[wave] NSA: CDNA4 wavefront scheduling for sparse gather patterns #1256

Parent

Part of #1243 — DeepSeek NSA kernels for MI350

Description

Optimize wavefront scheduling and occupancy for the irregular memory access patterns in NSA's selection attention kernel on MI350 (CDNA4).

Problem

Selection attention gathers non-contiguous KV blocks based on per-query top-k indices. This creates:

• Irregular global memory access patterns (poor cache utilization)
• Variable work per wavefront (some queries select nearby blocks, others select distant ones)
• Potential wavefront stalls waiting for memory

Tasks

1. Gather coalescing analysis

   • Profile actual memory access patterns for representative block_indices distributions
   • Measure global memory bandwidth utilization vs theoretical peak
   • Identify whether block_size=64 aligns well with MI350 cache lines (64B) and memory channels

2. Wavefront occupancy tuning

   • Determine optimal number of wavefronts per CU for selection attention
   • Trade off register usage (more live state = fewer wavefronts) vs memory latency hiding (more wavefronts)
   • MI350 has 64KB VGPR per SIMD, 128 VGPRs per wavefront at full occupancy — find the sweet spot

3. Prefetch strategies

   • Software prefetch: issue global loads for the next block's KV while computing attention on the current block
   • LDS staging: load entire selected KV blocks into LDS before attention computation
   • Double-buffering: overlap loads and computation across blocks

4. Workgroup sizing

   • Current grid: (B, M, G) — one program per query position per GQA group
   • Consider coarsening: multiple query positions per workgroup to amortize block index loads
   • Consider splitting: if T is large, split blocks across workgroups with a reduction step

Depends on

• [wave] NSA: selection attention forward kernel #1248 (selection attention forward — baseline to optimize)
• [wave] NSA: architecture mapping & design doc for MI350 #1244 (design doc — roofline analysis)