1998$BG/(B3$B7n(B17$BF|(B 1948$BG/(B1$B7n$N(BGATT($B4X@G5Z$SKG0W$K4X$9$k0lHL6(Dj(B)$B$NH/8z0JMh(B50$BG/$r7P2a$7$?!#$3$N4V!"(B
$BB>J}!"(BGATT$B$+$i(BWTO$BBN@)$K0\9T$7$F$+$i(B3$BG/$,7P2a$7$?$,!"0lIt$N2CLA9q$K$*$$$F0MA3$H$7$F(BWTO$B6(Dj$"$k$$$OM}G0$KH?$9$k$H;W$o$l$kJ]8n $BB>J}!"2CLA9q$K$h$k6(Dj$d3F9g0U$N=e
$B$3$&$7$?EXNO$K2C$(!"5^B.$J%0%m!<%p%k2=$,?je8$9$k$j$+!"(bwto$b$o4d6-!"ej;q!"6%ah@/:v$h$$$c$??7$?$j2]bj$kbp$9$k9q:]e*9g0u$n7a@.$k8~$1@q6ke*$k $BCO0hKG0W6(Dj$H(BWTO$B6(Dj$H$N@09g@-$N3NJ](B $B%"%s%A!&%@%s%T%s%0A $B@/I\D4C#6(Dj$NDyLs9q$N3HBg$HE,MQ=|30$N:o8:(B $BCNE*:b;:J]8n$N6/2=(B $B86;:CO5,B'$ND4OB:n6H$N?d?J(B $BES>e9q$N9qFb;:6HJ]8n$rL\E*$H$7$?@/:v!&A UR$B8r>D$N7k2L!"J6Ah=hM}5!G=$,6/2=$5$l$?$3$H$O9b$/I>2A$5$l$k$,!"Ho32$r$^$l$k!#(B $BJ6Ah2r7h $B2CLA9q$KBP$9$k4F;kBN@)$N6/2=(B WTO$BHs2CLA9q$NB?$/$O!"4X@G@/:v!"CNE*:b;:8"J]8n!"30;q@/:v$J$I$NLL$G!"B?$/$NLdBj$rJz$($F$$$k!#2C$($F!"9qFbK!$N&@/:v$NF)L@@-$r9b$a$F$$$/I,MW$,$"$k!#(B $BKG0W$H4D6-LdBj$X$N@:NOE* $BEj;q$N<+m32=$k8~$1$?8r>D$N3+;O(B $BKG0W$H6%AhLdBj$X$N 1995$BG/$N(BWTO$B@_N)0J9_$b!"(BITA($B>pJs5;=Q6(Dj(B)$B$NDy7k!"4pK\EE5$DL?.<+m32=8r>D$J$i$S$K6bM;%5!<%s%9<+m32=8r>D$N=*7k$J$I!"0lAX$NKG0W<+m32=$,?d?j$5$l$f$-$?$3$h$r4?7^$9$k!#8=:_8!f$cf$n(bita$b$n2cla9q5z$sbp>]IJL\$N3HBg(B($BNc$($P!"(BDVD$B%W%l!<%d!<$d%+!pJs2HEEJ,Ln(B)$B$K2C$(!"?7$?$JJ,LnJL<+m32=8r>D$H$7$F!"A0=R$NM}M3$+$i4D6-4XO"5!4o$N4X@GE1GQ8r>D$,Aa5^$KK>$^$l$k!#(B WTO$B$NBP>]NN0h$N3HBg$KH<$$!"(bwto$b$o%s%8%m%93hf0$k1w!9bg$-$j1f6a$rm?$($k$h$&$k$j$c$f$*$j!"(bwto$b$hl14v4k6h$h$n4x78$n6/2=$,k>$^$l$k!#(B
