Threads / replies from Mattermost not visible on XMPP #20

gdstr commented 2026年02月27日 12:05:08 +01:00

Tested with Dino and Gajim. Are they missing support for some XEP?

Tested with Dino and Gajim. Are they missing support for some XEP?

nicoco commented 2026年03月01日 08:26:41 +01:00

Only Cheogram supports threads. There is no "reply" concept in mattermost per se, every message is potentially the start of a thread. I have started some work on gajim threads it needs a little more love (and rebasing...) to be use-able https://dev.gajim.org/gajim/gajim/-/merge_requests/1007

Threads / replies from Mattermost not visible on XMPP

Do you mean messages are just "mixed" together or that they're actually missing?

Only Cheogram supports threads. There is no "reply" concept in mattermost per se, every message is potentially the start of a thread. I have started some work on gajim threads it needs a little more love (and rebasing...) to be use-able https://dev.gajim.org/gajim/gajim/-/merge_requests/1007 > Threads / replies from Mattermost not visible on XMPP Do you mean messages are just "mixed" together or that they're actually missing?

gdstr commented 2026年04月11日 23:45:26 +02:00

Do you mean messages are just "mixed" together or that they're actually missing?

"Mixed" together not actually missing.

> Do you mean messages are just "mixed" together or that they're actually missing? "Mixed" together not actually missing.

nicoco commented 2026年04月13日 17:23:47 +02:00

Then that is the expected behaviour. Threads are supported by slidge, but very few clients implement them, that is why you can't see them in Dino or Gajim. Only Cheogram Android supports threads unfortunately.

We could map all threaded messages as replies to the first message of the thread, which Dino and Gajim would show, but I am not sure it would be better.

Then that is the expected behaviour. Threads are supported by slidge, but very few clients implement them, that is why you can't see them in Dino or Gajim. Only Cheogram Android supports threads unfortunately. We _could_ map all threaded messages as replies to the first message of the thread, which Dino and Gajim would show, but I am not sure it would be better.

gdstr commented 2026年04月29日 23:26:00 +02:00

We could map all threaded messages as replies to the first message of the thread, which Dino and Gajim would show, but I am not sure it would be better.

That would be great, at least as a config option.

> We could map all threaded messages as replies to the first message of the thread, which Dino and Gajim would show, but I am not sure it would be better. That would be great, at least as a config option.