Schrage played four seasons as an outfielder at Creighton from 1980 to 1983, earning all-conference and Academic All-American honors. He hit .400 or higher in both his junior and senior seasons.[5]
After completing his degree at Creighton, Schrage accepted a position as a graduate assistant at St. Thomas, working for Paul Mainieri in 1984. The following season, he returned to Creighton as an assistant coach before coaching the Queensland Rams club team in Australia. He earned his first head coaching job at Waldorf, then a junior college in 1987. After three seasons and a 61–66 record, Schrage moved to Northern Iowa. He would remain with the Panthers for nine seasons, improving the team's win totals from 2 to 18 during his tenure and earning a pair of Missouri Valley Conference Coach of the Year awards. He would be honored as the only person to be named All-Conference and Coach of the Year in baseball by the MVC at their Centennial Celebration.[5] From 2000 to 2002, Schrage served as head coach at Northern Illinois. He took over a team that recorded only 4 wins the previous season and guided them to 24 wins in his first year and a winning season in his second. He was named runner-up for the National Coach of the Year Award by Collegiate Baseball.[6] Schrage then moved to Evansville, where he led the Purple Aces to 130 wins and a regional final in the 2006 NCAA tournament. Schrage then earned what he called his dream job, succeeding Mainieri as head coach at Notre Dame.[7] Prior to coaching a game, his wife Jody died from cancer.[8] Schrage was not able to continue Mainieri's success with the Irish, and was fired after four years. During his one year absence, he spent time with the Dowagiac Union high School (MI) where fellow Notre Dame coach was the Athletic Director. He was hired to coach the Jackrabbits in the summer of 2011.[5] After coaching the Jackrabbits to a 136–144–1 record over the past 5 seasons, on July 5, 2016, he was hired to be the head coach of Butler University within the Big East conference.[1] Retired from coaching on 5/21/22
Below is a table of Schrage's yearly records as a head baseball coach.[9][10][11][12][13]
(Gray)</small>"},"postseason":{"wt":"Mid-Con Tournament"}},"i":4}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB Yearly Record Subhead","href":"./Template:CBB_Yearly_Record_Subhead"},"params":{"name":{"wt":"[[Northern Iowa Panthers baseball|Northern Iowa Panthers]]"},"conference":{"wt":"[[Missouri Valley Conference]]"},"startyear":{"wt":"1992"},"endyear":{"wt":"1999"}},"i":5}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[1992 NCAA Division I baseball season|1992]]"},"name":{"wt":"Northern Iowa"},"overall":{"wt":"22–34"},"conference":{"wt":"2–17"},"confstanding":{"wt":"8th"},"postseason":{"wt":""}},"i":6}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[1993 NCAA Division I baseball season|1993]]"},"name":{"wt":"Northern Iowa"},"overall":{"wt":"12–39"},"conference":{"wt":"1–20"},"confstanding":{"wt":"8th"},"postseason":{"wt":""}},"i":7}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[1994 NCAA Division I baseball season|1994]]"},"name":{"wt":"Northern Iowa"},"overall":{"wt":"24–32"},"conference":{"wt":"5–16"},"confstanding":{"wt":"T-7th"},"postseason":{"wt":""}},"i":8}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[1995 NCAA Division I baseball season|1995]]"},"name":{"wt":"Northern Iowa"},"overall":{"wt":"24–32"},"conference":{"wt":"12–20"},"confstanding":{"wt":"T-7th"},"postseason":{"wt":""}},"i":9}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[1996 NCAA Division I baseball season|1996]]"},"name":{"wt":"Northern Iowa"},"overall":{"wt":"26–32"},"conference":{"wt":"13–19"},"confstanding":{"wt":"6th"},"postseason":{"wt":"MVC Tournament"}},"i":10}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[1997 NCAA Division I baseball season|1997]]"},"name":{"wt":"Northern Iowa"},"overall":{"wt":"32–23"},"conference":{"wt":"18–8"},"confstanding":{"wt":"2nd"},"postseason":{"wt":"MVC Tournament"}},"i":11}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[1998 NCAA Division I baseball season|1998]]"},"name":{"wt":"Northern Iowa"},"overall":{"wt":"26–30"},"conference":{"wt":"9–22"},"confstanding":{"wt":"8th"},"postseason":{"wt":""}},"i":12}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[1999 NCAA Division I baseball season|1999]]"},"name":{"wt":"Northern Iowa"},"overall":{"wt":"28–26"},"conference":{"wt":"13–17"},"confstanding":{"wt":"7th"},"postseason":{"wt":""}},"i":13}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record subtotal","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_subtotal"},"params":{"name":{"wt":"Northern Iowa"},"overall":{"wt":"211–292"},"confrecord":{"wt":"74–148"}},"i":14}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB Yearly Record Subhead","href":"./Template:CBB_Yearly_Record_Subhead"},"params":{"name":{"wt":"[[Northern Illinois Huskies baseball|Northern Illinois