To: J3 08-195
From: Stan Whitlock
Subject: Minutes of meeting #184
Date: 21 June 2008
Minutes of INCITS/PL22.3 Committee Meeting #184
formerly known as INCITS/J3
Emerald Suites, Las Vegas, Nevada USA
May 12-16, 2008
Note: J3 has been renamed from INCITS/J3 to INCITS/PL22.3. In
these minutes, the committee will be referred to as J3.
0. List of papers passed at meeting #184
This is a list of the paper numbers that passed at meeting
#184, including interpretations. The reference is to the
latest revision on the J3 server after the meeting, not to
the actual revision that was voted upon. The motions below
reference the actual revision voted upon.
08-143r3 08-159r1 08-175 0081 08-186r1 0112
08-144r2 08-161 08-176 0082 S2 08-187 0076 S2
08-147r1 08-162r2 08-178 08-188r1 0073
08-148r1 08-165r1 08-179r1 08-189r1 0071
08-152r2 08-166r1 08-180r1 08-190r1 0074
08-153r3 08-168r2 08-181 08-191r1 0075
08-154r1 08-171 0102 08-182r1 0049 08-192r1 0087
08-156r2 08-172 0074 08-183 0098 08-193
08-157r2 08-173 0117 08-184r1
08-158 08-174r1 0081 08-185r1
The 4-digit number after a paper number indicates an F03/ interp
number. "S2" means only section 2 passed.
The interpretations passed by this meeting were:
interp F95/0074 == 08-172 interp F03/0081 == 08-175
F95/0102 =わ=わ 08-ひく171 0086 =わ=わ 08-ひく176 S2
F03/0071 =わ=わ 08-ひく189 0087 =わ=わ 08-ひく192r1
0073 =わ=わ 08-ひく188r1 0089 == 08-182r1
0074 =わ=わ 08-ひく190r1 0098 =わ=わ 08-ひく183
0075 =わ=わ 08-ひく191r1 0112 == 08-186r1
0076 =わ=わ 08-ひく187 S2 0115 == 08-151 withdrawn
0077 == 08-174r1 0117 =わ=わ 08-ひく173
1. Monday, May 12, 2008 8:00 AM
--------------------------------
/J3
The J3 meeting (#184) was called to order at 8:00 AM, Monday,
May 12, 2008, at the Emerald Suites, Las Vegas, NV, USA,
by the J3 chair, Dan Nagle.
1.1 Opening business D. Nagle
The Chairman welcomed everyone.
1.1.1 Remarks from the chair D. Nagle
Dan said the major work for this meeting was to resolve comments
on the current draft Fortran 2008, 07-007r2, to start creating
the US position on F2008, and to continue answering
interpretations.
1.1.2 Adoption of agenda D. Nagle
** motion: Adopt the agenda as amended (moved by Van Snyder/
seconded by Michael Ingrassia): passed by unanimous
consent {uc}
1.1.3 Approval of Meeting 183 minutes D. Nagle
** motion: Approve paper 08-139, the minutes of meeting #183
(Whitlock/Long): uc
1.1.4 INCITS/SDB report (if any) D. Nagle
PL22 had an organizational meeting and adopted new standard
operating procedures. All existing task groups {including
J3} were grandfathered to retain their previous powers,
including the ability to approve US positions on international
questions.
Dan will become a member of PL22.
The US public comment period on the draft F2008 is June 6 -
July 7, 2008.
J3 needs to formalize its liaison list. See closing business.
PL22 accepted the list of proposed emeritus members:
At the April 2008 meeting of the INCITS Executive Board, the
INCITS/J3 nominations of the following persons for emeritus
membership on INCITS/J3 were reviewed and approved:
Keith Bierman
Walt Brainerd
Kurt Hirchert
Tom Lahey
Richard Maine
Loren Meissner
Mallory North
Brian Smith
Jerry Wagener
J3 expressed its thanks to INCITS for naming these emeritus
members.
1.1.5 OWG-V report (if any) D. Nagle
The draft is done and is in editorial review. It is called
N0125 and will probably be out next year. Dan would like
help creating a Fortran appendix that would be like sections
6 and 7, written in Fortran. The draft is under the Documents
tab in the left pane at
www.aitcnet.org/isai
1.1.6 ISO/WG5 report Van Snyder, IR
The last J3 meeting, #183, was joint with WG5. It went well.
The next WG5 meeting is a joint meeting with J3 in Tokyo in
November, 2008.
1.1.7 J11 Liaison report (if any) C. Rasmussen
Nothing new to report on J11.
Craig reported on MPI. He is working with a group to fix the
Fortran bindings to MPI.
