cucina_vegana doesn't register plants through the farming API when this mod is used #34

camelia commented 2025年07月13日 17:44:32 +02:00

Hi! First of all thanks for this incredible mod!

I believe that when this mod is loaded, it overwrites plants that were previously registered using the farming.register_plant function.

The problem is that some mods, such as cucina_vegana, use this API. I believe that this mod specifically is loaded before the farming mod, and that, once the farming redo mod is loaded, it overwrites previously registered plants.

This causes behavior reported in: camelia/farmtools#6.

However, I have no easy fix for this, since the farming.registered_plants is not available through the Lua API here. I think this could be fixed if there was a way to load this mod before any other one, but I'm still new to Luanti modding and I don't know if such an option exists.

Hi! First of all thanks for this incredible mod! I believe that when this mod is loaded, it overwrites plants that were previously registered using the `farming.register_plant` function. The problem is that some mods, such as [`cucina_vegana`](https://github.com/acmgit/cucina_vegana), use this API. I believe that this mod specifically is loaded before the farming mod, and that, once the farming redo mod is loaded, it overwrites previously registered plants. This causes behavior reported in: https://codeberg.org/camelia/farmtools/issues/6. However, I have no easy fix for this, since the `farming.registered_plants` is not available through the Lua API here. I think this could be fixed if there was a way to load this mod before any other one, but I'm still new to Luanti modding and I don't know if such an option exists.

camelia commented 2025年07月13日 18:14:21 +02:00

hold on, maybe this is not the cause at all 🤔
maybe the problem comes from the cucina_vegana mod, and not this one. I'm troubleshooting and will let you know once I figure out the cause.

hold on, maybe this is not the cause at all 🤔 maybe the problem comes from the cucina_vegana mod, and not this one. I'm troubleshooting and will let you know once I figure out the cause.

camelia commented 2025年07月13日 18:19:22 +02:00

okay, well my bad, it looks like the problem comes from the cucina_vegana mod and not this one. it seems that farming.register_plant is not called when the farming mod is redo, but that it is called when the farming mod is the default one.

sorry for the inconvenience, I will investigate and report to the correct repository.

okay, well my bad, it looks like the problem comes from the cucina_vegana mod and not this one. it seems that `farming.register_plant` is not called when the farming mod is redo, but that it is called when the farming mod is the default one. sorry for the inconvenience, I will investigate and report to the correct repository.

tenplus1 commented 2025年07月13日 18:50:07 +02:00

The cucina_vegana mod only has to use the default registered crops since Farming redo has a compatible API, I dont really know why the are registered differently.

The cucina_vegana mod only has to use the default registered crops since Farming redo has a compatible API, I dont really know why the are registered differently.

tenplus1 commented 2025年07月14日 11:58:48 +02:00

I've forked cucina_vegana to run on 5.x clients only and removed the need for _redo files if you wish to try it out.

https://codeberg.org/tenplus1/cucina_vegana

I've forked cucina_vegana to run on 5.x clients only and removed the need for _redo files if you wish to try it out. https://codeberg.org/tenplus1/cucina_vegana

camelia commented 2025年07月14日 14:34:40 +02:00

Thank you very much! I can confirm that the mod I'm developing works as expected when using your fork :)

Thank you very much! I can confirm that the mod I'm developing works as expected when using your fork :)