9
103
Fork
You've already forked web
30

Deeper links to Comaps/Osmand/... #906

Open
opened 2025年04月10日 10:25:58 +02:00 by laem · 11 comments
Owner
Copy link

Cartes.app won't cover all the use case perfectly covered by these apps.

E.g. for car navigation, we do not have this on our roadmap. A navigation mode would not be difficult to launch as a v1, but it would miss all the Android Auto and similar optimizations that Organic Maps is working on for years !

The best thing would be to direct the user to them.

Should we open a link with A->B in the URL ? How does it work ?

What about other features of these apps not covered, how to inform the user about them ?

See our wiki entry about Organic Maps #831

Cartes.app won't cover all the use case perfectly covered by these apps. E.g. for car navigation, we do not have this on our roadmap. A navigation mode would not be difficult to launch as a v1, but it would miss all the Android Auto and similar optimizations that Organic Maps is working on for years ! The best thing would be to direct the user to them. Should we open a link with A->B in the URL ? How does it work ? What about other features of these apps not covered, how to inform the user about them ? See our wiki entry about Organic Maps #831
Author
Owner
Copy link

⌚️1 day

⌚️1 day
Author
Owner
Copy link

@westnordost if you think of some ways to direct cartes.app users to StreetComplete, that would be cool ! I don't have any precise idea but we can probably find some.

@westnordost if you think of some ways to direct cartes.app users to StreetComplete, that would be cool ! I don't have any precise idea but we can probably find some.
westnordost commented 2025年04月23日 17:12:39 +02:00 (Migrated from github.com)
Copy link

Me neither.

Me neither.
laem changed title from (削除) Deeper links to Organic/Osmand/... (削除ここまで) to Deeper links to Compas/Osmand/... 2026年02月26日 18:00:46 +01:00
laem changed title from (削除) Deeper links to Compas/Osmand/... (削除ここまで) to Deeper links to Comaps/Osmand/... 2026年02月26日 18:00:51 +01:00
Author
Owner
Copy link
  • The first step is done : a comaps style in cartes.app. See !1699 to make it even better
- [x] The first step is done : a comaps style in cartes.app. See !1699 to make it even better
Author
Owner
Copy link

@jeanbaptistec, do you know if it's easy to open an itinerary link from a website to open Comaps on mobile ?

From cartes.app, it's easy to download the GPX. But then, opening them in Comaps on my Android has multiple UX problems :

  • the GPX is added as a favorite but the map doesn't zoom on it
  • the GPX becomes a trace, not an itinerary : what we want here is for Comaps to handle navigation from A to B with the chosen mode (car, walk, bike), including intermediate points if possible

Is there some kind of Android intent URL that would trigger this ? Is it easy to implement on your side ?

@jeanbaptistec, do you know if it's easy to open an itinerary link from a website to open Comaps on mobile ? From cartes.app, it's easy to download the GPX. But then, opening them in Comaps on my Android has multiple UX problems : - the GPX is added as a favorite but the map doesn't zoom on it - the GPX becomes a trace, not an itinerary : what we want here is for Comaps to handle navigation from A to B with the chosen mode (car, walk, bike), including intermediate points if possible Is there some kind of Android intent URL that would trigger this ? Is it easy to implement on your side ?
Contributor
Copy link

You can find more details about our api here

About gpx, zoom is applied only when users select it in the list, because I think it's not easy to manage to zoom on places or tracks if users import multiple tracks or favorites during the same import
Use gpx like a route is the most asked feature comaps/comaps#251 but for now anyone members or contributors work on this feature.

You can find more details about our api [here](https://comaps.at/api) About gpx, zoom is applied only when users select it in the list, because I think it's not easy to manage to zoom on places or tracks if users import multiple tracks or favorites during the same import Use gpx like a route is the most asked feature https://codeberg.org/comaps/comaps/issues/251 but for now anyone members or contributors work on this feature.
Author
Owner
Copy link

Oh yeah, found it ! https://comaps.at/api

Done ! For now, we'll limit this link to Comaps only, as per the idea that cartes.app is for the general public, whereas Osmand is more for more technical users.

image
image

Oh yeah, found it ! https://comaps.at/api Done ! For now, we'll limit this link to Comaps only, as per the idea that cartes.app is for the general public, whereas Osmand is more for more technical users. ![image](/attachments/37ca35af-a2fa-4dc2-b349-8ac3a77c0d5a) ![image](/attachments/2a668a2c-05e2-4b82-a298-1d71d1887f47)
Author
Owner
Copy link

Demo here : https://bsky.app/profile/cartes.app/post/3mfruld7m7k2h

Demo here : https://bsky.app/profile/cartes.app/post/3mfruld7m7k2h
Author
Owner
Copy link

@jeanbaptisteC je crois qu'ouvrir une fois après l'autre un intent fait planter Comaps.

@jeanbaptisteC je crois qu'ouvrir une fois après l'autre un intent fait planter Comaps.
Contributor
Copy link

Ca fonctionne bien de mon côté t'as un exemple?