1.1.8 H2 Liaison report (if any) D. Nagle
Nothing new to report.
We need to decide if J3 wants to keep a liaison with H2 about
SQL. The sentiment was no. See closing business.
1.1.9 IEEE 754 report (if any) M. Ingrassia
The latest ballot is complete - there are no changes. The
revision is on track to be accepted.
Van reported on IFIP Working Group 2.5 on Numerical
Software. This group was unsuccessful at getting interval
arithmetic into IEEE 754. So they started a new effort to
create a separate IEEE standard for interval arithmetic and
"complete" arithmetic.
1.1.10 Treasurer's report V. Snyder
The ending balance at the previous meeting was 1991ドル.76 .
There is a 50ドル meeting fee starting with meeting 184.
1.1.11 Beginning membership report S. Whitlock
Total Membership at beginning of Meeting 184 9
Majority 5
Quorum 4
members alternates
M. Ingrassia
S. Kokrady S. Kohli
B. Long J. Brixius
J. Martin M. Cohen
D. Nagle A. Donev & J. Wallen
C. Rasmussen
V. Snyder R. Maine
S. Whitlock L. Menard & S. Lionel
J. Xia K. Li
No one is in jeopardy of losing membership because of not
attending 2 of the last 3 meetings.
HP {S. Kokrady} is in jeopardy of losing membership because
of missing 2 of the last 3 letter ballots.
Attendance - J3 members present:
M. Ingrassia
B. Long
J. Martin
D. Nagle
C. Rasmussen
V. Snyder
S. Whitlock
J. Xia
J3 alternates present:
Malcolm Cohen (alternate for J. Martin - present)
Lorri Menard (alternate for S. Whitlock - present)
1.1.12 Local arrangements D. Nagle
Bill Long is acting local host and will provide supplies as
requested.
We are rotating hosts: Jeanne Martin will host J3 meeting #185
in Aug-2008.
1.1.13 Comments from members
No comments from members were recorded.
1.2 Subgroup organization D. Nagle
J3 is divided into its usual three subgroups, /JOR, /DATA, and
/HPC, to work on comments against 08-007r2.
Everyone should read: N1727 draft F2003 corrigendum 3
N1728 interps for F2003 corrigendum 3
Papers below suffixed with "C" contain non-J3 comments.
/JOR Whitlock (head), Nagle, Menard
initial papers: 150, 153C, 154C, 159, 161
/DATA Cohen (head), Snyder, Ingrassia, Martin
initial papers: 144, 146, 147C, 156, 157, 165, 166, 170
/HPC Long (head), Rasmussen, Xia
initial papers: 143r1, 148, 152r1, 158, 162, 168C
/EDIT Cohen (head)
initial papers: 145, 149, 160
/interp Whitlock (head), Cohen
initial papers: 151 interp F03/0111
155 WG5 ballot 4 results
163 J3 letter ballot #16 results
164 WG5 ballot 5 results
169 interp F03/0116
171 0102
172 0074
1.3 Subgroup meetings (9:06 AM)
1.4 Subgroup reports (4:30 PM)
/J3
Edits and corrections to F2008 08-007r2 will be in standing
document 019 and become part of J3's public comment.
Suggestions for new features that are accepted by J3 will be
in standing document 020 and become part of J3's public
comment.
The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later in
the week was discussed.
Recessed at 4:53 PM
2. Tuesday, May 13, 2008 8:00 AM
---------------------------------
2.1 F2008 Plenary (00-010) Subgroup Heads
/JOR
** motion: 08-159 "Generic I/O procs unspecified?" [Long] as
amended {Whitlock/Ingrassia}: uc {there will be an
r1 revision paper in the post meeting papers}
** motion: 08-161 "dtio-generic-spec" [Long] {Whitlock/Cohen}:
uc
paper 08-150 "dtio-generic-spec" [Snyder]
straw vote {SV}: pursue the change in 08-150 to ?
yes-no-undecided: 0-9-1
no further action will be taken on 08-150
paper 08-153 "Another processor dependency" [Snyder]
SV: add "processor dependent" to section 6.6.3.2?
