Support Taskbar #42

zyend82 commented 2021年04月06日 14:33:17 +02:00

I want to run yambar on Wayfire. But,i need it to have Taskbar. Taskbar can be achieved by foreign-toplevel-manager protocol.

Please see

https://github.com/Alexays/Waybar/wiki/Module:-Taskbar

And please try to implement Taskbar so that I can switch to Yambar.

Thanks in advance

I want to run yambar on Wayfire. But,i need it to have Taskbar. Taskbar can be achieved by foreign-toplevel-manager protocol. Please see https://github.com/Alexays/Waybar/wiki/Module:-Taskbar And please try to implement Taskbar so that I can switch to Yambar. Thanks in advance

dnkl commented 2021年04月07日 08:16:48 +02:00

We might add support for something corresponding to the xwindow module, using e.g. the foreign-toplevel-manager protocol. But a full blown task bar is unfortunately out of scope for yambar.

We might add support for something corresponding to the `xwindow` module, using e.g. the `foreign-toplevel-manager` protocol. But a full blown task bar is unfortunately out of scope for yambar.

AhmadRaniri commented 2021年10月14日 02:47:22 +02:00

We might add support for something corresponding to the xwindow module, using e.g. the foreign-toplevel-manager protocol. But a full blown task bar is unfortunately out of scope for yambar.

Thanks for the implementation, sir. Considering "taskbar for wayland compositor" is one of killer features, especially for stacking wayland compositor with foreign-toplevel-manager support. Glad to wait, I use yambar with hikari wayland compositor (as daily driver), but when I try labwc, I switch to waybar.

> We might add support for something corresponding to the `xwindow` module, using e.g. the `foreign-toplevel-manager` protocol. But a full blown task bar is unfortunately out of scope for yambar. Thanks for the implementation, sir. Considering "taskbar for wayland compositor" is one of killer features, especially for stacking wayland compositor with **foreign-toplevel-manager** support. Glad to wait, I use yambar with hikari wayland compositor (as daily driver), but when I try **labwc**, I switch to waybar.

AhmadRaniri commented 2021年10月14日 02:49:56 +02:00

I want to run yambar on Wayfire. But,i need it to have Taskbar. Taskbar can be achieved by foreign-toplevel-manager protocol.

Please see

https://github.com/Alexays/Waybar/wiki/Module:-Taskbar

And please try to implement Taskbar so that I can switch to Yambar.

Thanks in advance

No need to rush the developer, mate! if you like just use it, implement a feature need time and resource.

> I want to run yambar on Wayfire. But,i need it to have Taskbar. Taskbar can be achieved by foreign-toplevel-manager protocol. > > Please see > > https://github.com/Alexays/Waybar/wiki/Module:-Taskbar > > And please try to implement Taskbar so that I can switch to Yambar. > > Thanks in advance No need to rush the developer, mate! if you like just use it, implement a feature need time and resource.

tinywrkb commented 2022年01月23日 13:06:59 +01:00

https://pagure.io/fedora-workstation/issue/264

edit: More importantly, this https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/xdg/xdg-specs/-/issues/84

https://pagure.io/fedora-workstation/issue/264 **edit:** More importantly, this https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/xdg/xdg-specs/-/issues/84

txtsd commented 2022年02月16日 17:27:36 +01:00

I would also like this feature to switch over from waybar.

I would also like this feature to switch over from waybar.

je-vv commented 2025年01月12日 11:02:21 +01:00

Waybar's "wlr/taskbar" requires workarounds for several things, one of them to prevent it growing indefinitely as more apps get stacked, like preventing them to show up on the taskbar, :( See this issue for example. Other than, as a stacking compositor user, I'm hoping for taskbar, tray and idle-inhibitor to be eventually supported by yambar. But as this issue originated using waybar as a reference, I wanted to say there might be some better reference, and yes, perhaps as things currently are, waybar is like the option for stacking compositors like labwc (the compositor I use), but hoping for yambar to catch up eventually.

Waybar's "wlr/taskbar" requires workarounds for several things, one of them to prevent it growing indefinitely as more apps get stacked, like preventing them to show up on the taskbar, :( See this [issue](https://github.com/Alexays/Waybar/issues/2910) for example. Other than, as a stacking compositor user, I'm hoping for taskbar, tray and idle-inhibitor to be eventually supported by yambar. But as this issue originated using waybar as a reference, I wanted to say there might be some better reference, and yes, perhaps as things currently are, waybar is like the option for stacking compositors like labwc (the compositor I use), but hoping for yambar to catch up eventually.