Schindler's
List (1993)
In director Steven Spielberg's (and Universal Pictures')
Best Picture-winning, unanimously-praised historical epic of the
Holocaust with crisp black and white cinematography, it was the director's
greatest dramatic masterpiece. It included stunning
and brilliant performances by the three male leads - Schindler (Liam
Nesson), Amon Goeth (Ralph Fiennes), and Itzhak Stern (Ben Kingsley).
The film was skillfully rendered with overlapping dialogue, parallel
editing, sharp and bold characterizations, contrasting compositions
of the two main characters (Schindler and Goeth), cinematographic
beauty detailing shadows and light with film-noirish tones, jerky
hand-held cameras (cinema verite), a beautifully selected and composed
musical score (including Itzhak Perlman's violin), and gripping performances.
It was based on a true story of an opportunistic German
businessman and charming womanizer Oskar Schindler (Liam Neeson),
who profited from WWII by employing cheap labor from Polish Jews
in his Krakow enamel cookware factory (the Deutsche Emailwaren Fabrik
or D.E.F.) during the Third Reich's Holocaust. He provided them with
refuge from the horrors of the Nazis. The film also documented the
hideous, disturbing evil personified by Nazi Amon Goeth (Ralph Fiennes)
- the Plaszow camp commandant, and Schindler's relationship with
his Jewish accountant Itzhak Stern (Ben Kingsley). Their list-making
courageously saved over 1,000 Jews from a senseless, brutal extermination
in Auschwitz.
The screenplay by Steven Zaillian was adapted from
Thomas Keneally's 1982 biographic novel (Schindler's Ark), constructed
by interviews with 50 Schindler survivors found in many nations,
and other wartime associates of the title character, as well as other
written testimonies and sources.
The exceptional film received 12
Academy Award nominations, including Best Actor (Liam Neeson), Best
Supporting Actor (Ralph Fiennes), Best Sound, Best Makeup, and Best
Costume Design, and won 7 Academy Awards: Best Picture, Best Director,
Best Original Musical Score (John Williams), Best Film Editing, Best
Art Direction-Set Decoration, Best Cinematography (Janusz Kaminski),
and Best (Adapted) Screenplay. With a budget of 22ドル million, the
film grossed revenues of 96ドル.9 million (domestic) and 322ドル.2 million
(worldwide).
- at the start of WWII in 1939, the defeated population
of Polish Jews (Hebrews) had been relocated by the Nazi German
forces into the Krakow Ghetto
- in the opening restaurant/cabaret
scene, set in German-occupied Poland during World War II, would-be
war profiteer Oskar Schindler (Liam Neeson), a German businessman,
wheeled and dealed his way into the pocketbooks of SS officers
in a Krakow nightclub; first, in his Krakow hotel room, the mysterious,
unknown man (not yet with his face unrevealed) dressed himself
and prepared for the evening; he pinned, in close-up, a gold, Nazi
Party button (with swastika or Hakenkreuz) on his lapel
- the slickly-dressed gentleman entered a swanky
nightclub in the Nazi-occupied city of Krakow and was seated at
a prime table; the authoritative, aristocratic-looking Oskar Schindler,
not yet identified by name, was a war profiteer
who was about to wheel and deal his way into the pocketbooks of
SS officers; he sized up the power elite to cultivate
their friendship; the gracious host purchased endless plates of
food, caviar, and French wines for the rowdy guests in his party;
Schindler's self-promotion was successful
- in the city, Schindler contacted Itzhak Stern (Ben
Kingsley), a financially-skilled official of Krakow's Judenrat
(Hebrew Council), to collaborate with him to secretly finance,
administer and run his business operation - using his contacts
in the Hebrew business community and in the black marketers [Note:
Jews could no longer own or operate their own businesses.]; Stern's
talent would be to recruit Jewish investors for capital, to provide
'free' Jewish workers (as cheap labor) from the population, and
to manage the business and financial side of the operation
- by 1941, thousands of Jewish families had been ordered
by the Nazis to move out of their residences and into a specified
area known as the Ghetto, an area of only sixteen square blocks;
Schindler was ushered in to take posession of one of the newly-vacated
apartments of a well-off Jewish family
- meanwhile, Schindler was setting up a metalworks,
cookware and enamelware factory-business (using cheap Jewish labor)
to supply the German military with basics, such as pot and pans,
door hinges, mess kits, etc.; the "essential" Jewish workers would
be saved from being sent off to concentration camps or
killed, although Stern also forged documents and provided work
certificates to rescue from extermination those who would be considered
'not essential'
- in a slightly amusing sequence, Schindler hired
eighteen of the prettiest, most 'qualified' young ladies as secretaries
- and was posed with them by a photographer outside the re-possessed
plant; the ultimate con-artist, he also continued to entertain
- and seduce - SS German officers with rich food, caviar and drink
in his apartment, to stimulate bids and purchase contracts; he
bragged about having 350 workers on his factory payroll
- there were many scenes of random and indiscriminate
killings of innocent Jews; on one snowy morning, as Schindler's
workers were marched out of the ghetto gate, under armed guard,
to the factory for their work day, a one-armed worker
was murdered at point-blank range with a gun; shortly later,
Diana Reiter (Elina Lowensohn), an educated female construction
engineer supervising the construction of a half-finished barracks
at Plaszow, was also brutally and senselessly exterminated
- in the winter of 1942, SS Lieutenant Amon Goethe (Ralph
Fiennes), the commandant for a new labor camp in Plaszow, gave a
chilling speech to his officers, on the extermination and liquidation
of Jews in the Ghetto in Krakow, Poland after the completion of the
Plaszow concentration labor camp:
- "Today is history. Today will be remembered. Years
from now, the young will ask with wonder about this day. Today
is history, and you are part of it. Six hundred years ago when
elsewhere they were footing the blame for the Black Death, Kazimierz
the Great, so-called, told the Jews they could come to Krakow.