$B0J>e$N$h$&$K!"(B21$B@$5*$K8~$1!"(BWTO$B$N0lAX$N5!G=6/2=$d99$J$kKG0W$N<+m32=$*$h$s?7$?$jj,ln$g$n%k!<%k$n:vdj$,5^l3$h$j$c$f$$$k!#$3$&$7$?$j$+$o$,9q@/i\$,6/$$%j!<%@!<%7%c%w$rh/4x$7!":#8e$n5do@$d8r>D$r%j!<%i$7$f$$$/$3$h$r6/$/4|bt$9$k!#(b $B0J(B $B>e(B ($BCm(B)$B7PCDO"0U8+=q(B$B!VG@6H4pK\K!$N8+D>$7$K4X$9$kDs8@!W(B(1997$BG/(B9$B7n(B)$B$h$jH4?h(B $B0J(B $B>e(B
($B
21$B@$5*$K8~$1!"0z$-B3$-Fs9q4V;j>e
$B$J$I$NLdBj$KD>LL$7$F$$$k!#(B
$B$3$l$rJ|CV$9$l$P(BWTO$B$KBP$9$k?.Mj$O<:df$7!"b?3qe*kg0wbn@)$n:,44$rmi$k$,$7$+$m$j$$!#2cla9q$o(bur($b%&%k%0%"%$!&%i%&%s%i(b)$b9g0u$j$i$n3f9g0u$r3n
$B$J$I$G$"$k!#(B
WTO$B$OL5:9JL$r86B'$H$7$F$*$j!"CO0hKG0W6(Dj$K$h$kNc3007$$$O!"K\Mh8BDjE*$K$N$_G'$a$i$l$k$Y$-$G$"$k$H9M$($k!#$7$+$7!"(B1990$BG/Be$KF~$jCO0hKG0W6(Dj$,99$K5^B.$J9-$,$j$r8+$;$F$*$j!"FC$K2$JF$NF0$-$O:9JLE*FC7CCO0h$N3HBg6%Ah$NMMAj$9$iBS$S$F$$$k!#$3$&$7$?F0$-$,9T$-2a$.!"B?3QE*KG0WBN@)$NJx2u$d8eB`$K7R$,$k$3$H$N$J$$$h$&!"(BWTO$B$,KIGHDi$H$7$F$NLr3d$r2L$?$9$3$H$r4|BT$9$k!#(B
$BCO0hKG0W6(Dj$O$"$/$^$G$b(BWTO$B$H@09gE*!&Aj8_Jd40E*$G$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$!#$7$+$7!"(BEU$B!"(BNAFTA$BEy$NCO0hKG0W6(Dj$K$*$$$F$O!"8=COD4C#N($N0z$->e$2!"86;:CO5,B'$NWs0UE*$J1?MQ!"?75,2CLA9q$N4X@G$N0z$->e$2$J$I$K$h$j!"0h30$KBP$9$k?7$?$J>cJI$,@8$8!"Hs2CLA9q$N4k6H3hF0$,AK32$5$l$k;vNc$,8+$i$l$k!#CO0hKG0W6(Dj$KBP$7!"(BGATT$BBh(B24$B>r(B($B5Z$S(BGATS$BBh(B5$B>r(B)$B$N873J$J=e
$BCO0hKG0W6(Dj$K4X$9$k(BGATT$BBh(B24$B>r(B($B5Z$S(BGATS$BBh(B5$B>r(B)$B$N2r$^$7$$!#Nc$($P!"(BWTO$B$,
$B?7%"%s%A!&%@%s%T%s%0(B(AD)$B6(Dj$K$h$j!"F)L@@-!"M=8+@-!"8x@5@-$NLL$G5,N'$,6/2=$5$l$?$K$b$+$+$o$i$:!"J]8n
$BD4::$,3+;O$5$l$?>l9g!"HoDsAJ4k6H$K$OC;4|4V$K4XO"2q
$B$^$?!"3F9q$N(BAD$BA
$B?7@/I\D4C#6(Dj$O!"B>$N(BWTO$B6(Dj$H$N0l3g
