Create a doc about network requirements #84

jeanbaptisteC commented 2026年05月13日 22:21:05 +02:00

To know more easily which neworks can be integrated in the, I suggest to create a doc with requirements foreach different type of networks (subway, train, light_rail)
It's can be a web page of the validator to improve visibility to our community

To know more easily which neworks can be integrated in the, I suggest to create a doc with requirements foreach different type of networks (subway, train, light_rail) It's can be a web page of the validator to improve visibility to our community

jeanbaptisteC commented 2026年05月25日 20:42:09 +02:00

Subway:

• relation route_master

  • having type=route_master
  • having a colour tag
  • having a ref tag
  • having a name tag
  • contains route relations

• relation route

  • having type=route
  • having type=subway
  • having a colour tag
  • having a ref tag
  • having a name tag
  • having a network tag that match with network tag from the route_master relation
  • contains stop_positions
    • having public_transport=stop_position tag
    • having railway=stop or railway=tram_stop tag
    • having subway=yes tag
  • contains platforms
    • having public_transport=platform tag
    • having railway=platform or railway=platform_edge tag
    • having subway=yes tag
    • contains railway tracks
      • having railway=subway tag
    • items should be order in the relations
      • stop_position/platform
      • tracks
    • each stop positions and platforms present in the relation should be inside a stop_area relation
    • having public_transport=stop_area tag
    • having type=public_transport tag
    • having name tag
    • the stop_area relation should contains also a station
      • having public_transport=station tag
      • having railway=station tag
      • having station=subway or railway=halt tag
      • having subway=yes tag
      • having a name tag
    • having multiple stop_area relation for different route is possible but require to use a stop_area_group and include stop_area relations inside
      • having name tag
      • having public_transport=stop_area_group tag
      • having type=public_transport tag

Subway: - relation route_master - having `type=route_master` - having a `colour` tag - having a `ref` tag - having a `name` tag - contains route relations - relation route - having `type=route` - having `type=subway` - having a `colour` tag - having a `ref` tag - having a `name` tag - having a `network` tag that match with `network` tag from the route_master relation - contains stop_positions - having `public_transport=stop_position` tag - having `railway=stop` or `railway=tram_stop` tag - having `subway=yes` tag - contains platforms - having `public_transport=platform` tag - having `railway=platform` or railway=`platform_edge` tag - having `subway=yes` tag - contains railway tracks - having `railway=subway` tag - items should be order in the relations - stop_position/platform - tracks - each stop positions and platforms present in the relation should be inside a stop_area relation - having `public_transport=stop_area` tag - having `type=public_transport` tag - having `name` tag - the stop_area relation should contains also a station - having `public_transport=station` tag - having `railway=station` tag - having `station=subway` or `railway=halt` tag - having `subway=yes` tag - having a `name` tag - having multiple stop_area relation for different route is possible but require to use a stop_area_group and include stop_area relations inside - having `name` tag - having `public_transport=stop_area_group` tag - having `type=public_transport` tag

jeanbaptisteC commented 2026年05月25日 20:45:13 +02:00

@Bovi887 review is appreciated to having a first valid version to know more easily which network can be integrated
I have planned to doing the same thing for light_rail and commuters train relations
Feel free to edit my comment or suggest a version in a different format

@Bovi887 review is appreciated to having a first valid version to know more easily which network can be integrated I have planned to doing the same thing for light_rail and commuters train relations Feel free to edit my comment or suggest a version in a different format