[Robin van Spaandonk wrote:
In reply to Dr. Mitchell Swartz's message of 2009年9月29日 13:44:24 -0400:
- Hi,
- [snip]
- > Corroborating your fabrications, Jed, you have told others and us
- >that you demand to EDIT the papers.
- [snip]
- ..from the perspective of an outsider to all of this, I get the impression that
- Jed edit's papers to make them more comprehensible, however I can understand
- that some authors would object to any interference at all.
- [snip]
(but then in the next paragraph)
When I am preparing papers for a proceedings, that's another matter. ...."
[email protected]>
To: Mitchell Swartz <[email protected]>
"Mitch,
FYI -- this was a message that Rothwell posted to Vortex about a month ago:
"At LENR-CANR.org we have censored out some of the controversial claims
related to CF, such as transmuting macroscopic amounts of gold, or
biological transmutations, along with some of the extremely unconventional
theories. This is not because we (Storms and Rothwell) oppose these claims,
or because we are upset by them. It is for political reasons only. The goal
of LENR-CANR is to convince mainstream scientists that CF is real. This
goal would be hampered by presenting such extreme views. Actually, I have
no opinion about most theories, and I could not care less how weird the
data may seem. At the Scientific American and the APS they feel hostility
toward such things. They have a sense that publishing such data will harm
their readers and sully the traditions and reputation of academic science.
I am not a member of the congregation at the Church of Academic Science,
and I could not care less about the Goddess Academia's Sacred Reputation. I
don't publish because of politics and limited web space.
- Jed"
Date: 2004年3月29日
Subject: Storms/Rothwell censorship
From: "Eugene F. Mallove" <[email protected]>
"This is known as science by politics -- it is disgusting. Storms doesn't
have leg to stand on and he knows it."
- the late, great, Dr. Eugene Mallove
That said, I support, and in the past have supported, Jed and Ed in most
of their efforts, and however they want to run their site. It is their choice.