yes-no-undecided: 9-0-1
paper will be improved and brought back
/DATA
** motion: 08-144r1 "Statement functions in BLOCK constructs?"
[Snyder] {Cohen/Snyder} as amended: uc {post r2}
There will be no action taken on paper 08-146 "Constraints
C1213-C1215" [Snyder]
/HPC
** motion: 08-143r2 "Comment: to disallow coindexed object as a
data-ref in procedure-designator [Xia/Long] (Long/Xia):
withdrawn
** motion: 08-148r1 "VALUE attribute for coarrays?" [Snyder/Long]
(Long/Rasmussen): uc
** motion: 08-152r2 "Stuff related to coarrays" [Snyder/Long]
(Long/Rasmussen): 7-1 passes
** motion: 08-158 "Allocatable coarrays with intent(out)" [Long/
Reid] (Long/Rasmussen): uc
** motion: 08-162r1 "Comment: allocatable coarray and non-coarray
allocatable dummy" [Xia/Long] (Long/Xia): withdrawn
/INTERP
** motion: 08-171 "Interp F95/0102" [Malcolm] interpreted in the
context of F2003 (Whitlock/Cohen): uc
** motion: 08-172 "Interp F95/0074" [Malcolm] interpreted in the
context of F2003 (Whitlock/Cohen): uc
/EDIT
Paper 08-018r1 "Interpretation Update Pages: Standing
Document 018 (08-018r1)" [Cohen] has change pages to F2003
04-007 for corrigenda 1 and 2.
Paper 08-177 "Interpretation Update Pages: Changes to
Standing Document 018" [Cohen] has change pages to F2003
04-007 for draft corrigendum 3.
2.2 Tutorials (if needed)
Craig Rasmussen gave a tutorial with slides about the technical
issues uncovered with a Fortran binding for MPI 3.0.
2.3 Subgroup meetings (10:00 AM)
2.4 Subgroup reports (4:30 PM)
/DATA
Paper 08-170 "Reducing duplication concerning subscripts"
[Snyder] has one edit (to page 119) that will be sent to /EDIT.
No further processing of 08-170 will be done.
/J3
The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later in
the week was discussed.
Recessed at 5:00 PM
3. Wednesday, May 14, 2008 8:00 AM
-----------------------------------
3.1 F2008 Plenary Subgroup Heads
/JOR
** motion: 08-153r2 "Another processor dependency" [Snyder/
Whitlock] (Whitlock/Snyder) as amended: uc {post r3}
/DATA
** motion: 08-156r1 "Attributes, especially the EXTERNAL attribute"
[Snyder] (Cohen/Snyder): withdrawn
** motion: 08-157r1 "Even more editorial stuff" [Snyder] (Cohen/
Snyder) as amended: uc {post r2}
** motion: 08-179 "Problems in 12.5.5.3" [Snyder] (Cohen/Snyder)
as amended: uc {post r1}
** motion: 08-180 "Problems in 4.5.4.1" [Snyder] (Cohen/Snyder)
as amended: uc {post r1}
paper 08-178 "Premature public comment concerning generic
interfaces" [Snyder]
SV: pursue new feature in 08-178? yes-no-undecided: 8-1-0
** motion: 08-178 (Cohen/Rasmussen): uc
/HPC
** motion: 08-162r2 "Comment: allocatable coarray and non-coarray
allocatable dummy" [Xia/Long] (Long/Cohen): uc
/INTERP
** motion: 08-173 F03/0117 "Reconsideration of interp F90/000209"
[Cohen] (Whitlock/Cohen): 7-1 passes
/DATA
paper 08-147 "Premature public comment: VALUE attribute" [Snyder]
SV: pursue the feature in 08-147 without pointer and
allocatable? yes-no-undecided: 3-2-5
paper 08-165 "Copy in/out and ASYNCHRONOUS/VOLATILE dummies"
[Donev]
SV: ease restriction as described in 08-165? yes-no-undecided:
7-1-2
paper 08-166 "Guaranteed no copy in/out and TARGET" [Donev]
SV: pursue new feature in 08-166?
(1) status quo (ie, processor dependent) or
(2) simply contiguous or
(3) run-time contiguous or
(4) undecided
0-5-4-1
After further discussion, simply contiguous accepted uc
paper 08-181 "VALUE alone for pure procedure dummy arguments"
[Snyder]
SV: pursue new feature in 08-181? yes-no-undecided: 10-0-0
** motion: 08-181 (Cohen/Snyder): uc
/EDIT
a draft of 08-019 "Cumulative edits for corrections to the
current 007" [Cohen] is ready for examination.
/J3
What does J3 tell MPI?
SV: pursue new feature to suppress argument checking as
described in the MPI Forum slides? yes-no-undecided:
9-0-1
SV: (1) should this new feature be put into F2008 or
(2) should it be put in the Interop TR or
(3) undecided
0-9-1
** motions: How should the new feature be spelled?
(1) C_VOID intrinsic type? 0-9 => rejected
(2) type (C_VOID) in ISO_C_BINDING? 7-3
(3) IGNORE (TKR) attribute? 7-2
(4) CLASS (*)? 0-7 => rejected
(5) TYPE (*) and use assumed shape to override rank?
