Como Conference
The International Congress of Physicists (Italian: Congresso internazionale dei fisici), better known as the Como Conference or the Volta Conference, was an international academic conference held from 11 to 27 September 1927, near Lake Como, Italy as part of a series of celebrations of the hundredth anniversary of the death of Alessandro Volta.[1] This conference inspired the Volta Congresses held in Rome and organized since 1931.
It concerned the topic of Volta's work and quantum mechanics. It gathered 61 physicists and mathematicians from all over the world. During the conference, Niels Bohr first introduced the principle of complementarity. The first quantum theory of metals was also discussed through the works of Arnold Sommerfeld and Enrico Fermi.
Organization
[edit ]The conference was part of the Volta centennial anniversary celebrations (Italian: Celebrazioni voltiane [it]) ordered by the government of Benito Mussolini.[2]
The physics conference was organized by the Italian Physical Society. The program was organized by Quirino Majorana, president of the society.[3] He was joined by Hendrik Lorentz, Aimé Cotton, Robert Andrews Millikan, Max von Laue and Giancarlo Vallauri as vicepresidents of the congress.[4]
The first four days were dedicated to works related to Volta, and the rest of the time was reserved for the topic of matter and radiation.[3] The venue was the Carducci Institute at Como.[4] Due to the presence of Guglielmo Marconi, many of the discussions were broadcast via radio.[4]
During the conference, Mussolini hosted a reception with the participants in Rome,[5] [6] in his residence at Villa Torlonia.[7]
Topics
[edit ]Bohr's complementarity
[edit ]On the 16th September, Niels Bohr presented a seminal lecture titled "The Quantum Postulate and the Recent Development of Atomic Theory" that introduced the principle of complementarity.[8] Bohr argued that phenomena at the quantum level exhibit a dual nature—wave–particle duality—but these aspects are excluded of being observed simultaneously.[1]
Oskar Klein and Bohr's brother Harald, helped him prepare the speech.[8] The idea was motivated by a discussion in February–March with Werner Heisenberg, who had recently introduced the uncertainty principle.[1] [8] For Bohr, these two principles were key for the new quantum mechanics.[1] The complementarity principle became the essence of what would become the Copenhagen interpretation, the standard interpretation of quantum mechanics.[1] [9]
Hendrik Lorentz praised Bohr's clarity of the presentation but regretted that there was not enough time for discussions.[3] The same speech was repeated in October during the 5th Solvay Conference, and became part of the Bohr–Einstein debates.[1]
Quantum theory of metals
[edit ]During the conference, Arnold Sommerfeld presented the free electron model for metals, which extended the classical Drude model by introducing the recently introduced Fermi statistics and Fermi gas model.[10] [11] [12] These results boosted Enrico Fermi's reputation outside Italy.[13] [6]
Participants
[edit ]The list of physicists that attended included nine of Nobel Prize laureates in Physics, two Nobel Prize laureates in Chemistry, and various founders of quantum mechanics.[4] Physicist Franco Rasetti and others have referred to the list as the Almanach de Gotha of physics.[12] [13] The full list includes:[14] [4]
- Vienna, Austria:
- Toronto, Canada: John Cunningham McLennan.
- Copenhagen, Denmark:
- Paris, France:
- Germany
- Max Born, Göttingen;
- James Franck, Gottingen;
- Walther Gerlach, Tübingen;
- Eduard Grüneisen, Marburg;
- Max von Laue, Berlin;
- Friedrich Paschen, Charlottenburg;
- Wolfgang Pauli, Hamburg;
- Max Planck, Berlin;
- Arnold Sommerfeld, Munich;
- Otto Stern, Hamburg;
- Karl Willy Wagner, Berlin.
- India:
- Debendra Mohan Bose, Calcutta;
- Meghnad Saha, Allahabad.
- Italia:
- Lavoro Amaduzzi, Parma;
- Alessandro Amerio [it], Pavia;
- Michele Cantone [it], Naples;
- Orso Mario Corbino, Rome;
- Enrico Fermi, Rome;
- Antonio Garbasso, Florence;
- Giuseppe Gianfranceschi [it], Rome;
- Giovanni Giorgi, Cagliari;
- Tullio Levi-Civita, Rome;
- Antonino Lo Surdo, Rome;
- Quirino Majorana;
- Guglielmo Marconi, Rome;
- Michele La Rosa [it], Palermo;
- Eligio Perucca, Turin;
- Carlo Somigliana, Torino;
- Paolo Straneo, Genoa,
- Vito Volterra, Rome.
- Netherlands:
- Hans Kramers, Utrecht;
- Hendrik Lorentz, Leiden;
- Pieter Zeeman, Amsterdam.
- Russia:
- Yakov Frenkel, Leningrad;
- Petr Lazarev, Moscow.
