Landscape and Urban Planning
Volume 151, July 2016, Pages 89-102
Value of urban views in a bay city: Hedonic analysis with the spatial multilevel additive regression (SMAR) model
Highlights
- •Non-linear effects of open view, ocean view, and green view, are estimated.
- •The spatial multilevel additive model is applied for a hedonic analysis.
- •Not only poor green view, but also excessive green view has a negative impact.
- •How to evaluate 3D view to trees with remotely sensed data is demonstrated.
Abstract
This paper attempts to assess the value of urban views in a bay city (Yokohama), Japan. Firstly, three types of views, open view (goodness of visibility), green view (visibility of open space), and ocean view (visibility of ocean), were quantified employing the viewshed analysis implemented on the GIS with airborne LiDAR data and 0.5 m ×ばつ 0.5 m high resolution aerial photos. Secondly, hedonic analyses were conducted to test the capitalization of value of those views into condominium prices using the spatial multilevel additive regression (SMAR) model, where possible non-linearity, multilevel structure of condominiums (unit-building), and spatial dependence were considered. This study implies that "very nice" open view (in terms of the amount of visibility) and ocean view may have a positive premium, whereas "slightly nice" open and ocean views may not. Also, a "moderate amount" of green view may raise condominium prices, but "poor" and "too much" green view may reduce condominium prices. These results indicate that the effects of views are indeed non-linear, and therefore it may be misleading to interpret the results obtained by linear models as existing studies have done.
Introduction
According to Lynch (1960) in a pioneering study of urban landscape, urban environment is perceived through human eyes as an image. Hence "value of view" may be one of the very important factors which can raise the value of a city, although neither "view" nor "value of view" is easy to quantify. After the seminal work by Rosen (1974), the hedonic approach has enjoyed a great deal of success in empirical literature to assess the value of non-market goods. The value of views, including open view (goodness of visibility), water view (visibility of water body), green view (visibility of open space), and urban view (visibility of urban elements such as streets or buildings) has also been assessed by employing this approach, and the results are nicely summarized in Bourassa, Hoesli, and Sun (2004) and Jim and Chen (2009), except for recent studies, and in Yamagata, Murakami, and Seya (2015) with the most recent results.
In the existing literature, several approaches have been taken for visibility evaluation. Some earlier studies measured visibility using a dummy variable, which takes one if a focused object is visible and zero if it is not visible (e.g., Benson, Hansen, Schwartz, & Smersh, 1998; McLeod, 1984). Other studies evaluated visibility based on field investigations. For instance, Tyrvainen and Miettinen (2000) used a field investigation to obtain the visibility information from the window of a unit of a condominium, whereas Luttik (2000) extracted such information from maps, complemented by field investigations. Clearly, both the dummy variable approach and the field investigation approach have their own limitations. That is, the former approach may suffer from an underestimation of values of high quality views and an overestimation of values of low quality views (Behrer, 2010), because the "quality" of views is not considered in this approach. Also, the latter approach may suffer from huge implementation costs if the number of required samples is fairly large.
Recent studies have employed more sophisticated visibility evaluation approaches (Yamagata et al., 2015): the isovist analysis, which has been developed mainly in architectural and urban studies (Benedikt, 1979), and the viewshed analysis, which has been developed mainly in landscape studies (Lynch, 1976). Isovist is defined as "the set of all points visible from a given vantage point in space and with respect to an environment" (Benedikt, 1979). A conventional isovist analysis evaluates views in a two dimensional (2D) space, and therefore one of the limitations of the conventional isovist analysis is ignorance of the third dimension (i.e., height)—capturing only a 2D horizontal slice of human perception (Yu, Han, & Chai, 2007; Yang, Putra, & Li, 2007). Note that, recently, some extensions that cope with this problem have been proposed (e.g., Bhatia, Chalup, & Ostwald, 2013; Morello & Ratti, 2009). On the other hand, the viewshed analysis tries to quantify a three dimensional (3D) view by examining whether each cell in a 3D raster is visible or not from an observation point. In recent years, it has gradually become possible to obtain high-resolution 3D elevation maps such as digital surface maps (DSM) and/or digital terrain maps (DTM), thus the applicability of viewshed analysis has dramatically increased (Sander and Polasky, 2009, Yu et al., 2007). However, in Japan, no studies have been conducted to quantify the "value of view", especially in urban areas, except for our preliminary study (Yamagata, Murakami, Seya, & Tsutsumi, 2013). One of the seemingly obvious reasons for this is the difficulty in obtaining high-resolution DSM data, whereas the high-resolution (5 m) digital terrain model (DTM) is easily available through "Fundamental Geospatial Data" of the Geospatial Information Authority (GSI) of Japan (http://www.gsi.go.jp/kiban/). In this study, we solved this issue by utilizing airborne LiDAR data and 0.5 m ×ばつ 0.5 m high resolution aerial photos, which was provided by the Geospatial Information Authority of Japan.