4-2
Use of the VOLATILE, ASYNCHRONOUS, and TARGET attributes to
protect MPI buffers from overly aggressive optimizations was
discussed but no votes were taken.
3.2 Tutorials (if needed) - none
3.3 Subgroup meetings (11:45 AM)
3.4 Subgroup reports (4:30 PM)
/INTERP
paper 08-155 "Interpretation results from WG5 ballot 4 - N1711
& N1721" [Whitlock] and 08-163 "Results of the J3 interp letter
ballot #16" [Whitlock] will have no action taken on them.
Interp F03/0115 in paper 08-151 "Interpretation request concerning
specification" [Snyder] has been withdrawn. The interp number will
not be reused.
/EDIT
Some edits in paper 08-145 "Editorial comments" [Snyder] were
accepted.
All of the edits in 08-149 "More editorial comments (see also
08-145)" [Snyder] were rejected.
The edit in 08-160 "Obsolete text in Note 4.50" [Snyder] was
accepted.
/J3
The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later in
the week was discussed.
Recessed at 4:44 PM
4. Thursday, May 15, 2008 8:00 AM
----------------------------------
4.1 F2008 Plenary Subgroup Heads
/JOR
** motion: 08-154r1 "Loosening a restriction in use of submodules"
[Bader/Whitlock] (Whitlock/Long): uc
** motion: 08-184 "Minor fix for CMPLX" [Whitlock] (Whitlock/
Cohen) as amended: uc {post r1}
/DATA
paper 08-147r1 "Public comment: VALUE attribute" [Snyder]
SV: pursue new feature in 08-147r1? yes-no-undecided: 8-1-1
** motion: 08-147r1 (Cohen/Snyder): 7-1 passes
** motion: 08-165r1 "Restrictions on ASYNCHRONOUS/VOLATILE dummy
arguments" [Cohen] (Cohen/Ingrassia): uc
** motion: 08-166r1 "Contiguous TARGET dummy arguments" [Cohen]
(Cohen/Whitlock): uc
/HPC
** motion: 08-185 "Request for new features from MPI Forum"
[Rasmussen] (Long/Xia) as amended: uc {post r1}
paper 08-168r1 "Adding locks to the co-array core subset"
[Long/Donev]
SV: pursue new feature in 08-168r1? yes-no-undecided: 9-0-1
there will be no action taken on companion paper 08-167 "Reply
to J3/08-126" [Long]
/INTERP
** motion: 08-174 "Interp F03/0077" [Cohen] as amended (Whitlock/
Cohen): uc {post r1}
** motion: 08-175 "Interp F03/0081" [Cohen] (Whitlock/Cohen): uc
paper 08-176 "Interp F03/0082" [Cohen]
SV: (1) take the answer in section 2 or
(2) take the answer and edit in section 3 {an F2008 change
will be needed} or
(3) undecided
4-5-1 {support was strong for (1) and week for (2)
** motion: 08-176 section 2 answer (Whitlock/Cohen): uc {Section 2
will appear in the 006A}
** motion: 08-182 "Interp F03/0049" [Cohen] (Whitlock/Cohen) as
amended: uc {post r1}
** motion: 08-183 "Interp F03/0098" [Cohen] (Whitlock/Cohen): uc
** motion: 08-186 "New answer for F2003 interp F03/0112" [Whitlock]
(Whitlock/Cohen) as amended: uc {post r1}
** motion: J3 agrees with the contents of WG5 paper N1727 "DRAFT
TECHNICAL CORRIGENDUM 3" (Whitlock/Cohen): uc
4.2 TAG meeting (10:15) Van Snyder, IR
4.3 Tutorials (if needed) - none
4.4 Subgroup meetings (10:40 AM)
4.5 Subgroup reports (4:30 pm)
/DATA
** motion: 08-156r2 "Attributes, especially the EXTERNAL attribute"
[Cohen] (Cohen/Snyder): uc
/J3
The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later in
the week was discussed.
closing business was begun early
5.1 Closing business
** motion: J3 should drop its liaison with H2 {SQL} (Whitlock/
Snyder): uc
The following liaisons will be dropped:
Dan Nagle, liaison with H2
Mike Ingrassia, liaison with IEEE/SA 754r
The following liaisons are active:
Van Snyder, liaison with IFIP WG2.5 on Numerical Software
Craig Rasmussen, liaison with programming language C
Craig Rasmussen, liaison with the MPI Forum
Dan Nagle, liaison with OWG-V
Dan Nagle, liaison with the UPC Consortium
5.3 Future meetings V. Snyder
Meeting #186 is November 16 - 21, 2008, in Tokyo, Japan,
joint with WG5, Masayuki Takata, acting host
Meeting 187 is February 9 - 13, 2009, in Las Vegas, NV,
Dan Nagle, acting host
See Appendix C for details of future meetings.
