HTTPGET an image

Back for some help,
I have a Liberty Basic program that displays charts from Yahoo finance via the Yahoo API
httpget works fine in LB, I can display the downloaded image in a graphic box with no issues.

I don't understand why the "png" image will not display in RB using the same code

how ever the file downloaded using LB4.50 will render when opened within RB

I have concluded the RB "saved" file gets corrupted some how

any help appreciated
urlfile$ = "http://chart.finance.yahoo.com/z?s=NAB.AX&t=1y&q=l&l=on&z=l&p=m10,m50,v&a=r14"
page$=HTTPGET$(urlfile$)


open "pic.png" for output as #1
print #1, page$
close #1


loadgraphic #picture, "pic.png"
render #picture

SOLVED: opened the file for binary did the trick
:(
lot to learn

An image is always a binary file ;)
Generally all files can be saved using the binary file type without data corruption.