The objective of this study was as follows. In this study, we attempted to assess the value of urban views in Yokohama city, Japan. Firstly, three types of views, open view, green view, and ocean view, were quantified employing the viewshed analysis implemented on ArcGIS 10.1. Secondly, hedonic analyses were conducted to test the capitalization of value of those views into condominium prices registered from 1993 to 2008 using the spatial multilevel additive regression (SMAR) model, where possible non-linearity, multilevel structure of condominiums (unit-building), and spatial dependence were considered. This study is meaningful to encourage an effective urban landscape design with deeper understanding of the possibly non-linear influence of open views, green views, and ocean views.
The organization of this paper is as follows. Section 2 reviews previous hedonic analysis studies focusing on views employing the viewshed analysis. Section 3 describes our models for hedonic analysis. Section 4 introduces the data, followed by the empirical investigation examining the value of views, and Section 5 concludes this paper.
Section snippets
Literature review on hedonic analyses of views using the viewshed analysis
As mentioned in Section 1, the literature on hedonic analyses of views has utilized fairly manual methods to quantify views. Field investigation may provide an accurate estimation of views, but it is not easy to implement it in large scale like our city-scale case. However, it is now fairly easy to implement viewshed analysis using e.g., the ArcGIS of Environmental Systems Research Institute, Inc. (ESRI) if spatially fine DSM and/or DTM data are available. The 3D Analyst toolbox of the ArcGIS
Basic assumptions
Rosen (1974) showed that the pricing function of residence coincides with the upper envelope of the bid rent function describing the willingness of consumers to pay. He also demonstrated that, based on this coincidence, the economic values of the non-market goods, including urban views, can be quantified by estimating their impacts on the pricing function (see, e.g., Rosen (1974) and Epple (1987), for more detail).
A pricing function gives rise to a linear-regression form if goods are freely
Study area
Our study area was the seven central wards of Yokohama city (Naka, Nishi, Minami, Isogo, Hodogawa, Konan, and Tostuka wards), which is the second largest city in Japan with a population of over three million (Fig. 1). The study area is located less than thirty minutes south of the Tokyo central business district (CBD) by train.
Viewshed analysis
Visibility measures can be selected among the isovist-based (vector-based) indices, which quantify the volume of the visible space, and the viewshed-based (raster-based)
Concluding remarks
This paper attempted to assess the value of urban view in Yokohama city, Japan. Firstly, three types of views, "Open view", "Green view", and "Ocean view", were quantified employing the viewshed analysis implemented on ArcGIS with DSM/DTM, derived from airborne LiDAR data, and 0.5 m ×ばつ 0.5 m high resolution aerial photos. Secondly, hedonic analyses were conducted to test the capitalization of values of those views into condominium prices using the SMAR model, where possible non-linearity, multilevel
Acknowledgments
We thank the staff of Geospatial Information Authority of Japan, who provided us with the LiDAR data and aerial photos. We thank Dr. Simon Benger (Flinders University), Dr. Perry Yang (Georgia Institute of Technology), Dr. Morito Tsutsumi (University of Tsukuba), Dr. Masaki Mori (National University of Singapore), and Dr. Yuichiro Kawaguchi (Waseda University) for their scientific advice regarding this and other relevant studies. We also thank Drs. Hasi Bagan, Masatomo Hayashi, and Habura
References (66)
- D.M. Brasington et al.
