Looking at the images, the bottom line of the toolbar is not aligned with the line in the sidebar and in the inspector. It's not a straight line across the toolbar and the sidebars. Is that something that Apple's frameworks are rendering or CodeEdit?

It seems the toolbar has significantly longer height than it should have

Looking at the images, the bottom line of the toolbar is not aligned with the line in the sidebar and in the inspector. It's not a straight line across the toolbar and the sidebars. Is that something that Apple's frameworks are rendering or CodeEdit?

It's a bit of both. The built-in toolbar no longer has a set size across each so we'll probably follow Xcode's lead and change it up. That's not actually a part of the toolbar in CE though, so it'll be a different PR.

It seems the toolbar has significantly longer height than it should have

It's larger now but it also looks significantly larger because we have some hard-coded top padding in components that will need to be updated.

It seems the toolbar has significantly longer height than it should have

It's larger now but it also looks significantly larger because we have some hard-coded top padding in components that will need to be updated.

May I ask which components need this top padding removed?

It seems the toolbar has significantly longer height than it should have

It's larger now but it also looks significantly larger because we have some hard-coded top padding in components that will need to be updated.

May I ask which components need this top padding removed?

It should be the EditorLayoutView iirc and I think there's some in the navigator code. tbh I haven't looked into it yet.

Ah shoot, you're totally right it is the toolbar making that space...

Good catch, figured it out. Can't use the .unified toolbar style it has to be .automatic.

Well that unified to default change led to a whole slew of bugs but I think this is ready to go!

Yeah size seems perfect now. But the toolbar background is getting this transparent effect from the tahoe default toolbar styling.
I'd assume .scrollEdgeEffectStyle(.hard) could help but couldn't get that to work

Yeah size seems perfect now. But the toolbar background is getting this transparent effect from the tahoe default toolbar styling.

I'd assume .scrollEdgeEffectStyle(.hard) could help but couldn't get that to work

2025年08月30日_07-12-29

Shoot! I forgot to double check it on dark mode. I'll take a look.

Okay two things with the transparency. It's inconsistent when it's that opaque on light mode, almost like it only remembers to do so after it's been changed from dark mode.

I think it's the right move to have it pretty transparent. But the gutter view is not having the glass effect applied to it for some reason... I'm going to see if I can fix that as a CESE issue and leave the transparency in the toolbar.

When I move on to tabs next I may explore making them sit on a glass element.

Okay yeah this is partly a liquid glass bug. It's not applying the glass styling to floating scrollview views. I'll submit a feedback and then we'll need to consider how to move forward. Probably making the toolbar less opaque.

Usually it applies the blurring to SwiftUI scrollviews or lists automatically but Im guessing the underlying codeeditorview is far from swiftui.
Also, I’d say its fine for the toolbar to be opaque, similar to Xcode 26 since there are elements like tabviww and jumpbar below it

Yeah it appears that the liquid glass effect just doesn't apply to floating scrollview views. I've submitted a feedback for it, we may just have to clip the gutter to the visible area for now. And yeah the editor view isn't SwiftUI it's mostly AppKit.

What if we added a layer underneath for now instead of clipping it?

What if we added a layer underneath for now instead of clipping it?

Good thought, I can try it

It looks great on the tab bar but the gutter still overflows everything. I'm really not sure how to move forwards with it. Same is true of the minimap divider view, glass just completely ignores it no matter what.

There's a second bug going on here too where again the toolbar sometimes just forgets to apply the glass effect to anything like in this screen cap. This is frustrating to work with

After a little messing around it remembers, but the gutter and minimap dividers are still unaffected.

Alright finally got an under-toolbar visual effect item to work! And it seems to have fixed the bug or at least made it unnoticeable. It is noticeable that it isn't glass, but maybe we can figure out a fix from CESE's side of things with the gutter view and minimap view.

I did originally have glass instead of a plain visualeffectview, but glass has a deactivated state that makes it obvious we're injecting something behind the toolbar. Maybe we can subclass NSGlassEffectView and change that but this works.