They came. They trundled their belongings into the city. They
settled. They took hold. They prospered in business, science,
education, the arts. They came here with nothing. Nothing. And
they flourished. For six centuries, there has been a Jewish Krakow.
Think about that. By this evening, those six centuries are a
rumour. They never happened. Today is history."
- subsequently, the film documented
the brutal clearing and liquidation of the Krakow Ghetto in March
of 1943; hundreds of troops arbitrarily murdered and executed thousands
of Jews; there was an indelible image of a girl in a drab red coat
walking amidst the murderous chaos as Krakow's ghetto was destroyed
- [Note: The girl's body was later spotted on a
cart piled with corpses.]
- the final chapter of the Krakow
ghetto liquidation scene occurred that evening, with a night-time
hunt by special squads of SS killers for Jews still in hiding in
the ghetto apartments; thousands were transported to the new
camp, while many others were slaughtered in the streets
- to illustrate Goeth's savage and barbaric nature,
the shirtless, overweight and sadistic Goeth randomly fired his telescopic
rifle from his villa's balcony perch above the Plaszow work camp
at innocent prisoners
- meanwhile, for their first encounter, Schindler met
with and attempted to befriend the high ranking Goeth, through bribery
and other means, to maintain SS support; Schindler concluded ther
conversation, asking:
- "You could make things easier for me. (Goeth shrugged)
I'd be grateful"
- for a price, he was allowed to let some of the
labor camp inhabitants go back to work for him in his factory in
Krakow, so that he could continue to profit from them; as a result,
five hundred Plaszow worker/prisoners were marched back into the
factory gates of the D.E.F. to re-establish Schindler's workforce
- as time passed, Schindler began to take risks to
keep some of the Jews from being executed or sent away to concentration
camps, and to try and save as many lives as possible
- after a party at Goeth's villa, Schindler delivered
a speech to the drunken Goeth about power with restraint, convincing
Goeth to offer pardons instead of deadly justice:
- "Power is when we have every justification to
kill - and we don't"
- although Goeth temporarily experimented with giving
out pardons, he soon reverted to his murderous impulses; a pardon
was not as powerful or pleasing as sporting target practice
- in the villa's basement living quarters in a disturbing
sexually-confrontational scene, the lusting Goeth circled around
his glisteningly-sweaty, nubile and trembling Jewish housekeeper
Helen (Embeth Davidtz) in a flimsy, clinging chemise; he wanted to
both threaten and seduce her; but then he remembered that she was supposed
to be detested like a rat; pathologically filled with deep self-loathing,
he beat the tempting young Jewess for seducing him:
- "You're a Jewish
bitch. You nearly talked me into it, didn't you?"
- in the next scene in the upstairs offices of the D.E.F.,
Schindler celebrated his birthday - with a questionable sustained
kiss from a young Jewess worker who brought him a homemade cake
- in a medical examination sequence at the train depot
in Plaszow, it was announced that a shipment of Hungarians to the
camp meant a reduction in the size of the Plaszow work force: "We've
got to separate the sick from the healthy to make room"; the
healthy were winnowed out from the unfit by having prisoners run
naked before doctors; in addition, innocently-happy children were
lured from the barracks, and placed in large transport trucks; some
children fled and hid waist-deep in latrine
excrement
- Schindler was briefly arrested and jailed for violating the Race
and Resettlement Act, for kissing the young Jewish girl at his party;
Goeth intervened and defended the racial improprieties of Schindler's
action, allowing him to be released
- in April of 1944, Goeth was ordered to exhume and
incinerate the bodies of more than 10,000 Jews killed at Plaszow
and the Krakow Ghetto massacre; it was a way for the Nazis to cover
up the evidence of the slaughter of Jews; as Schindler spoke to Goeth,
he glimpsed one of the wheelbarrows which held the red-coated
corpse of the little girl seen earlier
- as the Germans began to lose the war, both Stern
and Schindler felt resigned to their fates; Schindler was wearied,
fearing that he would lose his Jewish workers; Goeth was being pressured
to ship the remaining Hebrews at Plaszow to the Auschwitz concentration
camp
- at a major turning point in his life, Schindler was
transformed from a profiteer to a savior of his Jews from slaughter;
Schindler negotiated with Goeth to move his workers to a military
munitions factory in the town of Brunnlitz (instead of executing
them), but then had to pay an enormous bribe for each chosen and
saved worker; Stern
laborously compiled and typed 'Schindler's List' (of 1,100 names) as
Schindler desperately paced the room; Stern eloquently summed it up:
- "The list is an absolute good.