5.4 Treasurer's report V. Snyder
12 May 08 Opening balance 1991.76
12 May 08 Meeting 184 fees 500.00
14 May 08 Office supplies -48.48
15 May 08 Meeting expenses -163.23
15 May 08 Closing balance 2380.05
Outstanding obligations:
None
See 08-194 for the detailed Treasurer's Report
5.5 Closing membership report S. Whitlock
Of 9 principal members:
8 were present
0 voting alternate was present
2 non-voting alternates were present
0 visitors were present
Membership changes since last meeting:
M. Van Waveren/T. Moene are no longer members of J3 because
of lack of payment of INCITS dues.
HP is in jeopardy of losing membership because of not
attending 2 of the last 3 meetings.
HP is in jeopardy of losing membership because of missing 2
of the last 3 letter ballots.
See appendix E for the detailed membership summary.
/J3
** resolution: J3 thanks John Reid for his service as WG5 convener
and is pleased that he is applying for another term
(Snyder/Ingrassia): unanimous acclaim
Recessed at 4:59 PM
5. Friday, May 16, 2008 8:00 AM
--------------------------------
/J3
** motion: 08-193 "Public Comment Procedures" [Nagle] (Snyder/
Ingrassia): uc
/HPC
** motion: 08-143r3 "Comment: to disallow coindexed object as a
data-ref in procedure-designator" [Xia/Long] (Long/
Xia): uc
** motion: 08-168r2 "Adding locks to the co-array core subset"
[Long/Donev] (Long/Xia): uc
/INTERP
** motion: 08-187 "Interp F03/0076" [Snyder] section 2 (Whitlock/
Snyder): uc
** motion: 08-188 "Interp F03/0073" [Snyder] (Whitlock/Snyder) as
amended: uc {post r1}
** motion: 08-189 "Interp F03/0071" [Cohen] (Whitlock/Ingrassia) as
amended: uc {post r1}
** motion: 08-190 "Interp F03/0074" [Cohen] (Whitlock/Snyder) as
amended: uc {post r1}
** motion: 08-191 "Interp F03/0075" [Snyder] (Whitlock/Snyder) as
amended: uc {post r1}
** motion: 08-192 "Interp F03/0087" [Snyder] (Whitlock/Snyder) as
amended: uc {post r1}
5.1 Closing business (continued from Thursday)
/J3
J3 thanked the meeting host, Bill Long
5.6 Comments from members
No comments from members were recorded.
** motion: adjourn meeting #184 (Nagle/Whitlock): uc
J3 Adjournment at 8:46 AM, May 16, 2008
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Appendix A: Final Agenda for J3 Meeting 184
----------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Monday, May 12, 2008 8:00 am
-------------------------------------
1.1 Opening business D. Nagle
Remarks from the chair D. Nagle
Adoption of agenda D. Nagle
Approval of Meeting 183 minutes D. Nagle
NCITS/OMC report (if any) D. Nagle
OWG-V report (if any) D. Nagle
ISO/WG5 report Van Snyder, IR
J11 Liaison report (if any) C. Rasmussen
H2 Liaison report (if any) D. Nagle
IEEE 754 report (if any) M. Ingrassia
Treasurer's report V. Snyder
Beginning membership report S. Whitlock
Local arrangements D. Nagle
Comments from members
1.2 Tutorials (if needed)
1.3 Subgroup organization D. Nagle
1.4 Subgroup meetings
1.5 Subgroup reports (4:30 pm)
2. Tuesday, May 13, 2008 8:00 am
--------------------------------------
2.1 F2008 Plenary (00-010) Subgroup Heads
2.2 Tutorials (if needed)
2.3 Subgroup meetings
2.4 Subgroup reports (4:30 pm)
3. Wednesday, May 14, 2008 8:00 am
----------------------------------------
3.1 F2008 Plenary Subgroup Heads
3.2 Tutorials (if needed)
3.3 Subgroup meetings
3.4 Subgroup reports (4:30 pm)
4. Thursday, May 15, 2008 8:00 am
---------------------------------------
4.1 F2008 Plenary Subgroup Heads
4.2 TAG meeting (10:15) Van Snyder, IR
4.3 Tutorials (if needed)
4.4 Subgroup meetings
4.5 Subgroup reports (4:30 pm)
5. Friday, May 16, 2008 8:00 am
--------------------------------------
5.1 Closing business
5.2 Review of action items (if any)
5.3 Future meetings V. Snyder
5.4 Treasurer's report V. Snyder
5.5 Closing membership report S. Whitlock
5.6 Comments from members
Adjournment
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Appendix B: J3 REGISTER OF DOCUMENTS FOR 2008
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
PAPERS SUBMITTED FOR J3 MEETING 184
LAS VEGAS, NEVADA, May 12 - 16, 2008
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Paper Number Date Submitter Title
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
J3/08-001r1 080423 Whitlock Membership List
txt
J3/08-001r2 080519 Whitlock Membership List
txt
J3/08-006Ar1 080428 Whitlock Outstanding Fortran Interpretations
txt
J3/08-007r2 080311 Cohen Committee Draft
pdf
J3/08-018 080513 Cohen Interpretation Update Pages
pdf
J3/08-139 080220 Whitlock Draft 183 Minutes
txt
J3/08-140 080226 Cohen Editor's Report for 08-007r1
txt
J3/08-141 080307 Whitlock J3 Fortran interp letter ballot #16 -
txt
J3/08-142 080310 Cohen Editor's Report for N1723 (08-007r1).
