How can you use the python exec keyword inside functions?
asked Apr 13, 2010 at 2:20
None
-
5What exactly is giving you trouble? What have you tried so far?Mark Rushakoff– Mark Rushakoff2010年04月13日 02:22:54 +00:00Commented Apr 13, 2010 at 2:22
-
4what is it that you are trying to do?ghostdog74– ghostdog742010年04月13日 02:23:13 +00:00Commented Apr 13, 2010 at 2:23
3 Answers 3
It's going to damage your function's performance, as well as its maintainability, but if you really want to make your own code so much worse, Python2 (this will not work in Python3, there you need to use the second alternative) gives you "enough rope to shoot yourself in the foot" (;-):
>>> def horror():
... exec "x=23"
... return x
...
>>> print horror()
23
A tad less horrible, of course, would be to exec in a specific dict:
>>> def better():
... d = {}
... exec "x=23" in d
... return d['x']
...
>>> print better()
23
This at least avoids the namespace-pollution of the first approach.
Thomas
1,8811 gold badge12 silver badges25 bronze badges
answered Apr 13, 2010 at 2:27
Alex Martelli
888k175 gold badges1.3k silver badges1.4k bronze badges
Sign up to request clarification or add additional context in comments.
3 Comments
imranal
Sometimes I need to make variables on the fly while doing some symbolic computing. How else do you suggest to do this, without using exec?
taiko
@imranal i need exactly this in my code and the only way I also found was using 'exec'. Did you find any other option ever since
Vaidøtas I.
worst example of exec() use I've ever seen
Alex's answer works slightly differently in Python 3.
Since exec() is a function in Python 3, use the following pattern-
def better():
d = {}
exec("x=23", d)
return d['x']
print better()
23
See this question for more details- Behavior of exec function in Python 2 and Python 3
3 Comments
Nic Scozzaro
Is there a solution for python3 that doesn't involve creating a dictionary?
H. Saxena
Use
exec('x=23', globals()) but note that this will add all variables generated inside exec into your global scope. It'll also overwrite any variables with the same name.vpz
The
exec(code_string, globals()) was exactly what I needed to import and use functions from interactively. Thanks @H.Saxena!Yes.
class A:
def __init__(self):
self.a1 = ''
self.a2 = ''
def populate():
att1 = raw_input("enter a1: ")
att2 = raw_input("enter a2: ")
my_object = A()
eval("my_obj.a1 = att1")
eval("my_obj.a2 = att2")
if eval("my_obj.a2") == 2:
print "Hooray! the value of a2 in my_obj is 2"
Hope this helps
answered Apr 13, 2010 at 2:30
inspectorG4dget
115k30 gold badges159 silver badges253 bronze badges
3 Comments
Ponkadoodle
eval and exec, two different things in Python. eval("my_obj.a1 = att1") will give you a syntax error (raised by eval) (try exec instead).
Greg Hewgill
eval() in Python only accepts expressions, and assignment is a statement, not an expression.inspectorG4dget
I'm sorry. I clearly made a bad post. I see the error now and realize that I made an idiot move. I guess the exam stress must be getting to me. Apologies.
lang-py