Message 261181 - Python tracker

➜

This issue tracker has been migrated to GitHub , and is currently read-only.
For more information, see the GitHub FAQs in the Python's Developer Guide.

In-reply-to
Author	methane
Recipients	alecsandru.patrascu, brett.cannon, gregory.p.smith, lemburg, methane, pitrou, r.david.murray, scoder, skrah, steve.dower, zach.ware
Date	2016年03月04日.01:32:38
SpamBayes Score	-1.0
Marked as misclassified	Yes
Message-id	<1457055162.46.0.101182280758.issue25702@psf.upfronthosting.co.za>

Content
I've tried LTO without PGO in Debian Jessie. $ LTOFLAGS='-flto -fuse-linker-plugin -ffat-lto-objects -flto-partition=none' $ CFLAGS=$LTOFLAGS LDFLAGS=$LTOFLAGS ./configure --prefix=... $ make -j32 results is here (compared with neither LTO and PGO): Test minimum run-time average run-time this other diff this other diff ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- BuiltinFunctionCalls: 47ms 50ms -6.6% 48ms 51ms -6.0% BuiltinMethodLookup: 29ms 29ms -1.3% 29ms 29ms -0.1% CompareFloats: 32ms 33ms -2.8% 34ms 34ms -0.5% CompareFloatsIntegers: 67ms 70ms -3.9% 69ms 71ms -3.1% CompareIntegers: 48ms 46ms +5.1% 49ms 47ms +5.8% CompareInternedStrings: 30ms 31ms -1.9% 31ms 31ms -1.6% CompareLongs: 28ms 26ms +8.0% 29ms 27ms +8.5% CompareStrings: 26ms 26ms -0.9% 27ms 26ms +1.5% ComplexPythonFunctionCalls: 47ms 51ms -8.9% 48ms 52ms -7.8% ConcatStrings: 32ms 33ms -3.2% 33ms 34ms -2.2% CreateInstances: 51ms 52ms -2.5% 52ms 53ms -3.5% CreateNewInstances: 38ms 40ms -4.5% 39ms 41ms -4.4% CreateStringsWithConcat: 68ms 69ms -1.4% 70ms 71ms -0.4% DictCreation: 53ms 51ms +5.2% 55ms 52ms +6.7% DictWithFloatKeys: 41ms 42ms -2.2% 43ms 43ms -0.0% DictWithIntegerKeys: 34ms 34ms +0.1% 35ms 35ms +0.5% DictWithStringKeys: 31ms 32ms -1.3% 32ms 32ms -1.6% ForLoops: 26ms 30ms -12.1% 28ms 30ms -8.7% IfThenElse: 42ms 41ms +2.6% 43ms 41ms +5.0% ListSlicing: 40ms 40ms -0.8% 41ms 41ms -0.4% NestedForLoops: 42ms 42ms -0.3% 43ms 43ms +0.6% NestedListComprehensions: 42ms 47ms -11.9% 45ms 50ms -10.5% NormalClassAttribute: 89ms 96ms -7.9% 92ms 98ms -5.9% NormalInstanceAttribute: 47ms 45ms +4.8% 48ms 45ms +4.9% PythonFunctionCalls: 41ms 44ms -7.5% 41ms 45ms -7.4% PythonMethodCalls: 53ms 59ms -9.4% 55ms 60ms -8.5% Recursion: 69ms 73ms -5.1% 71ms 74ms -4.2% SecondImport: 36ms 41ms -12.0% 38ms 42ms -9.9% SecondPackageImport: 45ms 42ms +6.5% 46ms 43ms +7.0% SecondSubmoduleImport: 115ms 107ms +7.9% 117ms 108ms +7.9% SimpleComplexArithmetic: 27ms 29ms -6.5% 28ms 30ms -4.5% SimpleDictManipulation: 60ms 65ms -7.8% 61ms 66ms -7.0% SimpleFloatArithmetic: 33ms 30ms +7.4% 34ms 31ms +8.3% SimpleIntFloatArithmetic: 36ms 38ms -3.3% 37ms 38ms -4.0% SimpleIntegerArithmetic: 36ms 38ms -5.2% 37ms 38ms -4.1% SimpleListComprehensions: 36ms 37ms -3.2% 38ms 41ms -7.5% SimpleListManipulation: 34ms 34ms -1.3% 35ms 38ms -6.8% SimpleLongArithmetic: 26ms 26ms +0.3% 27ms 30ms -7.5% SmallLists: 45ms 47ms -4.1% 46ms 56ms -17.2% SmallTuples: 51ms 54ms -6.3% 53ms 62ms -14.8% SpecialClassAttribute: 92ms 97ms -5.0% 95ms 99ms -4.8% SpecialInstanceAttribute: 46ms 45ms +2.5% 48ms 46ms +3.9% StringMappings: 71ms 100ms -29.0% 73ms 101ms -27.8% StringPredicates: 49ms 59ms -17.8% 50ms 60ms -16.5% StringSlicing: 48ms 47ms +3.3% 79ms 47ms +66.2% TryExcept: 24ms 29ms -16.9% 25ms 30ms -15.8% TryFinally: 35ms 37ms -6.0% 36ms 38ms -4.6% TryRaiseExcept: 12ms 13ms -7.5% 13ms 14ms -7.2% TupleSlicing: 48ms 50ms -2.9% 49ms 51ms -2.7% WithFinally: 52ms 57ms -8.4% 53ms 58ms -8.2% WithRaiseExcept: 42ms 46ms -8.8% 43ms 47ms -9.1% ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Totals: 2291ms 2398ms -4.5% 2390ms 2470ms -3.2% (this=lto.pybench, other=default.pybench)