txt
J3/08-142r1 080311 Cohen Editor's Report for N1723 (08-007r2).
txt
J3/08-143 080325 Xia Comment: to disallow coindexed object
txt
J3/08-143r1 080428 Xia Comment: to disallow coindexed object
txt
J3/08-143r2 080512 Xia/Long Comment: to disallow coindexed object
txt
J3/08-143r3 080515 Xia/Long Comment: to disallow coindexed object
txt
J3/08-144 080411 Snyder Statement functions in BLOCK construct
txt
J3/08-144r1 080511 Snyder Statement functions in BLOCK construct
txt
J3/08-144r2 080513 Cohen Statement functions in BLOCK construct
txt
J3/08-145 080411 Snyder Editorial comments
txt
J3/08-146 080411 Snyder Constraints C1213-C1215
txt
J3/08-147 080414 Snyder Premature public comment: VALUE attrib
txt
J3/08-147r1 080513 Snyder Premature public comment: VALUE attrib
txt
J3/08-148 080414 Snyder VALUE attribute for coarrays?
txt
J3/08-148r1 080512 Snyder/Long VALUE attribute for coarrays?
txt
J3/08-149 080414 Snyder More editorial comments (see also 08-1
txt
J3/08-150 080414 Snyder Premature public comment: BLOCK constr
txt
J3/08-151 080414 Snyder Interpretation request concerning spec
txt
J3/08-151r1 080515 Snyder/Whitlo Interpretation request concerning spec
txt
J3/08-152 080414 Snyder Stuff related to coarrays
txt
J3/08-152r1 080429 Snyder Stuff related to coarrays
txt
J3/08-152r2 080512 Snyder/Long Stuff related to coarrays
txt
J3/08-153 080414 Snyder Another processor dependency
txt
J3/08-153r1 080512 Snyder/Whitlo Another processor dependency
txt
J3/08-153r2 080513 Snyder/Whitlo Another processor dependency
txt
J3/08-153r3 080514 Snyder/Whitlo Another processor dependency
txt
J3/08-154 080419 Bader Loosening a restriction in use of subm
txt
J3/08-154r1 080514 Bader/Whitlo Loosening a restriction in use of subm
txt
J3/08-155 080421 Whitlock Interpretation results from WG5 ballot
txt
J3/08-156 080423 Snyder Attrributes, especially the EXTERNAL a
txt
J3/08-156r1 080512 Snyder Attrributes, especially the EXTERNAL a
txt
J3/08-156r2 080515 Cohen Attrributes, especially the EXTERNAL a
txt
J3/08-157 080423 Snyder Even more editorial stuff
txt
J3/08-157r1 080513 Snyder Even more editorial stuff
txt
J3/08-157r2 080514 Snyder Even more editorial stuff
txt
J3/08-158 080425 Long and John Allocatable coarrays with intent(out)
txt
J3/08-159 080425 Long Generic I/O procs unspecified?
txt
J3/08-159r1 080513 Long Generic I/O procs unspecified?