The list is life. All around its margins lies the gulf"
- almost all of the people on Schindler's list (including
Goeth's maid Helen, the last name on the list) arrived safely at
the new site via train; in
one of the most intense sequences, however, a boxcar of his female
workers was accidentally rerouted and arrived at Auschwitz, where they
were led into what they believed was a lethal shower-gassing; the hair
of Schindler's women was shorn, and they were stripped naked of their
clothing - and identity; although fearful of dying, they wept with
relief when they realized they were in the delousing plant of Auschwitz
and not the gas chamber
- to save his female workers at Auschwitz, Schindler
had to intervene, and was forced to purchase them twice in order to
liberate them; the next day at the train yard, as the names from
Schindler's List were being called out, Schindler stepped
forward to prevent guards from detaining the children of the women,
arguing forcefully:
- "What are you doing? These are mine. These are
my workers. They should be on my train. They're skilled munitions
workers. They're essential. Essential girls. Their fingers polish
the insides of shell metal casings. How else am I to polish the
inside of a 45 millimeter shell casing? You tell me. You tell
me!"
- for the remainder of the war, Schindler was forced
to continue bribing Nazi officials; privately, he had decided to
manufacture only defective munitions and sabotage the German war
effort; eventually he went bankrupt; he had spent all his fortune
to save his Jews
- following the war in 1945 soon after the unconditional
surrender of Germany, Schindler gave an emotional final and farewell
address to his 1,200 workers and guards; he
described his own peril, due to his Nazi Party membership and self-described
position as a "profiteer
of slave labor"; Schindler would be forced to flee the advancing
Red Army:
- "...After six long years of murder, victims are
being mourned throughout the world. We've survived. Many of you
have come up to me and thanked me. Thank yourselves. Thank your
fearless Stern, and others among you who worried about you and
faced death at every moment. (sighing) I'm a member of the Nazi
party. I'm a munitions manufacturer. I'm a profiteer of slave
labor. I am a criminal. At midnight, you'll be free and I'll
be hunted. I shall remain with you until five minutes after midnight.
After which time, and I hope you'll forgive me, I have to flee"
Schindler's Farewell to His Factory Workers and
Nazi Guards
- then, at the end of his speech, he convincibly urged
the SS guards (who had been ordered to kill
the Jews) to return to their families as men, not murderers:
- ..."This is your opportunity. (murmuring) Or, you could leave,
and return to your families as men instead of murderers. (The guards
left) In memory of the countless victims among your people, I ask
us to observe three minutes of silence."
- now a fugitive, Oskar Schindler prepared to flee westward
(wearing Polish prisoner clothes and posing as a refugee);
some of his most loyal workers bid him goodbye, and gave him a letter,
exonerating him; he was also presented with a golden ring
secretly made from a worker's gold dental bridge; it was engraved
with a Talmudic quotation:
- "Whoever
saves one life saves the world entire"
- before leaving, he also gave a heart-wrenching goodbye
to his accountant Itzhak Stern, ashamed and sorrowful that he didn't
do more:
- "I could've
got more... I didn't do enough"
Schindler to Stern: "I
didn't do enough"
Film's Coda
- in the film's epilogue, it summarized post-war events
(including the hanging-execution of Amon Goeth) and Schindler's later
life ("Oskar Schindler failed at his marriage and several businesses
after the war"
- the final coda
(in color) paired actual elderly survivors (Schindler Hebrews) in the
present-day with their counterpart actors-actresses as they placed
rocks on the real-life grave of Schindler in Jerusalem, to express
their gratitude:
- "There are fewer than four thousand Jews left
alive in Poland today. There are more than six thousand descendants
of the Schindler Jews. In memory of the more than six million
Jews murdered."
The Entrance Sequence of War Profiteer
Oskar Schindler (Liam Neeson)
Amon Goeth's (Ralph Fiennes) Speech to Officers
Educated Female Jewish Worker Executed - Shot in Back of the Head
Goeth Randomly Firing His Telescopic Rifle From His Villa's
Balcony
Schindler's and Goeth's First Face-to-Face Meeting-Conversation
Goeth's Seductive Brutalization of His Jewish Housekeeper Helen (Embeth
Davidtz)
April of 1944 - Goeth and Schindler At Site of Exhumed And Burned Bodies
Girl in Red Coat Later Seen as a Corpse Piled on a Cart
The Typing of 'Schindler's List'
Harrowing Shower-Scene at Auschwitz
Schindler Rescuing Children at Auschwitz
Presentation of Gold Ring to Schindler