$BES>e9q$NB?$/$O!"CNE*:b;:$NJ]8n$,IT==J,$G$"$j!"(BTRIPS($BKG0W4XO"CNE*:b;:8"(B)$B6(Dj$K4p$E$-B.$d$+$K9qFbK!$r@0Hw$7!"LOJoIJ$J$I$N
$B86;:CO5,B'$K4X$9$k6(Dj$K$O!"3F9q$,86;:CO5,B'$r@)Dj!&1?MQ$9$k:]$N86B'!"=eCO$,Bg$-$$$?$a!"CO0hKG0W6(Dj$d(BAD$BA
$BES>e9q$G$O!"9qFb;:6H$NJ]8n$N$?$a!"4X@G@/:v$NIQHK$JJQ99!"MM!9$J30;q5,@)$J$I$NA
$BES>e9q$NB?3QE*<+m3kg0w%7%9%f%`$x$n1_3j$j;22c$k$o!"9qfbk!$n@0hw$d@/:vn)0f$kbp$9$k5;=qe*;y1g$,i,mw$g$"$k!#(bwto$b$,@$3&6d9t$d(bunctad$b$j$i$n9q:]5!4x$h6(no$7$f!"0z$-b3$-es>e9q$K@Q6KE*$K=u8@$7$F$$$/$3$H$,K>$^$l$k!#(B
$B$J$*!"9q:]5!4X$NHnBg2=$,LdBj;k$5$l$kCf$G!"(BWTO$B$N;vL36I$,$o$:$+(B500$BL>$NAH?%$G!"8zN($h$/@$3&$NDL>&LdBj$KBP=h$7$F$$$kE@$O9b$/I>2A$5$l$k!#$7$+$7!"J6Ah=hM}BN@)$d4F;kBN@)$N6/2=$K8~$1!"I,MW$K1~$88=:_$N;vL36IBN@)$N3H=<$,k>$^$l$k!#(B
1998$BG/Kv$^$G$Ke5i0Q0w$N3H=o6P2=Ey(B)$B!"(BWTO$B;vL36I$K$*$1$kK!N'@lLg%9%?%C%U$N3H=<$j$i$r?^$k$y$-$g$"$k!#(b
$BA0=R$NDL$j!"?7(BAD$B6(Dj$N?3::4p=`(B(standard of review)$B$OGQ;_$9$Y$-$G$"$j!"$^$7$F$dB>6(Dj$X$NE,MQ3HBg$K$O6/$/H?BP$9$k!#(B
UR$B8r>D$N7k2L!"0lJ}E*A
$B4{$K=R$Y$?$h$&$K!"2$JFEy$N%"%s%A%@%s%T%s%0$Ne9q$N4X@G@/:v!&CNE*:b;:8"@)EY$d3FCO0hKG0W6(Dj$H(BWTO$B$H$N@09g@-$J$I$K4X$9$k(BWTO$B$K$h$k4F;kBN@)$r6/2=$7!"LdBjE@$rE,59;XE&$7!"2~A1$r5a$a$F$$$/$h$&$JBN@)$r@0Hw$9$Y$-$G$"$k!#(B
$B$=$N$?$a$K$O!"8=:_$N(BTPRM(WTO$BKG0W@/:v8!F$@)EY(B)$B$rH4K\E*$K8+D>$9I,MW$,$"$k!#Nc$($P!"BP>]9q$N?3::$K@hN)$A$=$N
$B$H$j$o$1@$3&KG0W$K$*$1$kCf9q$N=EMW@-$O1W!99b$^$C$F$*$j!"(BWTO$B$r??$K@$3&E*$J$b$N$H$7$F$$$/$?$a$K$O!"Cf9q$NAa4|2CLA$,IT2D7g$G$"$k!#$=$N$?$a$K$bCf9q$,!"CNE*:b;:J]8n@)EY$J$I$N9qFb$NKG0W!"7P:Q@)EY$r(BWTO$B%k!<%k$k@09ge*$j$b$n$k$7$f$$$/$h$h$b$k!"4x@g@/:v$n8+d>$7!"N.DL6H$J$I$X$N30;q5,@)$N4KOB$J$I;T>l%"%/%;%9LL$G$N99$J$k<+m32=$k0z$-b3$-