txt
J3/08-160 080425 Long Obsolete text in Note 4.50
txt
J3/08-161 080425 Long dtio-generic-spec
txt
J3/08-162 080425 Xia Comment: allocatable coarray and non-c
txt
J3/08-162r1 080512 Xia/Long Comment: allocatable coarray and non-c
txt
J3/08-162r2 080513 Xia/Long Comment: allocatable coarray and non-c
txt
J3/08-163 080427 Whitlock Results of the J3 interp letter ballot
txt
J3/08-164 080427 Whitlock Interpretation results from WG5 ballot
txt
J3/08-164r1 080515 Whitlock Interpretation results from WG5 ballot
txt
J3/08-165 080428 Donev Copy in/out and ASYNCHRONOUS/VOLATILE
txt
J3/08-165r1 080514 Cohen Restrictions on ASYNCHRONOUS/VOLATILE
txt
J3/08-166 080428 Donev Guaranteed no copy in/out and TARGET
txt
J3/08-166r1 080514 Cohen Contiguous TARGET dummy arguments
txt
J3/08-167 080428 Long Reply to J3/08-126
txt
J3/08-168 080428 Long, Aleksan Adding locks to the co-array core subs
txt
J3/08-168r1 080514 Long/Donev Adding locks to the co-array core subs
txt
J3/08-168r2 080515 Long/Donev Adding locks to the co-array core subs
txt
J3/08-169 080429 Ingrassia interp request: indistinguishable spec
txt
J3/08-170 080507 Snyder Reducing duplication concerning subscr
txt
J3/08-171 080509 Cohen Interp F95/0102
txt
J3/08-172 080509 Cohen Interp F95/0074
txt
J3/08-173 080513 Cohen Reconsideration of interp F90/000209.
txt
J3/08-174 080513 Cohen Interp F03/0077
txt
J3/08-174r1 080514 Cohen Interp F03/0077
txt
J3/08-175 080513 Cohen Interp F03/0081
txt
J3/08-176 080513 Cohen Interp F03/0082
txt
J3/08-177 080513 Cohen Interpretation Update Pages: Changes t
pdf
J3/08-178 080513 Snyder Premature public comment concerning ge
txt
J3/08-179 080513 Snyder Problems in 12.5.5.3
txt
J3/08-179r1 080514 Snyder Problems in 12.5.5.3
txt
J3/08-180 080513 Snyder Problems in 4.5.4.1
txt
J3/08-180r1 080514 Snyder Problems in 4.5.4.1
txt
J3/08-181 080513 Snyder VALUE alone for pure procedure dummy a
txt
J3/08-182 080514 Cohen Interp F03/0049
txt
J3/08-182r1 080515 Cohen/Whitlo Interp F03/0049
txt
J3/08-183 080514 Cohen Interp F03/0098
txt
J3/08-184 080514 Whitlock Minor fix for CMPLX
txt
J3/08-184r1 080515 Whitlock Minor fix for CMPLX
txt
J3/08-185 080514 Rasmussen Request for new features from MPI Foru
txt
J3/08-185r1 080515 Rasmussen Request for new features from MPI Foru
txt
J3/08-186 080514 Whitlock New answer for F2003 interp F03/0112
txt
J3/08-186r1 080515 Whitlock New answer for F2003 interp F03/0112
txt
J3/08-187 080515 Snyder Interp F03/0076
txt
J3/08-188 080515 Snyder Interp F03/0073
txt
J3/08-188r1 080516 Snyder/Whitlo Interp F03/0073
txt
J3/08-189 080515 Cohen Interp F03/0071
txt
J3/08-189r1 080516 Cohen/Whitloc Interp F03/0071
txt
J3/08-190 080515 Cohen Interp F03/0071
txt
J3/08-190r1 080516 Cohen/Whitloc Interp F03/0071
txt
J3/08-191 080515 Snyder Interp F03/0075
txt
J3/08-191r1 080516 Snyder/Whitlo Interp F03/0075
txt
J3/08-192 080515 Snyder Interp F03/0087
txt
J3/08-192r1 080516 Snyder/Whitlo Interp F03/0087
txt
J3/08-193 080515 Nagle Public Comment Procedures
txt
J3/08-194 080516 Snyder Treasurer's report
txt
J3/08-195 080621 Whitlock Minutes of meeting #184
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appendix C: Future Meetings and Distribution
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Meeting Conventions:
- Four meetings per year
- Attempt to schedule second full week of the month
- Attempt to schedule meeting contiguous or simultaneous with WG5
annual meeting
Future meeting schedule:
185 August 11 - 15, 2008, in Las Vegas, NV
Jeanne Martin/Dan Nagle/Van Snyder, acting host
Pre-meeting distribution deadline: July 28, 2008
Pre-meeting distribution: electronic
Post-meeting distribution: electronic
186 November 16 - 21, 2008, in Tokyo, Japan
** joint with WG5
Masayuki Takata, acting host
Pre-meeting distribution deadline: October 27, 2008
Pre-meeting distribution: electronic
Post-meeting distribution: electronic
187 February 9 - 13, 2009, in Las Vegas, NV
Dan Nagle, acting host
Pre-meeting distribution deadline: January 26, 2009
Pre-meeting distribution: electronic
Post-meeting distribution: electronic
Committee materials availability:
Agenda and meeting notice available at the J3 web site.
