Après m'être relu, je suis sans doute inutilement agressif dans mon message, mais le fait est que tu reproches au film de ne pas avoir pris le parti pris explicite de défendre ton interprétation totalement personnelle du comics, sans la défendre, et en méprisant ceux qui auraient l'audace de la remettre en cause...
Si jamais tu me montres un commentaire de l'auteur qui va dans ton sens, je changerais d'avis. En attendant, pour moi, voila pourquoi le film n'est pas fidèle au message de la bédé :
«So I decided to use this to political effect by coming up with a projected Fascist state in the near future and setting an anarchist against that. As far I'm concerned, the two poles of politics were not Left Wing or Right Wing. In fact they're just two ways of ordering an industrial society and we're fast moving beyond the industrial societies of the 19th and 20th centuries. It seemed to me the two more absolute extremes were anarchy and fascism. This was one of the things I objected to in the recent film, where it seems to be, from the script that I read, sort of recasting it as current American neo-conservatism vs. current American liberalism. There wasn't a mention of anarchy as far as I could see. The fascism had been completely defanged. I mean, I think that any references to racial purity had been excised, whereas actually, fascists are quite big on racial purity. » http://web.archive.org/web/20070305213808/http://www.comicon(...)
Je préfère écouter l'auteur de la bédé que toi.
LinuxFr, parfois c'est bien de la MERDE : https://linuxfr.org/users/c2462250/journaux/ecriture-inclusive-feministes-et-wikipedia#comment-1793140
[^] # Re: Film Shutter Island
Posté par O'neam Anne . En réponse à la dépêche Brothers, Mr Fox, Sherlock et Shutter Island. Évalué à 6.
Si jamais tu me montres un commentaire de l'auteur qui va dans ton sens, je changerais d'avis. En attendant, pour moi, voila pourquoi le film n'est pas fidèle au message de la bédé :
«So I decided to use this to political effect by coming up with a projected Fascist state in the near future and setting an anarchist against that. As far I'm concerned, the two poles of politics were not Left Wing or Right Wing. In fact they're just two ways of ordering an industrial society and we're fast moving beyond the industrial societies of the 19th and 20th centuries. It seemed to me the two more absolute extremes were anarchy and fascism. This was one of the things I objected to in the recent film, where it seems to be, from the script that I read, sort of recasting it as current American neo-conservatism vs. current American liberalism. There wasn't a mention of anarchy as far as I could see. The fascism had been completely defanged. I mean, I think that any references to racial purity had been excised, whereas actually, fascists are quite big on racial purity. »
http://web.archive.org/web/20070305213808/http://www.comicon(...)
Je préfère écouter l'auteur de la bédé que toi.
LinuxFr, parfois c'est bien de la MERDE : https://linuxfr.org/users/c2462250/journaux/ecriture-inclusive-feministes-et-wikipedia#comment-1793140