The Talk.Origins Archive: Exploring the Creation/Evolution Controversy
Index to Creationist Claims,
edited by Mark Isaak, Copyright © 2006
Claim CI100.1:
Design is self-evident. You just need to open your eyes and see it.
Source:
Response:
- This claim lacks any substance. It is nothing more than a subjective
assertion. That design is far from self-evident is demonstrated by the
difficulty people have in trying to describe the objective evidence for
it.
- There are good reasons why people should see design that is not there.
- Humans anthropomorphize. We tend to attribute our humanlike
qualities to all sorts of things. Since design is what humans do,
we attribute it far and wide.
- Evolution and some human design both involve complex systems dealing
with the same physical constraints (Csete and Doyle 2002).
- Evolution has much in common with a design process. It generates
trial-and-error modifications of existing forms and discards the
inferior versions.
References:
- Csete, Marie E. and John C. Doyle, 2002. Reverse engineering of
biological complexity. Science 295: 1664-1669.
Further Reading:
Isaak, Mark, 2003. What design looks like.
Reports of the National Center
for Science Education 23(5-6): 25-26,31-35.
created 2003年11月29日, modified 2006年8月22日