Demand for environmental quality: a spatial hedonic analysis
Regional Science and Urban Economics
(2005) - B.C. Chamberlain et al.
A route-based visibility analysis for landscape management
Landscape and Urban Planning
(2013) - N.E. Coulson
The empirical content of the linearity-as-repackaging hypothesis
Journal of Urban Economics
(1989) - J.M. Domingo-Santos et al.
The visual exposure in forest and rural landscapes: an algorithm and a GIS tool
Landscape and Urban Planning
(2011) - A.E. Gelfand et al.
Multilevel modeling using spatial processes: application to the Singapore housing market
Computational Statistics & Data Analysis
(2007) - S.E. Hamilton et al.
Integrating lidar, GIS and hedonic price modeling to measure amenity values in urban beach residential property markets
Computers, Environment and Urban Systems
(2010) - C.Y. Jim et al.
Value of scenic views: hedonic assessment of private housing in Hong Kong
Landscape and Urban Planning
(2009) - J. Luttik
The value of trees, water and open space as reflected by house prices in the Netherlands
Landscape and Urban Planning
(2000) - H. Sander et al.
The value of views and open space: estimates from a hedonic pricing model for Ramsey County, Minnesota, USA
Land Used Policy
(2009) - H. Seya et al.
Empirical comparison of the various spatial prediction models: in spatial econometrics, spatial statistics, and semiparametric statistics
Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences
(2011)
Automatic selection of a spatial weight matrix in spatial econometrics: application to a spatial hedonic approach
Regional Science and Urban Economics
(2013)
Public preferences for biodiversity conservation and climate-change mitigation: a choice experiment using ecosystem services indicators
Land Use Policy
(2013)
Property prices and urban forest amenities
Journal of Environmental Economics and Management
(2000)
Simulating a future smart city: an integrated land use-energy model
Applied Energy
(2013)
Moderation of summertime heat-island phenomena via modification of the urban form in the Tokyo metropolitan area
Journal of Applied Meteorology and Climatology
(2014)
Spatial econometrics
Methods and models
(1988)
Spatial fixed effects and spatial dependence in a single cross-section
Papers in Regional Science
(2013)
Building in the mountains: a hedonic analysis of the value of degraded mountain views using GIS modeling. Discussion paper 2010–15
(2010)
To take hold of space: isovists and isovist fields
Environment and Planning B
(1979)
Pricing residential amenities: the value of a view
Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics
(1998)
Wayfinding: a method for the empirical evaluation of structural saliency using 3D isovists
Architectural Science Review
(2013)
Viewscapes and flood hazard: coastal housing market response to amenities and risk
Land Economics
(2008)
What’s in a view?
Environment and Planning A
(2004)
Modelling house prices using multilevel structured additive regression
Statistical Modelling
(2013)
GIS-based hedonic pricing of landscape
Environmental and Resource Economics
(2009)
The value of a floor: valuing floor level in high-rise condominiums in San Diego
International Journal of Housing Markets and Analysis
(2013)
Where is the economics in spatial econometrics?
Journal of Regional Science
(2012)
Segmenting the wine market based on price: hedonic regression when different prices mean different products
Journal of Agricultural Economics
(2007)
Spatial autoregressive models for geographically hierarchical data structures
Geographical Analysis
(2015)
Spatial openness as a practical metric for evaluating built-up environments
Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design
(2003)
Mostly pointless spatial econometrics?
Journal of Regional Science
(2012)
Predicting the scenic beauty value of mapped landscape changes in a mountainous region through the use of GIS
Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design
(2007)
Cited by (59)
Eco-gentrification and who benefits from urban green amenities: NYC's high Line
2020, Landscape and Urban PlanningEffects of floor level and landscape proximity on housing price: A hedonic analysis in Hangzhou, China
2019, Habitat InternationalAssessing CO2 emissions in China's iron and steel industry: A nonparametric additive regression approach
2017, Renewable and Sustainable Energy ReviewsMeasuring impacts of urban environmental elements on housing prices based on multisource data-a case study of Shanghai, China
2020, ISPRS International Journal of Geo InformationMultiscale geographically and temporally weighted regression: exploring the spatiotemporal determinants of housing prices
2019, International Journal of Geographical Information Science
© 2016 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.