Element X does not work #8

Atemu commented 2025年01月25日 18:32:08 +01:00

According to its debug menu, it gets a 404. (See attached screenshot.)

I tried changing the UP provider to https://ntfy.sh but sunup somehow doesn't recognise it as a UP provider?

According to its debug menu, it gets a 404. (See attached screenshot.) I tried changing the UP provider to https://ntfy.sh but sunup somehow doesn't recognise it as a UP provider?

balint commented 2025年01月27日 15:03:08 +01:00

I have the same issue. Mercurygram doesn't work either.

I have the same issue. Mercurygram doesn't work either.

s1m commented 2025年01月27日 15:19:09 +01:00

@Atemu wrote in #8 (comment):

According to its debug menu, it gets a 404. (See attached screenshot.)

I tried changing the UP provider to https://ntfy.sh but sunup somehow doesn't recognise it as a UP provider?

There is a bug in Element-X, the patch is merged but not yet released. Shildinext has already the fix

@Atemu wrote in https://codeberg.org/Sunup/android/issues/8#issue-959745: > According to its debug menu, it gets a 404. (See attached screenshot.) > > I tried changing the UP provider to https://ntfy.sh but sunup somehow doesn't recognise it as a UP provider? There is a bug in Element-X, the patch is merged but not yet released. Shildinext has already the fix

s1m commented 2025年01月27日 15:20:07 +01:00

@balint wrote in #8 (comment):

I have the same issue. Mercurygram doesn't work either.

They don't use webpush, which is now required. Maybe they can use a gateway for that

@balint wrote in https://codeberg.org/Sunup/android/issues/8#issuecomment-2655061: > I have the same issue. Mercurygram doesn't work either. They don't use webpush, which is now required. Maybe they can use a gateway for that

Atemu commented 2025年01月27日 20:42:50 +01:00

Indeed Schildichat Next does work!

It's still weird that I can't switch to ntfy.sh as the UP server though; what's up with that?

Indeed Schildichat Next does work! It's still weird that I can't switch to ntfy.sh as the UP server though; what's up with that?

s1m commented 2025年01月28日 09:00:54 +01:00

Because sunup isn't a ntfy client. It uses mozilla's autopush server

Because sunup isn't a ntfy client. It uses mozilla's autopush server

wrenix commented 2025年01月29日 16:32:14 +01:00

Intro:

Matrix does not support UnifiedPush or WebPush native.
Here is a MSC to support WebPush (and with it UnifiedPush) in there protocol Standard: https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals/pull/4174

Current state:

We need a transformation between the Matrix Push to the UnifiedPush API format.
Therefore was common-proxy from UnifiedPush developed: https://codeberg.org/UnifiedPush/common-proxies

SchildiChat run this proxy (but Mozilla not).

This translation from matrix to UnifiedPush is native implemented into ntfy.sh (so you do not need common-proxy to run, if you run ntfy.sh).

Other matrix-client like Element(-X) has to solutions:

• wait till MSC4174 is defined and implemented
• run a own autopush-rs (the WebPush server from Mozilla) with common-proxy (or use my one https://push.chaos.fyi)
• use a different UnifiedPush-Provider till MSC4174 is ready

Maybe more details here: https://github.com/element-hq/element-x-android/pull/3388#issuecomment-2451406904

## Intro: Matrix does not support UnifiedPush or WebPush native. Here is a MSC to support WebPush (and with it UnifiedPush) in there protocol Standard: https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals/pull/4174 ## Current state: We need a transformation between the Matrix Push to the UnifiedPush API format. Therefore was common-proxy from UnifiedPush developed: https://codeberg.org/UnifiedPush/common-proxies SchildiChat run this proxy (but Mozilla not). This translation from matrix to UnifiedPush is native implemented into ntfy.sh (so you do not need common-proxy to run, if you run ntfy.sh). Other matrix-client like Element(-X) has to solutions: - wait till MSC4174 is defined and implemented - run a own autopush-rs (the WebPush server from Mozilla) with common-proxy (or use my one https://push.chaos.fyi) - use a different UnifiedPush-Provider till MSC4174 is ready Maybe more details here: https://github.com/element-hq/element-x-android/pull/3388#issuecomment-2451406904

s1m commented 2025年01月29日 16:37:46 +01:00

Element-X is supposed to use the gateway hosted on unifiedpush.org, but they have introduced a bug a few versions ago that prevented to use it. It has been fixed here: https://github.com/element-hq/element-x-android/pull/4101 but this is not released yet

Element-X is supposed to use the gateway hosted on unifiedpush.org, but they have introduced a bug a few versions ago that prevented to use it. It has been fixed here: https://github.com/element-hq/element-x-android/pull/4101 but this is not released yet

s1m commented 2025年02月04日 13:30:40 +01:00

It has been released: https://github.com/element-hq/element-x-android/releases/tag/v25.02.0

It has been released: https://github.com/element-hq/element-x-android/releases/tag/v25.02.0