Skip to main content
Code Review

Return to Question

Notice removed Authoritative reference needed by Community Bot
Bounty Ended with Snowbody's answer chosen by Community Bot
Tweeted twitter.com/StackCodeReview/status/938092796694663170
Notice added Authoritative reference needed by Maldred
Bounty Started worth 50 reputation by Maldred
added 17 characters in body
Source Link

I'm currently designing a check list for my office using Excel that requires the user to save anywhere from 4-10 documents that need to be saved in the same folder as this check list. I thought it might be easier to consolidate everything into one Excel file by using User Forms. I noticed that it's not safe to use a User Form to store data, but instead using it as a means to display or manipulate data or cells from within the spreadsheet.

Unfortunately, I cannot store all the raw data from these files into a single cell as they can be quite large files. I thought maybe it'd be best to have an ActiveX Textbox to store this data into instead, but I'm wondering if I this might cause issues later down the road or if some one else's computer isn't compatible.

Visually what I've done...

This is the secondary spreadsheet (will be hidden) that stores the data in ActiveX Text Boxes

enter image description here

User form below that is displaying that data, stored from the secondary spreadsheet in the ActiveX Text Boxes

enter image description here

TL;DR

Everything is working as intended, but my primary question here is... Is this the best and safest (safest as in, lowest chance of losing data... I am not worried about security as everything is stored on a server) way to have all this data being stored in a single document by using embedded TextBoxes? If not, what would be a good alternative?

Code run when the User Form is closed

Private Sub btnSaveAndClose_Click()
 Sheets("Data").TextBox1.Value = PO850Data.Value
 Sheets("Data").TextBox2.Value = Invoice810Data.Value
 frmEDIData.Hide
End Sub

Code run when the User Form is opened

Private Sub UserForm_Initialize()
 btnSaveAndClose.SetFocus
 PO850Data.Value = Sheets("Data").TextBox1.Value
 Invoice810Data.Value = Sheets("Data").TextBox2.Value
 
End Sub

Everything is working as intended, but my primary question here is... Is this the best and safest (safest as in, lowest chance of losing data... I am not worried about security as everything is stored on a server) way to have all this data being stored in a single document? If not, what would be a good alternative?

EDIT 1:

EXAMPLE EDI 850 DOCUMENT - (X12 Format)

ISA*01*0000000000*01*0000000000*ZZ*ABCDEFGHIJKLMNO*ZZ*123456789012345*101127*1719*U*00400*000003438*0*P*>
GS*PO*4405197800*999999999*20101127*1719*1421*X*004010VICS
ST*850*000000010
BEG*00*SA*08292233294**20101127*610385385
REF*DP*038
REF*PS*R
ITD*14*3*2**45**46
DTM*002*20101214
PKG*F*68***PALLETIZE SHIPMENT
PKG*F*66***REGULAR
TD5*A*92*P3**SEE XYZ RETAIL ROUTING GUIDE
N1*ST*XYZ RETAIL*9*0003947268292
N3*31875 SOLON RD
N4*SOLON*OH*44139
PO1*1*120*EA*9.25*TE*CB*065322-117*PR*RO*VN*AB3542
PID*F****SMALL WIDGET
PO4*4*4*EA*PLT94**3*LR*15*CT
PO1*2*220*EA*13.79*TE*CB*066850-116*PR*RO*VN*RD5322
PID*F****MEDIUM WIDGET
PO4*2*2*EA
PO1*3*126*EA*10.99*TE*CB*060733-110*PR*RO*VN*XY5266
PID*F****LARGE WIDGET
PO4*6*1*EA*PLT94**3*LR*12*CT
PO1*4*76*EA*4.35*TE*CB*065308-116*PR*RO*VN*VX2332
PID*F****NANO WIDGET
PO4*4*4*EA*PLT94**6*LR*19*CT
PO1*5*72*EA*7.5*TE*CB*065374-118*PR*RO*VN*RV0524
PID*F****BLUE WIDGET
PO4*4*4*EA
PO1*6*696*EA*9.55*TE*CB*067504-118*PR*RO*VN*DX1875
PID*F****ORANGE WIDGET
PO4*6*6*EA*PLT94**3*LR*10*CT
CTT*6
AMT*1*13045.94
SE*33*000000010
GE*1*1421
IEA*1*000003438

These can be much larger documents, I'd say we deal with 10x this size on a regular basis. Each TextBox will store one of these document's data.

