Addressing Race-based Hate Speech and Microaggressive Behavior in Schools

APA Mental Health Primers
Addressing Race-Based Hate Speech and Microaggressive Behavior in Schools

Teachers are encouraged to be change agents as opposed to passive bystanders when they encounter race-based hate speech, jokes, and subtle prejudice-oriented references intended to insult and harm students. Ignoring and tolerating such behavior fosters a toxic classroom culture and dynamics that could have a long term negative impact emotionally, academically, and socially. Aside from protecting students who are targets of race-based microaggressions and hate speech, teachers need to work with students who initiate the behavior and help them learn from their inappropriate behavior.

Audio series: Addressing race-based hate speech and microaggressive behavior in schools
Join Amanda Dettmer, PhD, research scientist at the Yale School of Medicine’s Child Study Center, as she speaks with Tara Raines, PhD, PhyS, MS, deputy director of the Children's Advocacy Alliance and former associate professor and director of clinical training at the University of Denver’s School Psychology Program, who shares her expertise on how teachers can address race-based hate speech and microaggressive behavior in schools.

Disclaimer

This information is designed to help teachers respond to students who may be in need of support. It is not intended to be used as a diagnostic tool or to replace the use of formal assessments employed by mental health professionals. Additionally, it is important to consider the context of the situation, individual differences, and cultural and linguistic factors.

Race-based hate speech versus microaggressions

Race-based speech can take the form of verbal or nonverbal communications through spoken or written words, bodily expressions, or facial expressions that are meant to ridicule, hurt, discriminate, single out, or not include someone based on their race. Based on implicit biases, they are usually unconscious perceptions of racial groups.

Race-based speech ranges from subtle microaggressions, which are low-key, vague, and quick interactions, to blatant name calling, bullying, or accusations. Microaggressions and race-based speech are similar in that they both stem from underlying biases and perceptions; but differ in that microaggressions are covert faux pas whereas race-based speech is overt and includes intentional choices of words. They disrupt the flow of educational framework and settings because they trigger feelings of inferiority and dampen learning experiences.

Examples of race-based hate speech and microaggressions

Note that many of these examples can occur in both the physical classroom and in virtual learning environments (VLEs).

Race-based hate speech

Microaggressions

Staring, dirty looks I thought you liked that food.
Hateful slang words Isn’t that a sketchy neighborhood?
Having a "X group only "party" I don’t see color when I think of you as my friend.
"You people" I think you’re different than other Blacks or you’re not like those other Black people.
Posting hateful content on social media Posting (or reposting) a meme, GIF, or picture online that perpetuates a racial or cultural stereotype.

Why it should be addressed

It is important for educators to address race-based (speech) microaggressions to promote and maintain positive school culture and climate for all students. The use of race-based microaggressions alienates students who are targeted by their peers or, in an online format, people posting anonymously. They may experience feelings of sadness, anger, isolation, and/or powerlessness as a result of their racial identity being devalued by their peers. In particular, research studies indicate that for African American/Black students, one’s sense of belonging and connectedness are related to school culture and climate. When African American/Black students feel marginalized by microaggressive language, they are less likely to establish supportive peer relationships and less likely to feel motivated to voice their perspectives during conversations in the classroom. The cumulative effects of microaggressive language may result in African American/Black students being targeted, harassed, and discriminated against. It is crucial for educators to confront and engage students who use microaggressive language to foster equity and inclusion within the classroom and school environment. Students expect that educators will create a safe, welcoming, and inclusive space that facilitates classroom learning and positive peer engagement. Furthermore, research indicates that trust is an essential element within a student-teacher relationship. Educators who ignore microaggressive language inevitably destroy any possible meaningful relationship with African American/Black students.

What can I do or stop doing as a teacher?

There are a number of ways educators can address hate speech/behaviors and microaggressions in the school setting.

Engage in self-reflection so you are aware of your own implicit bias and behaviors that may be perceived as harmful.


Don't: Assume you cannot commit a microaggression or engage in racially harmful behaviors.

Understand that an intended message might get misunderstood and perceived by others as a microaggression.


Don't: Dismiss the feelings of the student who is the recipient because the microaggression was unintentional.

Pay attention to classroom dynamics and intervene ASAP.


Don't: Rely on students or colleagues of color to intervene or address the microaggression.

Address the incident when it occurs. This may provide a teachable moment for others involved or observing.


Don't: Wait to address the microaggression.

Communicate that you are a safe ally for students and colleagues of color.


Don't: Guess that people already know you are an ally.

Educate yourself and participate in anti-bias/anti-racist (ABAR) trainings in your area or online.


Don't: Assume that your required district, university, licensing, certification, or state trainings will explicitly cover antibias/anti-racist topics.

Empirical research

Allen,Q. (2012). "They think minority means lesser than": Black middle-class sons and fathers resisting microaggressions in the school. Urban Education, 48(2), pp. 171-197.

Malone, C., (2019). Understanding Implicit Bias and Addressing Microaggressions. Presentation for Thrive Behavioral Health, September 4, 2019.

The Mental Health Primers are developed by the Coalition for Psychology in Schools and Education. This resource was updated in October 2021 with support from cooperative agreement NU87PS004366 funded by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Its contents are solely the responsibility of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official views or endorsement of the CDC or the Department of Health and Human Services.

Mental Health Primers

These primers by the Coalition for Psychology in Schools and Education help teachers identify behaviors in the classroom that are symptomatic of mental health and other psychological issues.

APA contributes to psychological science by producing cutting-edge applied research to inform educational practices and policies, translating it into accessible formats for educators, championing evidence-based approaches, and supporting policies in which educators and students thrive.

Learn more about applying psychological science in pre-K to 12 schools and education