Huskies]]"},"conference":{"wt":"[[Mid-American Conference]]"},"startyear":{"wt":"2000"},"endyear":{"wt":"2002"}},"i":15}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[2000 NCAA Division I baseball season|2000]]"},"name":{"wt":"Northern Illinois"},"overall":{"wt":"24–33"},"conference":{"wt":"11–15"},"confstanding":{"wt":"3rd <small>(West)</small>"},"postseason":{"wt":"MAC Tournament"}},"i":16}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[2001 NCAA Division I baseball season|2001]]"},"name":{"wt":"Northern Illinois"},"overall":{"wt":"28–27"},"conference":{"wt":"10–17"},"confstanding":{"wt":"T-5th <small>(West)</small>"},"postseason":{"wt":""}},"i":17}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[2002 NCAA Division I baseball season|2002]]"},"name":{"wt":"Northern Illinois"},"overall":{"wt":"23–32"},"conference":{"wt":"11–14"},"confstanding":{"wt":"5th <small>(West)</small>"},"postseason":{"wt":""}},"i":18}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record subtotal","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_subtotal"},"params":{"name":{"wt":"Northern Illinois"},"overall":{"wt":"75–92"},"confrecord":{"wt":"32–46"}},"i":19}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB Yearly Record Subhead","href":"./Template:CBB_Yearly_Record_Subhead"},"params":{"name":{"wt":"[[Evansville Purple Aces baseball|Evansville Purple Aces]]"},"conference":{"wt":"[[Missouri Valley Conference]]"},"startyear":{"wt":"2003"},"endyear":{"wt":"2006"}},"i":20}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[2003 NCAA Division I baseball season|2003]]"},"name":{"wt":"Evansville"},"overall":{"wt":"24–31"},"conference":{"wt":"12–20"},"confstanding":{"wt":"9th"},"postseason":{"wt":""}},"i":21}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[2004 NCAA Division I baseball season|2004]]"},"name":{"wt":"Evansville"},"overall":{"wt":"28–32"},"conference":{"wt":"12–20"},"confstanding":{"wt":"T-5th"},"postseason":{"wt":"MVC Tournament"}},"i":22}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[2005 NCAA Division I baseball season|2005]]"},"name":{"wt":"Evansville"},"overall":{"wt":"35–22"},"conference":{"wt":"12–12"},"confstanding":{"wt":"4th"},"postseason":{"wt":"MVC Tournament"}},"i":23}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":"confboth"},"season":{"wt":"[[2006 NCAA Division I baseball season|2006]]"},"name":{"wt":"Evansville"},"overall":{"wt":"43–22"},"conference":{"wt":"16–8"},"confstanding":{"wt":"1st"},"postseason":{"wt":"[[2006 NCAA Division I baseball tournament#Athens Super Regional|NCAA Regional]]"}},"i":24}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record subtotal","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_subtotal"},"params":{"name":{"wt":"Evansville"},"overall":{"wt":"130–108"},"confrecord":{"wt":"52–60"}},"i":25}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB Yearly Record Subhead","href":"./Template:CBB_Yearly_Record_Subhead"},"params":{"name":{"wt":"[[Notre Dame Fighting Irish baseball|Notre Dame Fighting Irish]]"},"conference":{"wt":"[[Big East Conference (1979–2013)|Big East Conference]]"},"startyear":{"wt":"2007"},"endyear":{"wt":"2010"}},"i":26}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[2007 NCAA Division I baseball season|2007]]"},"name":{"wt":"Notre Dame"},"overall":{"wt":"28–28"},"conference":{"wt":"11–15"},"confstanding":{"wt":"7th (12)"},"postseason":{"wt":"[[2007 Big East Conference Baseball Tournament|Big East tournament]]{{efn|The top 8 finishers of the Big East's 12 teams qualified for the tournament in 2007.}}"}},"i":27}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[2008 NCAA Division I baseball season|2008]]"},"name":{"wt":"Notre Dame"},"overall":{"wt":"33–21–1"},"conference":{"wt":"16–10"},"confstanding":{"wt":"3rd (12)"},"postseason":{"wt":"[[2008 Big East Conference Baseball Tournament|Big East tournament]]{{efn|The top 8 finishers of the Big East's 12 teams qualified for the tournament in 2008.}}"}},"i":28}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[2009 NCAA Division I baseball season|2009]]"},"name":{"wt":"Notre Dame"},"overall":{"wt":"36–23"},"conference":{"wt":"15–12"},"confstanding":{"wt":"5th (12)"},"postseason":{"wt":"[[2009 Big East Conference Baseball Tournament|Big East tournament]]{{efn|The top 8 finishers of the Big East's 12 teams qualified for the tournament in 2009.