I'm currently designing a check list for my office using Excel that requires the user to save anywhere from 4-10 documents that need to be saved in the same folder as this check list. I thought it might be easier to consolidate everything into one Excel file by using User Forms. I noticed that it's not safe to use a User Form to store data, but instead using it as a means to display or manipulate data or cells from within the spreadsheet.

Unfortunately, I cannot store all the raw data from these files into a single cell as they can be quite large files. I thought maybe it'd be best to have an ActiveX Textbox to store this data into instead, but I'm wondering if I this might cause issues later down the road or if some one else's computer isn't compatible.

Visually what I've done...

This is the secondary spreadsheet (will be hidden) that stores the data in ActiveX Text Boxes

enter image description here

User form below that is displaying that data, stored from the secondary spreadsheet in the ActiveX Text Boxes

enter image description here

Code run when the User Form is closed

Private Sub btnSaveAndClose_Click()
 Sheets("Data").TextBox1.Value = PO850Data.Value
 Sheets("Data").TextBox2.Value = Invoice810Data.Value
 frmEDIData.Hide
End Sub

Code run when the User Form is opened

Private Sub UserForm_Initialize()
 btnSaveAndClose.SetFocus
 PO850Data.Value = Sheets("Data").TextBox1.Value
 Invoice810Data.Value = Sheets("Data").TextBox2.Value
 
End Sub

Everything is working as intended, but my primary question here is... Is this the best and safest (safest as in, lowest chance of losing data... I am not worried about security as everything is stored on a server) way to have all this data being stored in a single document? If not, what would be a good alternative?

EDIT 1:

EXAMPLE EDI 850 DOCUMENT

ISA*01*0000000000*01*0000000000*ZZ*ABCDEFGHIJKLMNO*ZZ*123456789012345*101127*1719*U*00400*000003438*0*P*>
GS*PO*4405197800*999999999*20101127*1719*1421*X*004010VICS
ST*850*000000010
BEG*00*SA*08292233294**20101127*610385385
REF*DP*038
REF*PS*R
ITD*14*3*2**45**46
DTM*002*20101214
PKG*F*68***PALLETIZE SHIPMENT
PKG*F*66***REGULAR
TD5*A*92*P3**SEE XYZ RETAIL ROUTING GUIDE
N1*ST*XYZ RETAIL*9*0003947268292
N3*31875 SOLON RD
N4*SOLON*OH*44139
PO1*1*120*EA*9.25*TE*CB*065322-117*PR*RO*VN*AB3542
PID*F****SMALL WIDGET
PO4*4*4*EA*PLT94**3*LR*15*CT
PO1*2*220*EA*13.79*TE*CB*066850-116*PR*RO*VN*RD5322
PID*F****MEDIUM WIDGET
PO4*2*2*EA
PO1*3*126*EA*10.99*TE*CB*060733-110*PR*RO*VN*XY5266
PID*F****LARGE WIDGET
PO4*6*1*EA*PLT94**3*LR*12*CT
PO1*4*76*EA*4.35*TE*CB*065308-116*PR*RO*VN*VX2332
PID*F****NANO WIDGET
PO4*4*4*EA*PLT94**6*LR*19*CT
PO1*5*72*EA*7.5*TE*CB*065374-118*PR*RO*VN*RV0524
PID*F****BLUE WIDGET
PO4*4*4*EA
PO1*6*696*EA*9.55*TE*CB*067504-118*PR*RO*VN*DX1875
PID*F****ORANGE WIDGET
PO4*6*6*EA*PLT94**3*LR*10*CT
CTT*6
AMT*1*13045.94
SE*33*000000010
GE*1*1421
IEA*1*000003438

These can be much larger documents, I'd say we deal with 10x this size on a regular basis. Each TextBox will store one of these document's data.

I'm currently designing a check list for my office using Excel that requires the user to save anywhere from 4-10 documents that need to be saved in the same folder as this check list. I thought it might be easier to consolidate everything into one Excel file by using User Forms. I noticed that it's not safe to use a User Form to store data, but instead using it as a means to display or manipulate data or cells from within the spreadsheet.

Unfortunately, I cannot store all the raw data from these files into a single cell as they can be quite large files. I thought maybe it'd be best to have an ActiveX Textbox to store this data into instead, but I'm wondering if I this might cause issues later down the road or if some one else's computer isn't compatible.

Visually what I've done...

This is the secondary spreadsheet (will be hidden) that stores the data in ActiveX Text Boxes

enter image description here

User form below that is displaying that data, stored from the secondary spreadsheet in the ActiveX Text Boxes

enter image description here

TL;DR

Everything is working as intended, but my primary question here is... Is this the best and safest (safest as in, lowest chance of losing data... I am not worried about security as everything is stored on a server) way to have all this data being stored in a single document by using embedded TextBoxes? If not, what would be a good alternative?