Content

I've tried LTO without PGO in Debian Jessie.
$ LTOFLAGS='-flto -fuse-linker-plugin -ffat-lto-objects -flto-partition=none'
$ CFLAGS=$LTOFLAGS LDFLAGS=$LTOFLAGS ./configure --prefix=...
$ make -j32
results is here (compared with neither LTO and PGO):
Test minimum run-time average run-time
 this other diff this other diff
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 BuiltinFunctionCalls: 47ms 50ms -6.6% 48ms 51ms -6.0%
 BuiltinMethodLookup: 29ms 29ms -1.3% 29ms 29ms -0.1%
 CompareFloats: 32ms 33ms -2.8% 34ms 34ms -0.5%
 CompareFloatsIntegers: 67ms 70ms -3.9% 69ms 71ms -3.1%
 CompareIntegers: 48ms 46ms +5.1% 49ms 47ms +5.8%
 CompareInternedStrings: 30ms 31ms -1.9% 31ms 31ms -1.6%
 CompareLongs: 28ms 26ms +8.0% 29ms 27ms +8.5%
 CompareStrings: 26ms 26ms -0.9% 27ms 26ms +1.5%
 ComplexPythonFunctionCalls: 47ms 51ms -8.9% 48ms 52ms -7.8%
 ConcatStrings: 32ms 33ms -3.2% 33ms 34ms -2.2%
 CreateInstances: 51ms 52ms -2.5% 52ms 53ms -3.5%
 CreateNewInstances: 38ms 40ms -4.5% 39ms 41ms -4.4%
 CreateStringsWithConcat: 68ms 69ms -1.4% 70ms 71ms -0.4%
 DictCreation: 53ms 51ms +5.2% 55ms 52ms +6.7%
 DictWithFloatKeys: 41ms 42ms -2.2% 43ms 43ms -0.0%
 DictWithIntegerKeys: 34ms 34ms +0.1% 35ms 35ms +0.5%
 DictWithStringKeys: 31ms 32ms -1.3% 32ms 32ms -1.6%
 ForLoops: 26ms 30ms -12.1% 28ms 30ms -8.7%
 IfThenElse: 42ms 41ms +2.6% 43ms 41ms +5.0%
 ListSlicing: 40ms 40ms -0.8% 41ms 41ms -0.4%
 NestedForLoops: 42ms 42ms -0.3% 43ms 43ms +0.6%
 NestedListComprehensions: 42ms 47ms -11.9% 45ms 50ms -10.5%
 NormalClassAttribute: 89ms 96ms -7.9% 92ms 98ms -5.9%
 NormalInstanceAttribute: 47ms 45ms +4.8% 48ms 45ms +4.9%
 PythonFunctionCalls: 41ms 44ms -7.5% 41ms 45ms -7.4%
 PythonMethodCalls: 53ms 59ms -9.4% 55ms 60ms -8.5%
 Recursion: 69ms 73ms -5.1% 71ms 74ms -4.2%
 SecondImport: 36ms 41ms -12.0% 38ms 42ms -9.9%
 SecondPackageImport: 45ms 42ms +6.5% 46ms 43ms +7.0%
 SecondSubmoduleImport: 115ms 107ms +7.9% 117ms 108ms +7.9%
 SimpleComplexArithmetic: 27ms 29ms -6.5% 28ms 30ms -4.5%
 SimpleDictManipulation: 60ms 65ms -7.8% 61ms 66ms -7.0%
 SimpleFloatArithmetic: 33ms 30ms +7.4% 34ms 31ms +8.3%
 SimpleIntFloatArithmetic: 36ms 38ms -3.3% 37ms 38ms -4.0%
 SimpleIntegerArithmetic: 36ms 38ms -5.2% 37ms 38ms -4.1%
 SimpleListComprehensions: 36ms 37ms -3.2% 38ms 41ms -7.5%
 SimpleListManipulation: 34ms 34ms -1.3% 35ms 38ms -6.8%
 SimpleLongArithmetic: 26ms 26ms +0.3% 27ms 30ms -7.5%
 SmallLists: 45ms 47ms -4.1% 46ms 56ms -17.2%
 SmallTuples: 51ms 54ms -6.3% 53ms 62ms -14.8%
 SpecialClassAttribute: 92ms 97ms -5.0% 95ms 99ms -4.8%
 SpecialInstanceAttribute: 46ms 45ms +2.5% 48ms 46ms +3.9%
 StringMappings: 71ms 100ms -29.0% 73ms 101ms -27.8%
 StringPredicates: 49ms 59ms -17.8% 50ms 60ms -16.5%
 StringSlicing: 48ms 47ms +3.3% 79ms 47ms +66.2%
 TryExcept: 24ms 29ms -16.9% 25ms 30ms -15.8%
 TryFinally: 35ms 37ms -6.0% 36ms 38ms -4.6%
 TryRaiseExcept: 12ms 13ms -7.5% 13ms 14ms -7.2%
 TupleSlicing: 48ms 50ms -2.9% 49ms 51ms -2.7%
 WithFinally: 52ms 57ms -8.4% 53ms 58ms -8.2%
 WithRaiseExcept: 42ms 46ms -8.8% 43ms 47ms -9.1%
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Totals: 2291ms 2398ms -4.5% 2390ms 2470ms -3.2%
(this=lto.pybench, other=default.pybench)

History
Date	User	Action	Args
2016年03月04日 01:32:42	methane	set	recipients: + methane, lemburg, brett.cannon, gregory.p.smith, pitrou, scoder, r.david.murray, skrah, zach.ware, steve.dower, alecsandru.patrascu
2016年03月04日 01:32:42	methane	set	messageid: <1457055162.46.0.101182280758.issue25702@psf.upfronthosting.co.za>
2016年03月04日 01:32:42	methane	link	issue25702 messages
2016年03月04日 01:32:38	methane	create

homepage