Support for Omitted .html Extension on Codeberg Pages #1694

mshibanami commented 2024年11月03日 16:27:20 +01:00

Comment

Hi, I have an HTML file hosted on Codeberg Pages at this URL:

https://mshibanami.codeberg.page/jisk/invidious.html

My question is: if I omit the .html extension, as shown below, should this still be a valid permalink?

https://mshibanami.codeberg.page/jisk/invidious

Currently, the server returns a 307 Temporary Redirect and redirects back to the original URL with the .html extension. Based on issue #177, it appears Codeberg Pages supported omitting the .html extension about 4 years ago. Is this understanding correct? Has this feature been deprecated?

Could this difference be due to issue #177 referencing https://pages.codeberg.org/ rather than https://username.codeberg.page/? Is there a possibility that username.codeberg.page could support this behavior in the future?

Background

I also host the same HTML page on GitHub Pages at: https://mshibanami.github.io/jisk/invidious
On GitHub Pages, the URL without the .html extension works as expected, but Codeberg Pages does not allow this.

### Comment Hi, I have an HTML file hosted on Codeberg Pages at this URL: <https://mshibanami.codeberg.page/jisk/invidious.html> My question is: if I omit the `.html` extension, as shown below, should this still be a valid permalink? <https://mshibanami.codeberg.page/jisk/invidious> Currently, the server returns a `307 Temporary Redirect` and redirects back to the original URL with the `.html` extension. Based on issue #177, it appears Codeberg Pages supported omitting the `.html` extension about 4 years ago. Is this understanding correct? Has this feature been deprecated? Could this difference be due to issue #177 referencing `https://pages.codeberg.org/` rather than `https://username.codeberg.page/`? Is there a possibility that `username.codeberg.page` could support this behavior in the future? ## Background I also host the same HTML page on GitHub Pages at: <https://mshibanami.github.io/jisk/invidious> On GitHub Pages, the URL without the `.html` extension works as expected, but Codeberg Pages does not allow this.

Gusted commented 2024年11月03日 16:56:46 +01:00

My question is: if I omit the .html extension, as shown below, should this still be a valid permalink?

https://mshibanami.codeberg.page/jisk/invidious

Yes.

Currently, the server returns a 307 Temporary Redirect and redirects back to the original URL with the .html extension. Based on issue #177, it appears Codeberg Pages supported omitting the .html extension about 4 years ago. Is this understanding correct? Has this feature been deprecated?

This is from the old pages server implementation, it still works and is an feature however the behavior is to redirect to the canonical link. This behavior is tracked at Codeberg/pages-server#298

> My question is: if I omit the .html extension, as shown below, should this still be a valid permalink? > > https://mshibanami.codeberg.page/jisk/invidious Yes. > Currently, the server returns a 307 Temporary Redirect and redirects back to the original URL with the .html extension. Based on issue #177, it appears Codeberg Pages supported omitting the .html extension about 4 years ago. Is this understanding correct? Has this feature been deprecated? This is from the old pages server implementation, it still works and is an feature however the behavior is to redirect to the canonical link. This behavior is tracked at https://codeberg.org/Codeberg/pages-server/issues/298

mshibanami commented 2024年11月04日 02:05:29 +01:00

Oh, thanks a lot for the details. I understand now. At least I'm glad it's on their milestone.
I'm closing this issue now. Thanks!

Oh, thanks a lot for the details. I understand now. At least I'm glad it's on their milestone. I'm closing this issue now. Thanks!