Code run when the User Form is closed

Private Sub btnSaveAndClose_Click()
 Sheets("Data").TextBox1.Value = PO850Data.Value
 Sheets("Data").TextBox2.Value = Invoice810Data.Value
 frmEDIData.Hide
End Sub

Code run when the User Form is opened

Private Sub UserForm_Initialize()
 btnSaveAndClose.SetFocus
 PO850Data.Value = Sheets("Data").TextBox1.Value
 Invoice810Data.Value = Sheets("Data").TextBox2.Value
 
End Sub

EDIT 1:

EXAMPLE EDI 850 DOCUMENT - (X12 Format)

ISA*01*0000000000*01*0000000000*ZZ*ABCDEFGHIJKLMNO*ZZ*123456789012345*101127*1719*U*00400*000003438*0*P*>
GS*PO*4405197800*999999999*20101127*1719*1421*X*004010VICS
ST*850*000000010
BEG*00*SA*08292233294**20101127*610385385
REF*DP*038
REF*PS*R
ITD*14*3*2**45**46
DTM*002*20101214
PKG*F*68***PALLETIZE SHIPMENT
PKG*F*66***REGULAR
TD5*A*92*P3**SEE XYZ RETAIL ROUTING GUIDE
N1*ST*XYZ RETAIL*9*0003947268292
N3*31875 SOLON RD
N4*SOLON*OH*44139
PO1*1*120*EA*9.25*TE*CB*065322-117*PR*RO*VN*AB3542
PID*F****SMALL WIDGET
PO4*4*4*EA*PLT94**3*LR*15*CT
PO1*2*220*EA*13.79*TE*CB*066850-116*PR*RO*VN*RD5322
PID*F****MEDIUM WIDGET
PO4*2*2*EA
PO1*3*126*EA*10.99*TE*CB*060733-110*PR*RO*VN*XY5266
PID*F****LARGE WIDGET
PO4*6*1*EA*PLT94**3*LR*12*CT
PO1*4*76*EA*4.35*TE*CB*065308-116*PR*RO*VN*VX2332
PID*F****NANO WIDGET
PO4*4*4*EA*PLT94**6*LR*19*CT
PO1*5*72*EA*7.5*TE*CB*065374-118*PR*RO*VN*RV0524
PID*F****BLUE WIDGET
PO4*4*4*EA
PO1*6*696*EA*9.55*TE*CB*067504-118*PR*RO*VN*DX1875
PID*F****ORANGE WIDGET
PO4*6*6*EA*PLT94**3*LR*10*CT
CTT*6
AMT*1*13045.94
SE*33*000000010
GE*1*1421
IEA*1*000003438

These can be much larger documents, I'd say we deal with 10x this size on a regular basis. Each TextBox will store one of these document's data.

added 1458 characters in body
Source Link

I'm currently designing a check list for my office using Excel that requires the user to save anywhere from 4-10 documents that need to be saved in the same folder as this check list. I thought it might be easier to consolidate everything into one Excel file by using User Forms. I noticed that it's not safe to use a User Form to store data, but instead using it as a means to display or manipulate data or cells from within the spreadsheet.

Unfortunately, I cannot store all the raw data from these files into a single cell as they can be quite large files. I thought maybe it'd be best to have an ActiveX Textbox to store this data into instead, but I'm wondering if I this might cause issues later down the road or if some one else's computer isn't compatible.

Visually what I've done...

This is the secondary spreadsheet (will be hidden) that stores the data in ActiveX Text Boxes

enter image description here

User form below that is displaying that data, stored from the secondary spreadsheet in the ActiveX Text Boxes

enter image description here

Code run when the User Form is closed

Private Sub btnSaveAndClose_Click()
 Sheets("Data").TextBox1.Value = PO850Data.Value
 Sheets("Data").TextBox2.Value = Invoice810Data.Value
 frmEDIData.Hide
End Sub

Code run when the User Form is opened

Private Sub UserForm_Initialize()
 btnSaveAndClose.SetFocus
 PO850Data.Value = Sheets("Data").TextBox1.Value
 Invoice810Data.Value = Sheets("Data").TextBox2.Value
 
End Sub

Everything is working as intended, but my primary question here is... Is this the best and safest (safest as in, lowest chance of losing data... I am not worried about security as everything is stored on a server) way to have all this data being stored in a single document? If not, what would be a good alternative?

