Hugo Awards — for SF/F works, voted by members of annual World Science Fiction Convention

(1 nomination)

2002:

Meditations on Middle-Earth (St. Martin's) — related book — nomination

British Fantasy Awards — for fantasy works published in the UK, voted by British Fantasy Society members, juried since 2012

(1 nomination)

2003:

Fantasy: The Best of 2001 (Robert Silverberg & KH, eds.) (ibooks) — anthology — nomination

Locus Awards — for SF/F/H works, polled by readers of Locus Magazine

(9 nominations)

2012:

Masters of Science Fiction and Fantasy Art (Rockport) — art book — 2nd place

2006:

Fantasy: The Best of 2004 (KH & Jonathan Strahan, eds.) (ibooks) — anthology — 16th place

2006:

Science Fiction: The Best of 2004 (KH & Jonathan Strahan, eds.) (ibooks) — anthology — 15th place

2005:

Science Fiction: The Best of 2003 (KH & Jonathan Strahan, eds.) (ibooks) — anthology — 15th place

2004:

Science Fiction: The Best of 2002 (Robert Silverberg & KH, eds.) (ibooks) — anthology — 20th place

2002:

Meditations on Middle-Earth (St. Martin's) — non-fiction — 2nd place

1995:

Universe 3 (Robert Silverberg & KH, eds.) (Bantam Spectra) — anthology — 8th place

1993:

Universe 2 (Robert Silverberg & KH, eds.) (Bantam Spectra) — anthology — 4th place

1991:

Universe 1 (Robert Silverberg & KH, eds.) (Doubleday Foundation) — anthology — 4th place

Asimov's Reader Poll — for stories, poems, and art published by Asimov's, polled by readers

(1 nomination)

1991:

“3 RMS, Good View ” (Asimov's mid-Dec 1990) — short story — 3rd place

Science Fiction Age Readers Poll — for stories published in SF Age magazine, polled by readers

(1 nomination)

1998:

“Your Eyes, My Darling, Black and White and Blue ” (Science Fiction Age May 1997) — short story — 2nd place