}}"}},"i":29}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[2010 NCAA Division I baseball season|2010]]"},"name":{"wt":"Notre Dame"},"overall":{"wt":"22–32"},"conference":{"wt":"10–17"},"confstanding":{"wt":"9th (12)"},"postseason":{"wt":""}},"i":30}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record subtotal","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_subtotal"},"params":{"name":{"wt":"Notre Dame"},"overall":{"wt":"119–104–1"},"confrecord":{"wt":"52–54"}},"i":31}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB Yearly Record Subhead","href":"./Template:CBB_Yearly_Record_Subhead"},"params":{"name":{"wt":"[[South Dakota State Jackrabbits baseball|South Dakota State Jackrabbits]]"},"conference":{"wt":"[[Summit League]]"},"startyear":{"wt":"2012"},"endyear":{"wt":"2016"}},"i":32}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[2012 NCAA Division I baseball season|2012]]"},"name":{"wt":"South Dakota State"},"overall":{"wt":"18–33–1"},"conference":{"wt":"7–14"},"confstanding":{"wt":"6th (7)"},"postseason":{"wt":""}},"i":33}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":"conference tournament"},"season":{"wt":"[[2013 NCAA Division I baseball season|2013]]"},"name":{"wt":"South Dakota State"},"overall":{"wt":"35–24"},"conference":{"wt":"16–10"},"confstanding":{"wt":"2nd (6)"},"postseason":{"wt":"[[2013 NCAA Division I baseball tournament#Eugene Regional|NCAA Regional]]"}},"i":34}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[2014 NCAA Division I baseball season|2014]]"},"name":{"wt":"South Dakota State"},"overall":{"wt":"28–29"},"conference":{"wt":"11–11"},"confstanding":{"wt":"2nd (5)"},"postseason":{"wt":"[[2014 Summit League Baseball Tournament|Summit tournament]]"}},"i":35}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[2015 NCAA Division I baseball season|2015]]"},"name":{"wt":"South Dakota State"},"overall":{"wt":"33–23"},"conference":{"wt":"17–11"},"confstanding":{"wt":"2nd (6)"},"postseason":{"wt":"[[2015 Summit League Baseball Tournament|Summit tournament]]"}},"i":36}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[2016 NCAA Division I baseball season|2016]]"},"name":{"wt":"South Dakota State"},"overall":{"wt":"22–35"},"conference":{"wt":"13–17"},"confstanding":{"wt":"4th (6)"},"postseason":{"wt":"[[2016 Summit League Baseball Tournament|Summit tournament]]"}},"i":37}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record subtotal","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_subtotal"},"params":{"name":{"wt":"South Dakota State"},"overall":{"wt":"136–144-1"},"confrecord":{"wt":"64–63<!-- 30–42 through end of 2021 -->"}},"i":38}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB Yearly Record Subhead","href":"./Template:CBB_Yearly_Record_Subhead"},"params":{"name":{"wt":"[[Butler Bulldogs baseball|Butler Bulldogs]]"},"conference":{"wt":"[[Big East Conference]]"},"startyear":{"wt":"2017"},"endyear":{"wt":"2022"}},"i":39}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[2017 NCAA Division I baseball season|2017]]"},"name":{"wt":"Butler"},"overall":{"wt":"31–20"},"conference":{"wt":"7–10"},"confstanding":{"wt":"5th"},"postseason":{"wt":""}},"i":40}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[2018 NCAA Division I baseball season|2018]]"},"name":{"wt":"Butler"},"overall":{"wt":"34–20"},"conference":{"wt":"9–8"},"confstanding":{"wt":"3rd"},"postseason":{"wt":""}},"i":41}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[2019 NCAA Division I baseball season|2019]]"},"name":{"wt":"Butler"},"overall":{"wt":"26–26"},"conference":{"wt":"6–11"},"confstanding":{"wt":"6th"},"postseason":{"wt":""}},"i":42}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[2020 NCAA Division I baseball season|2020]]"},"name":{"wt":"Butler"},"overall":{"wt":"8–6"},"conference":{"wt":"0–0"},"confstanding":{"wt":""},"postseason":{"wt":"Season canceled due to [[COVID-19]]"}},"i":43}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[2021 NCAA Division I baseball season|2021]]"},"name":{"wt":"Butler"},"overall":{"wt":"14–23"},"conference":{"wt":"8–13"},"confstanding":{"wt":"7th"},"postseason":{"wt":""}},"i":44}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record entry\n","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_entry"},"params":{"championship":{"wt":""},"season":{"wt":"[[2022 NCAA Division I baseball season|2022]]"},"name":{"wt":"Butler"},"overall":{"wt":"20–35–1"},"conference":{"wt":"4–16–1"},"confstanding":{"wt":"8th"},"postseason":{"wt":""}},"i":45}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record subtotal","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_subtotal"},"params":{"name":{"wt":"Butler"},"overall":{"wt":"133–130-1 <!-- 133-130-1through 5/21/22 -->"},"confrecord":{"wt":"34–58-1<!-- 34-58-1 through 5/21/22 -->"}},"i":46}},"\n",{"template":{"target":{"wt":"CBB yearly record end","href":"./Template:CBB_yearly_record_end"},"params":{"overall":{"wt":"804–870–3<!--804–870–3 through 5/21/22-->"}},"i":47}}]}'>
National champion
Postseason invitational champion
Conference regular season champion
Conference regular season and conference tournament champion
Division regular season champion
Division regular season and conference tournament champion
Conference tournament champion
↑The top 8 finishers of the Big East's 12 teams qualified for the tournament in 2007.
↑The top 8 finishers of the Big East's 12 teams qualified for the tournament in 2008.
↑The top 8 finishers of the Big East's 12 teams qualified for the tournament in 2009.