EDIT 1:

EXAMPLE EDI 850 DOCUMENT

ISA*01*0000000000*01*0000000000*ZZ*ABCDEFGHIJKLMNO*ZZ*123456789012345*101127*1719*U*00400*000003438*0*P*>
GS*PO*4405197800*999999999*20101127*1719*1421*X*004010VICS
ST*850*000000010
BEG*00*SA*08292233294**20101127*610385385
REF*DP*038
REF*PS*R
ITD*14*3*2**45**46
DTM*002*20101214
PKG*F*68***PALLETIZE SHIPMENT
PKG*F*66***REGULAR
TD5*A*92*P3**SEE XYZ RETAIL ROUTING GUIDE
N1*ST*XYZ RETAIL*9*0003947268292
N3*31875 SOLON RD
N4*SOLON*OH*44139
PO1*1*120*EA*9.25*TE*CB*065322-117*PR*RO*VN*AB3542
PID*F****SMALL WIDGET
PO4*4*4*EA*PLT94**3*LR*15*CT
PO1*2*220*EA*13.79*TE*CB*066850-116*PR*RO*VN*RD5322
PID*F****MEDIUM WIDGET
PO4*2*2*EA
PO1*3*126*EA*10.99*TE*CB*060733-110*PR*RO*VN*XY5266
PID*F****LARGE WIDGET
PO4*6*1*EA*PLT94**3*LR*12*CT
PO1*4*76*EA*4.35*TE*CB*065308-116*PR*RO*VN*VX2332
PID*F****NANO WIDGET
PO4*4*4*EA*PLT94**6*LR*19*CT
PO1*5*72*EA*7.5*TE*CB*065374-118*PR*RO*VN*RV0524
PID*F****BLUE WIDGET
PO4*4*4*EA
PO1*6*696*EA*9.55*TE*CB*067504-118*PR*RO*VN*DX1875
PID*F****ORANGE WIDGET
PO4*6*6*EA*PLT94**3*LR*10*CT
CTT*6
AMT*1*13045.94
SE*33*000000010
GE*1*1421
IEA*1*000003438

These can be much larger documents, I'd say we deal with 10x this size on a regular basis. Each TextBox will store one of these document's data.

I'm currently designing a check list for my office using Excel that requires the user to save anywhere from 4-10 documents that need to be saved in the same folder as this check list. I thought it might be easier to consolidate everything into one Excel file by using User Forms. I noticed that it's not safe to use a User Form to store data, but instead using it as a means to display or manipulate data or cells from within the spreadsheet.

Unfortunately, I cannot store all the raw data from these files into a single cell as they can be quite large files. I thought maybe it'd be best to have an ActiveX Textbox to store this data into instead, but I'm wondering if I this might cause issues later down the road or if some one else's computer isn't compatible.

Visually what I've done...

This is the secondary spreadsheet (will be hidden) that stores the data in ActiveX Text Boxes

enter image description here

User form below that is displaying that data, stored from the secondary spreadsheet in the ActiveX Text Boxes

enter image description here

Code run when the User Form is closed

Private Sub btnSaveAndClose_Click()
 Sheets("Data").TextBox1.Value = PO850Data.Value
 Sheets("Data").TextBox2.Value = Invoice810Data.Value
 frmEDIData.Hide
End Sub

Code run when the User Form is opened

Private Sub UserForm_Initialize()
 btnSaveAndClose.SetFocus
 PO850Data.Value = Sheets("Data").TextBox1.Value
 Invoice810Data.Value = Sheets("Data").TextBox2.Value
 
End Sub

Everything is working as intended, but my primary question here is... Is this the best and safest (safest as in, lowest chance of losing data... I am not worried about security as everything is stored on a server) way to have all this data being stored in a single document? If not, what would be a good alternative?

I'm currently designing a check list for my office using Excel that requires the user to save anywhere from 4-10 documents that need to be saved in the same folder as this check list. I thought it might be easier to consolidate everything into one Excel file by using User Forms. I noticed that it's not safe to use a User Form to store data, but instead using it as a means to display or manipulate data or cells from within the spreadsheet.

Unfortunately, I cannot store all the raw data from these files into a single cell as they can be quite large files. I thought maybe it'd be best to have an ActiveX Textbox to store this data into instead, but I'm wondering if I this might cause issues later down the road or if some one else's computer isn't compatible.

Visually what I've done...