Sent individually to other interested parties that specifically
request to be sent the material either via surface mail or
electronic mail.
REQUIREMENT: Distribution 4 weeks prior to meeting (SD-2 4.3.3)
Pre- and post-meeting distribution available at the J3 web site.
Sent individually to other interested parties that specifically
request to be sent the material via electronic mail.
REQUIREMENT: Distribution of premeeting 2 weeks prior to meeting.
(documents for action - two week rule: SD-2 4.3.4:1)
Meeting minutes are available at the J3 web site.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
J3 World Wide Web site URL: http://www.j3-fortran.org
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appendix D: Committee Organization
D.1 Officers and Management
Chair D. Nagle
International Rep. V. Snyder
Secretary S. Whitlock
Treasurer V. Snyder
Librarian D. Nagle
Editor M. Cohen (WG5 appointment)
Maintenance S. Whitlock
Vocabulary Rep. none
Future Meetings V. Snyder
Membership List S. Whitlock
IFIP WG2.5 Numerical Software V. Snyder
J11 Liaison - C language C. Rasmussen
OWG-V Liaison D. Nagle
MPI Forum C. Rasmussen
UPC D. Nagle
D.2 Subgroups
JOR: Responsible for the maintenance of the Journal of
Development (standing document 004)
S. Whitlock (head), D. Nagle
DATA: Responsible for language design topics related to data and
data structures
M. Cohen (head), A. Donev, J. Martin, V. Snyder
INTEROP: Responsible for interoperability with C
B. Long (head), M. Ingrassia, J. Xia
HPC: Responsible for topics in High Performance Computing
B. Long (head), M. Ingrassia, C. Rasmussen, J. Xia
INTERP: Responsible for evaluating interpretation requests,
providing responses to such requests, and maintaining
standing document 006
S. Whitlock (head), M. Cohen
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Appendix E: Membership summary
J3 Meeting Attendance (Principal Members)
Meeting # 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184
Location (state) VA NV NV NV NV NV UK NV NV NV
Date (month) 02 05 08 11 02 05 08 11 02 05
(year) 06 06 06 06 07 07 07 07 08 08
Name Affiliation
Ingrassia, M Sun V V V V V V V V V V
Kokrady, S HP V R V V A A1 V** R A A**
Long, W Cray V V V V V V V V V V
Martin, J self V V R V V V V V V V
Nagle, D self V V V V V V V V V V
Rasmussen, C LANL V A V R V V A R V V
Snyder, V JPL/Caltech V V V V V V V V V V
Whitlock, S Intel V V V V V V A V V V
Xia, J IBM V V V A A2 V** V A V V
J3 Letter Ballot Participation (Principal Members)
Meeting # 164 168 169 170 171 174 181 182 183 186
Date (month) 07 08 10 12 03 12 08 11 01 04
(year) 03 04 04 04 05 05 07 07 08 08
Name Affiliation I7 I8 I9 I10 I11 I12 I13 I14 I15 I16
Ingrassia, M Sun A V A** V V V V V V A
Kokrady, S HP V A A** V** V V1 V R A A**
Long, W Cray V V V V V V V V V V
Martin, J self V A V V V A V V V A
Nagle, D self V V V V V V V V V V
Rasmussen, C LANL E A V A** V V A V V
Snyder, V JPL/Caltech V V V V V V V V V V
Whitlock, S Intel V V V V V V V V V V
Xia, J IBM V V V V V V2 V V V V
V present and voting Voting alternates:
R absent but represented none
A absent and not represented
P present and not voting
RP represented by previous member Non-voting alternates:
E Excused M. Cohen (for J. Martin)
Q Resigned L. Menard (for S. Whitlock)
** missed 2 of last 3 meetings/votes
*** lost membership
1 S Kokrady replaced R Bleikamp as the HP representative at m181
2 J Xia replaced R James as the IBM representative at m180
Total Membership at beginning of Meeting 184 9
Majority 5
Quorum 4
Total Membership at end of Meeting 184 9
Total Members Attended or Represented at 184 8
Total Attendees at Meeting 183 10
Membership changes since last meeting:
M. Van Waveren/T. Moene are no longer members of J3 because of
lack of payment of INCITS dues.
HP is in jeopardy of losing membership because of not attending
2 of the last 3 meetings.
HP is in jeopardy of losing membership because of missing 2 of
the last 3 letter ballots.
Stan will notify S. Kokrady/S. Kohli that HP must be represented
at J3 meeting #185 or lose membership.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Appendix F: Membership Roster
The Membership Roster is not reproduced here. The current Membership
Roster may be found on the J3 web site at http://www.j3-fortran.org by
clicking on the tab "J3 Members" and then clicking on the pointer to
"full membership list".