$B:#F|!"4D6-LdBj$O5J6[$K
$BFC$K!"<+m3kg0w$rdl$8$?7p:q@.d9$,4d6-j]8n$rb%?j$9$k$&$($git2d7g$h$n4qe@$+$i!"b?9q4v4d6-6(dj(b(meas)$b>e$NKG0WA
$B4D6-LdBj$X$N
$B8=:_(BOECD$B$K$*$$$F?J$a$i$l$F$$$k(BMAI($BB?9q4VEj;q6(Dj(B)$B$NDy7k$K8~$1$?8r>D$,(B1998$BG/(B4$B7n$N(BOECD$B3UN=M};v2q$^$G$K9g0U$5$l$k$3$H$rK>$`!#(B
$B$^$?!"(BWTO$B$N>l$K$*$$$F$b!"9q:]E*$JEj;q$N<+m32=$k;q$9$k$y$/!"ej;q$k4x$9$kjq3ge*$j%k!<%k:vdj$k8~$1$?8r>D$r3+;O$9$kI,MW$,$"$k!#$3$&$7$?8r>D$N$J$+$G!"Ej;q$K$*$1$kFb9qL1BT6x!":G7C9qBT6x$J$I$N86B'$N3NN)!"Ej;q$r$a$0$kJ6Ah=hM}BN@)$N@0Hw$r?^$k$H$H$b$K!"3F9q$NEj;q$N<+m32=$,
$BKG0W$H6%Ah$K4X$9$k:n6HIt2q$K$*$$$F!"%@%s%T%s%0KI;_A
$B6%Ah@/:v$HDL>&@/:v$H$N9q:]E*D4OB$,?^$i$l$J$$$^$^$K!"0l9q$,<+9q$n;:6h$dm"=pj]8n$n$?$a$k6%ah@/:v$rmtmq$9$k$3$h$k$o!"6/$/h?bp$9$k!#(b
$B$7$+$7!"J,LnJL<+m32=8r>D$O!"$I$&$7$F$b0lIt@h?J9q$N4X?4J,Ln$7$+
$B$o$,9q$NG@6HJ,Ln$N<+m32=$k$d$$$f$o!"7pcdo"$,(b1997$bg/(b9$b7n$k8xi=$7$?0u8+=q(b($BCm;2>H(B)$B$K$"$k$h$&$K!">-Mh$NNc30$J$-4X@G2=$N
$B%5!<%s%9j,ln$k$d$$$f$o!":#8e!"(bgats$b5,b':n6hit2q$k$*$$$f%5!<%s%9$n@/i\d4c#$k4x$9$k5,n'$n:n@.!"jd=u6b$k4x$9$k5,n'$n:n@.ey$,
WTO$B$O!"2DG=$JHO0OFb$G3F8r>D$d:n6HIt2q$N5DO@$NFbMF$N@Q6KE*3+<($r9t$&$h$h$b$k!"i,mw$k1~$8l14v4k6h$h$nd>@\BPOC$r9T$&$J$I!"L14V4k6H$N@<$r3hf0$kh?1g$5$;$k$h$&$j5!2q$rds6!$7$f$$$/$3$h$,k>$^$l$k!#(B
$B$=$NA0Ds$H$7$F!"2f$,9q@/I\$O!"9qFb$N5,@)4KOB$rBgC@$K?d?J$9$k$H$H$b$K!"4p=`!&G'>Z@)EY$N9q:]E*@09g@-$N3NJ]!"=t309q$H$NAj8_G'>Z$N?d?J!"8!::!&8!1V@)EY$N2~A1$J$I!"BPF|;T>l%"%/%;%9$N0lAX$N2~A1$K<+$i@q6ke*$k
$BF|K\8l$N%[!<%`%z!<%8$x(b