This is the secondary spreadsheet (will be hidden) that stores the data in ActiveX Text Boxes

enter image description here

User form below that is displaying that data, stored from the secondary spreadsheet in the ActiveX Text Boxes

enter image description here

Code run when the User Form is closed

Private Sub btnSaveAndClose_Click()
 Sheets("Data").TextBox1.Value = PO850Data.Value
 Sheets("Data").TextBox2.Value = Invoice810Data.Value
 frmEDIData.Hide
End Sub

Code run when the User Form is opened

Private Sub UserForm_Initialize()
 btnSaveAndClose.SetFocus
 PO850Data.Value = Sheets("Data").TextBox1.Value
 Invoice810Data.Value = Sheets("Data").TextBox2.Value
 
End Sub

Everything is working as intended, but my primary question here is... Is this the best and safest (safest as in, lowest chance of losing data... I am not worried about security as everything is stored on a server) way to have all this data being stored in a single document? If not, what would be a good alternative?

EDIT 1:

EXAMPLE EDI 850 DOCUMENT

ISA*01*0000000000*01*0000000000*ZZ*ABCDEFGHIJKLMNO*ZZ*123456789012345*101127*1719*U*00400*000003438*0*P*>
GS*PO*4405197800*999999999*20101127*1719*1421*X*004010VICS
ST*850*000000010
BEG*00*SA*08292233294**20101127*610385385
REF*DP*038
REF*PS*R
ITD*14*3*2**45**46
DTM*002*20101214
PKG*F*68***PALLETIZE SHIPMENT
PKG*F*66***REGULAR
TD5*A*92*P3**SEE XYZ RETAIL ROUTING GUIDE
N1*ST*XYZ RETAIL*9*0003947268292
N3*31875 SOLON RD
N4*SOLON*OH*44139
PO1*1*120*EA*9.25*TE*CB*065322-117*PR*RO*VN*AB3542
PID*F****SMALL WIDGET
PO4*4*4*EA*PLT94**3*LR*15*CT
PO1*2*220*EA*13.79*TE*CB*066850-116*PR*RO*VN*RD5322
PID*F****MEDIUM WIDGET
PO4*2*2*EA
PO1*3*126*EA*10.99*TE*CB*060733-110*PR*RO*VN*XY5266
PID*F****LARGE WIDGET
PO4*6*1*EA*PLT94**3*LR*12*CT
PO1*4*76*EA*4.35*TE*CB*065308-116*PR*RO*VN*VX2332
PID*F****NANO WIDGET
PO4*4*4*EA*PLT94**6*LR*19*CT
PO1*5*72*EA*7.5*TE*CB*065374-118*PR*RO*VN*RV0524
PID*F****BLUE WIDGET
PO4*4*4*EA
PO1*6*696*EA*9.55*TE*CB*067504-118*PR*RO*VN*DX1875
PID*F****ORANGE WIDGET
PO4*6*6*EA*PLT94**3*LR*10*CT
CTT*6
AMT*1*13045.94
SE*33*000000010
GE*1*1421
IEA*1*000003438

These can be much larger documents, I'd say we deal with 10x this size on a regular basis. Each TextBox will store one of these document's data.

Source Link

Storing and Retrieving data with User Forms in Excel 2010

I'm currently designing a check list for my office using Excel that requires the user to save anywhere from 4-10 documents that need to be saved in the same folder as this check list. I thought it might be easier to consolidate everything into one Excel file by using User Forms. I noticed that it's not safe to use a User Form to store data, but instead using it as a means to display or manipulate data or cells from within the spreadsheet.

Unfortunately, I cannot store all the raw data from these files into a single cell as they can be quite large files. I thought maybe it'd be best to have an ActiveX Textbox to store this data into instead, but I'm wondering if I this might cause issues later down the road or if some one else's computer isn't compatible.

Visually what I've done...

This is the secondary spreadsheet (will be hidden) that stores the data in ActiveX Text Boxes

enter image description here

User form below that is displaying that data, stored from the secondary spreadsheet in the ActiveX Text Boxes

enter image description here

Code run when the User Form is closed

Private Sub btnSaveAndClose_Click()
 Sheets("Data").TextBox1.Value = PO850Data.Value
 Sheets("Data").TextBox2.Value = Invoice810Data.Value
 frmEDIData.Hide
End Sub

Code run when the User Form is opened

Private Sub UserForm_Initialize()
 btnSaveAndClose.SetFocus
 PO850Data.Value = Sheets("Data").TextBox1.Value
 Invoice810Data.Value = Sheets("Data").TextBox2.Value
 
End Sub

Everything is working as intended, but my primary question here is... Is this the best and safest (safest as in, lowest chance of losing data... I am not worried about security as everything is stored on a server) way to have all this data being stored in a single document? If not, what would be a good alternative?

lang-vb

AltStyle によって変換されたページ (->オリジナル) /