- Spain:
- Eduardo Alcobè y Arenas, Barcelona;
- Blas Cabrera, Madrid.
- Zurich, Switzerland: Peter Debye.
- United Kingdom:
- Francis William Aston, Cambridge;
- Lawrence Bragg, Manchester;
- Arthur Eddington, Cambridge;
- Owen Richardson, London;
- Ernest Rutherford, Cambridge.
- United States:
- Arthur Compton, Chicago;
- William Duane, Boston;
- Edwin Hall, Cambridge;
- Arthur E. Kennelly, Cambridge;
- Irving Langmuir, New York;
- Robert Andrews Millikan, Pasadena;
- Richard C. Tolman, Pasadena;
- Robert W. Wood, Baltimore.
Other invited scientists
[edit ]Albert Einstein did not participate due to his opposition to Mussolini's regime.[2] [4] James Franck wanted also to cancel due to political reasons but he had accepted before knowing that Mussolini would be receiving them.[5] Sommerfeld also expressed reservation in attending, but went to the conference anyway.[15]
In in his biography, Emilio Segrè says that he and Franco Rasetti were not invited but entered the lectures anyway.[6] The meetings convinced Segrè to switch careers from engineering to physics.[6]
Some letters suggest that Satyendra Nath Bose might have been invited to the conference, but by error his invitation was sent to Debendra M. Bose.[1] This claim has been contested as S. N. Bose's work was less well known at that time.[16] [17]
See also
[edit ]Notes
[edit ]References
[edit ]- ^ a b c d e f g Lahti, Pekka; Mittelstaedt, Peter (1988年02月01日). Symposium On The Foundations Of Modern Physics 1987 - The Copenhagen Interpretation 60 Years After The Como Lecture. World Scientific. ISBN 978-981-320-170-5.
- ^ a b Grünberg, Hans-Hennig von; Griffiths, Alex (2024). 1924-1927: The Dawning of Quantum Mechanics. Springer Nature. ISBN 978-3-662-70045-7.
- ^ a b c Pancaldi, Giuliano (2018年06月05日). Volta: Science and Culture in the Age of Enlightenment. Princeton University Press. ISBN 978-0-691-18861-4.
- ^ a b c d e f Giliberti, Marco; Lovisetti, Luisa (2024). Old Quantum Theory and Early Quantum Mechanics: A Historical Perspective Commented for the Inquiring Reader. Springer Nature. ISBN 978-3-031-57934-9.
- ^ a b c Lemmerich, Jost; Hentschel, Ann (2011年08月10日). Science and Conscience: The Life of James Franck. Stanford University Press. ISBN 978-0-8047-6310-3.
- ^ a b c d Segrè, Emilio (2019年08月17日). A Mind Always in Motion: The Autobiography of Emilio Segrè. Plunkett Lake Press.
- ^ Raboy, Marc (2016年06月28日). Marconi: The Man Who Networked the World. Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-931360-0.
- ^ a b c Various (2014年02月13日). The Quantum Theory and Particle Physics collection. OUP Oxford. ISBN 978-0-19-102542-6.
- ^ Bayın, Selçuk Ş (2023年06月18日). The Pursuit of Reality: Narrative History of the Quantum and the Great Minds That Made it. Springer Nature. ISBN 978-981-99-1031-1.
- ^ Mehra, Jagdish; Rechenberg, Helmut (2001). The Historical Development of Quantum Theory. Springer Science & Business Media. ISBN 978-0-387-95180-5.
- ^ Eckert, Michael (2013年06月24日). Arnold Sommerfeld: Science, Life and Turbulent Times 1868-1951. Springer Science & Business Media. ISBN 978-1-4614-7461-6.
- ^ a b Bernardini, Carlo; Bonolis, Luisa (2013年11月11日). Enrico Fermi: His Work and Legacy. Springer Science & Business Media. ISBN 978-3-662-01160-7.
- ^ a b Bruzzaniti, Giuseppe (2016年03月21日). Enrico Fermi: The Obedient Genius. Springer. ISBN 978-1-4939-3533-8.
- ^ Atti del congresso internazionale dei fisici : 11-20 settembre 1927, 5., Como, Pavia, Roma. Vol. 1. Accademia delle Scienze di Torino. 1928.
{{cite book}}
: CS1 maint: others (link) - ^ Eckert, Michael (2013年06月24日). Arnold Sommerfeld: Science, Life and Turbulent Times 1868-1951. Springer Science & Business Media. ISBN 978-1-4614-7461-6.
- ^ Rajinder Singh, Celebrating 125th birth anniversary of DM Bose - Invitation to the Como conference, Science and Culture 76, 494-501, 2010.
- ^ Rajinder Singh: D.M. Bose - His scientific work in international context, Shaker Publisher, Aachen 2016. DM Bose Scientific work