-
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 716
Replace Etcher in installation guide #3945
What Happened?
Etcher is doing shady privacy invading stuff
Steps to Reproduce
https://tails.net/news/rufus/index.en.html
Expected Behavior
Move to something else
OS Version
8.x (Circe)
Session Type
Classic Session (X11, This is the default)
Software Version
Latest release (I have run all updates)
Log Output
Hardware Info
No response
All reactions
-
👍 1
Replies: 5 comments 6 replies
The only all-platforms FOSS alternative I found was USBImager. I thought it wasn't user-friendly at first, but the interface looks alright. If that issue gains more traction, we at least have an alternative.
All reactions
That page is now 404.
Is it about the "analytics" problem? I found this from their blog and this in their bug tracker. They said they removed it in version 2.1.2.
All reactions
I'll take a stab at writing a PR for this. Etcher doesn't do a great job anyways, and has left me with USB sticks that aren't bootable. The MacOS instructions may stay as Etcher because, I have no idea what to use as an alternative. Perhaps the installation instructions should be updated to use:
- Windows - Rufus (with screenshots from Windows 11 so it's nice)
- Linux - Popsicle https://github.com/pop-os/popsicle
I'm a fan of popsicle, it's been fast, reliable, an it's available as an appimage so it runs on all distros
All reactions
@danirabbit I converted this into a discussion, because I wanted the regular website maintainers to weigh in before I commit time to working updating/changing the recommended installation method. #3945 (comment)
I'm looking for some input to these questions:
- If we change the installation instructions to move away from Etcher, should we unlink the video tutorial on the installation page? - There is some inertia around using Etcher right now, including an installation video/tutorial that I'm talking about is [here](https://
elementary.io/docs/installation#recommended-system-specifications.) - How do people feel about Rufus being the recommended USB creation tool on Windows?
- Would we recommend UEFI over BIOS? - I'd be happy to put a note saying that the user should decide based on their system, but if UEFI is supported, then we recommend it...or similar.
- How does the community feel about Popsicle? - I'd include a flathub link, and a link to the Releases page on Github so folks that don't have flatpak installed can still use the universal image.
Thanks!
All reactions
I see there's a GNOME Circle app called Impression, which is a simple image writer not associated with any OS. It looks new, and I've never used it. It's on Flathub too.
Honestly, I've never used Popsicle either, as I prefer to just use good old dd. Do you think it's a good idea to add dd instructions there as a kind of fallback in case the recommended app ever stops working?
All reactions
-
👍 3
We used to recommend Rufus for windows. It was nice to be able to recommend the same app across platforms because it simplifies the documentation a lot. If we can at least recommend something that works on both macOS and Windows that would be nice. And something with a less overwhelming UI would be really helpful. Seeing something like Rufus, I'm sure there's a not insignificant number of folks that would immediately think, "oh wow this is too hard for me, nevermind"
Impression looks really nice. I'm a lot less worried about documenting ISO burning for folks running Linux. They're most likely to already know how to do it, have a favorite iso burning tool, and they represent a minority of the folks downloading our OS
I would definitely not support ever recommending an AppImage. Both for technical reasons and political ones
All reactions
-
👍 3
I'll give Impression a try and see how it works. This may be a better solution since it should be available on Ubuntu whereas popsicle isn't unless it's an appimage. I'll also do some research on the Windows side of things. It's definitely the go to for many guides which mention installing Windows, since it sets some registry keys on your behalf if you opt to.
@danirabbit you got me in tangles with this double negative "I would definitely not support ever recommending an AppImage. Both for technical reasons and political ones". That's a thumbs down for appimage right?
All reactions
@LuminousHustler yes huge thumbs down for AppImage. The author is a Nazi sympathizer and it's a garbage technology anyways
All reactions
-
👀 1
OpenSUSE has instructions (with screenshots) for using Impression :)