment/Scope issues and copyright violations on Kyrgyz Wikibooks
- Requests for comment/sysop rights abuse in kawiki
- Requests for comment/Sysop abuse in Azerbaijani Wikipedia2
- Requests for comment/About copyright and possible infringements of it in WMF wikis
- Requests for comment/I need to solve the problem that I consider important in the eo.wiktionary.org project
- Requests for comment/Reforming local self government system on Croatian Wikipedia
- Requests for comment/Resolve massive copyright infringement on Wiktionary in Esperanto
- Requests for comment/Closing the gap to and between the base communities
See also
- Global project Wiki-Democracy providing links to RfCs, centralized discussions, elections and voting for all Wikimedia projects
General requests for: help from a Meta sysop or bureaucrat · deletion (speedy deletions: local · multilingual) · URL blacklisting · new languages · interwiki map
Personal requests for: username changes · permissions (global) · bot status · adminship on Meta · CheckUser information (local) · local administrator help
Cooperation requests for: comments (local) (global) · translation