Ca fonctionne bien de mon côté t'as un exemple?
Author
Owner
Copy link

Linked : comaps/url-processor#16

Linked : https://codeberg.org/comaps/url-processor/issues/16
Sign in to join this conversation.
No Branch/Tag specified
master
abostats
SynchroM-master
gps
embeddings
lysios-patch-5
lysios-patch-4
lysios-patch-3
lysios-patch-2
lysios-patch-1
abo-serveur2
clim
zone-en-favori
categories_toujours_visibles
rechercher_ici_avant_resultats
test-2365
panoramax-contribution
add-categories-validations
gel-bug-prod
osm-note-2
broken
wikidata_booking
fuse7.3
lysios-patrimoine-3
gps2
atproto-fix-2
styles-secondaires-mais-maison
atproto-scopes
itineraire-printemps-2026
modal-sheet-5.6
nlnet-cost-climate-perf
pb-icones-religieux
couvoiture
etiennejr-patch-2
meteo-fainéante
logo-static-url
poc-page-vitrine
remove-compass
test-reproduce-1795
display-cycleway-lanes-2
poc-image
add-media-condition
mapterhorn
test-indoor-equal
outdoors-VS-indoorEqual
hiking-colors
fix-blog-typing
poc-next-international
fix-map-style-modal-not-closing
i18n
hide-odd-zoom-levels
filter_categories
resume_wikipedia
deplacement_bouttons
fix-1095
mobile_permettre_selection
position-carte-initiale
dégradé-icônes
better_wikipedia
affichage_donnees_wikidata
mobile-permettre-selection
avis-details
perf-seo
modal-sheet-5
plans-novembre
display-cycleway-lanes
fix-1227
fix-1234
etiennejr-patch-1
update-1240
fix-1236
fix-1131
photon-search-street
fix-1221
article-avis
net-haut-zoom
baies-moins-visibles
belles-fiches-lieu
fix-1157
bug-page-vie-privée
use-watername
fix-1176
carte-du-onde
fix-1166
page-news
tchou
add-icon-alias
vitesse
photon-opensearch
private-in-italic
bâtiments-3D
merge-categories
handle-private-highway
improve-findcategory
injection-pmtiles
fix-1128
check-icons
update-readme
category-rugby
bug-position-carte-vs-lieu
limites-vitesse
improve-find-category-from-tags-v2
integrer
document-osmfeature
translate-document
velo-fin-aout-25
velo-ete-2025
moins-de-maptiler
planet-pmtiles-tilemaker
fix-1048
panoramax-leger
plume
horaires-i18n
planet
maj-deps-juillet-2025
improve-find-category-from-tags
bug-encart
interactions-encart-mobile
clic-on-station
fix-1028
fix-1014
edit
add-big-rivers
add-shortbread-tiles
handle-deleted-osm-elements-v2
codeberg
improve-useEffect
immoloc
update-dashboard
analyze
terradraw
sombre2
calendar
poi-sprites-using-svg
style-sombre
sprites
annuaire
motis-gtfs-attributes
next-styled-components
dev
cool2
cool
panoramax-angle
env-static-urls
borders-only
panoramax2
intelligence
debug-iles
nouveau-serveur
france-protomaps
turbo
fouss/cartes-#338
blog2
legislatives
presentation
pas-de-geoloc-si-hash-different
protomaps
vaul
carte-trains
citiz
maj-paquets
icones
ui2
bblog
voyagevoyage
test-image-origine
bugimagefin
searchParams
voyage
avion
perf
studio
piscine
journée
année
journée-transition
score-dès-acceuil
fix-space-problem
rebase-5août
correspondance
règles-séparées
indeps-acre
demo
indeps
indeps-cachés
indication-temps-plein
indeps-refactor-simulations
indeps-vue-comparaison
indeps-inversion
barème-continu
indeps-démo
textes-branches-sécu
engine-enum
2019
transport
publicodes
as
infrance-nouvelle-landing
better-translation
co2
simplifATMP
controle-SMIC
webi18n
bug-avantages-en-nature
revert-352-infrance-navigation-v2
laem-patch-1
robots.txt
improve-perf
iframe-bugfix
quickfixes
lib
irsimple
hiringinfrance.com
dégradé
refstate
johan
zrr
logo-interactif
revert-216-improve-tracking
redesign2
zrr2
fixtrad
correction-salaire-brut
petit-state
alien-consolidate
translate-ui
npm
alien-brut-net
translatable
différent
ir18
fix-typo
add-tracking
fix-collect-missing
défauts-partout
fix-double-unfold-three
fix-double-unfold
versement-transport
blocker-questions
v3
v2.1
v2
v1
v0.6.4
v0.6.3
v0.6.2
v0.6.1
v0.6.0
0.7.0
v0.5.1
v0.5.0
v0.4.2
v0.4.1
v0.4.0
v0.3.3
v0.3.2
v0.3.1
v0.3
v0.2
v0.1-cdd-alpha
v0-démo-tag-nav
Labels
Clear labels
🎨 Design
À propos de l'interface et de l'UX
💡 Idée
Nouvelle feature à intégrer
❓ question
Further information is requested
🌍 OSM
À propos de l'affichage et l'édition des éléments OSM
🌱 Amélioration
Amélioration/fix de l'existant
🐞 Bug
Something isn't working
📊 SEO
📋 Catégories
À propos des catégories de recherche et de l'annuaire
📖 Wiki
📝Avis
A propos de la fonction avis et de bluesky
📢 Oyez
📷 Photos
A propos des photos (sources, affichage)
🔍Recherche
A propos de la barre de recherche et de photon
🔥 Actuel
🔧 tech
🖌 Styles
Styles de la carte
🧝i18n
🧪 R&D
🚍 Transports
🚙 Voiture
🚨Prioritaire
Ticket à traiter rapidement
🚲Vélo
Cartes
climat
Communication
demo
Cette branche doit être déployée comme une démo
dependencies
Pull requests that update a dependency file
javascript
Pull requests that update javascript code
Pas urgent
Plein-air
Tuiles
Verso
Vieux
Milestone
Clear milestone
No items
No milestone
Projects
Clear projects
No items
No project
Assignees
Clear assignees
No assignees
3 participants
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference
cartes/web#906
Reference in a new issue
cartes/web
No description provided.
Delete branch "%!s()"

Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?