Writing a Counter object to a CSV-file in Python 3

Question

In Python 3.4, a Counter object called cnt like this:

Counter({'0200': 3, '3000': 2, '3011': 2, '0210': 1, '4000': 1}) 

is to be written to a comma-separated file.

I first tried with CSV and DictWriter that I had not used before, but I kept getting misty errors and was pressed for time, so I decided to make this simple version (it works):

outfile = infile[:-4] + '_freq.csv' 
fp = open(outfile, encoding='utf-8-sig', mode='w') 
fp.write('KMC|freq\n') 
for tag, count in cnt.items(): 
 fp.write('{}|{}\n'.format(tag, count)) 
fp.close() 

Then when I had some time I felt I should learn to use DictWriter and CSV, assuming it'd be 'better' or 'more pythonic'.

That turned into this (works too):

outfile2 = infile[:-4] + '_freq2.csv' 
with open(outfile2, encoding='utf-8-sig', mode='w', newline='') as f:
 # Note: empty newline to avoid blank lines in the output file 
 fieldnames = ['KMC', 'freq'] 
 writer = csv.DictWriter(f, fieldnames=fieldnames, delimiter='|') 
 writer.writeheader() 
 for tag, count in cnt.items(): 
 writer.writerow({'KMC': tag, 'freq': str(count)}) 

The trick with the empty newline to avoid blank lines is from here.

I like the first approach better. I think CSV and DictWriter are intended for much larger amounts of columns than the two small ones I got. But I'm no expert.

Any learned comments?

Answer 1

Simplicity

I think that, for an easy task like this, the first version is better as it is considerably simpler while accomplishing the same goal.

It can still be improved though:

Cleaner deletion of file extension

infile[:-4] is probably used to remove the extension from the file, but it is not obvious, I suggest infile.replace(".txt","")( where the extension may be different from txt but you get the idea).

Context managing

It is so easy to forget to close a file, it is better to use with that will close it automatically every time:

with open(outfile, encoding='utf-8-sig', mode='w') as fp:
fp.write('KMC|freq\n') 
for tag, count in cnt.items(): 
 fp.write('{}|{}\n'.format(tag, count)) 

Naming

cnt is a mysterious name, I have no idea what kind of data it may contain, I suggest coming up with a better name.