Downed state - 0% health is not the end! #183

Crystalwarrior commented 2022年08月10日 16:41:09 +02:00 (Migrated from github.com)

Reaching 0% health does not kill the player entirely, but puts them into a Downed state. Similar to Exhaustion status effect, the player cannot move. In this state, the player will die if their health reaches -100%. Other players are able to carry the Downed/Exhausted player. Some damage sources will skip the Downed state entirely, such as lava, suffocation, drowning. Downed state can be escaped by resting in a bed with all-OK status or health-recovering items. Other players carrying you can put you in bed. Hostile mobs ignore Downed players.

Inspired by Rimworld downed state mechanics, this might introduce an additional layer of camaraderie and emergent stories of saving your friends or carrying prisoners in a multiplayer environment. In a single player environment, it introduces a safenet for the player in case they have health-recovering items or a bed they can place to recover from death.

Reaching 0% health does not kill the player entirely, but puts them into a Downed state. Similar to Exhaustion status effect, the player cannot move. In this state, the player will die if their health reaches -100%. Other players are able to carry the Downed/Exhausted player. Some damage sources will skip the Downed state entirely, such as lava, suffocation, drowning. Downed state can be escaped by resting in a bed with all-OK status or health-recovering items. Other players carrying you can put you in bed. Hostile mobs ignore Downed players. Inspired by Rimworld downed state mechanics, this might introduce an additional layer of camaraderie and emergent stories of saving your friends or carrying prisoners in a multiplayer environment. In a single player environment, it introduces a safenet for the player in case they have health-recovering items or a bed they can place to recover from death.

jeremyshannon commented 2022年08月11日 05:18:09 +02:00 (Migrated from github.com)

I really like this idea! It would probably need to be disabled in singleplayer, as it would be insufficiently different from death with no other players to help you.

I really like this idea! It would probably need to be disabled in singleplayer, as it would be insufficiently different from death with no other players to help you.

Crystalwarrior commented 2022年08月11日 05:21:27 +02:00 (Migrated from github.com)

Disabling it in single player makes sense

Disabling it in single player makes sense

DokimiCU commented 2022年08月17日 09:46:49 +02:00 (Migrated from github.com)

Multiplayer ideas are cool!

I would only caution against immobilizing players. It robs people of agency. They can't do anything. (This is already a slight issue). Maybe always leave people the ability to crawl slowly.

Multiplayer ideas are cool! I would only caution against immobilizing players. It robs people of agency. They can't do anything. (This is already a slight issue). Maybe always leave people the ability to crawl slowly.

Crystalwarrior commented 2022年08月17日 11:08:09 +02:00 (Migrated from github.com)

Multiplayer ideas are cool!

I would only caution against immobilizing players. It robs people of agency. They can't do anything. (This is already a slight issue). Maybe always leave people the ability to crawl slowly.

I agree with agency, being able to crawl is cool

> Multiplayer ideas are cool! > > I would only caution against immobilizing players. It robs people of agency. They can't do anything. (This is already a slight issue). Maybe always leave people the ability to crawl slowly. I agree with agency, being able to crawl is cool

Yad commented 2026年07月05日 00:45:08 +02:00

@Mantar wrote in #183 (comment):

I really like this idea! It would probably need to be disabled in singleplayer, as it would be insufficiently different from death with no other players to help you.

Unless we allow players to have multiple characters in single-player, allowing the player to appear as a new exile to rush to save the dying exile — and/or if we implement NPCs such that the player can shift to controlling another character in the tribe. 🙃

@Mantar wrote in https://codeberg.org/Mantar/Exile/issues/183#issuecomment-652397: > I really like this idea! It would probably need to be disabled in singleplayer, as it would be insufficiently different from death with no other players to help you. Unless we allow players to have multiple characters in single-player, allowing the player to appear as a new exile to rush to save the dying exile — and/or if we implement NPCs such that the player can shift to controlling another character in the tribe. 🙃