[Antennas] Lightning Bolt Antennas

Fri Jun 24 20:51:12 EDT 2005

Gary Smith wrote:
>> Has anyone had any experience with the 2 element quad

Yup, I used a Maco quad for many years before
upgrading to my KT-34. The two element quad will
get you about 5db+ forward gain and a minimum 20db
front to back. At least that was my experience
with the Maco. I suspect other two elements quads
would be close to equal.
> or the 2 element delta-loop on HF?

Same as the two element quad.
 I am trying to
> make a decision on a directional antenna and am
> looking for feedback on overall performance,
> front-to-back and side-to-side, construction quality,
> etc. I've read the E-Ham reviews but there are not
> very many people who have expressed their opinions.
>
I cant vouch for quality or construction. I have
not heard anything negative about Lighting Bolt
Antennas. Have not heard anything positive
either. The term 'Lightning Bolt' puts me off
somewhat. I think a better monicker would have
been 'static free', but then each to his own.
The only 'commercial' antennas I have used are the
Maco quad and the KT-34. Both were excellent and
the KT-34 still is. Depending on your means and
objectives I could not recommend a KT-34 more
highly. Mine has been up for 15 years and still
working flawlessly. I got it as a used basket
case originally. Best investment I ever made but
it takes a good 50 foot tower to make the antenna
perform. The tower may add significant cost to the
installation.
A quad is not so finicky about height. Good
performance at less than a quarter wavelength
elevation. A quad (2 element, HF) is also pretty
easy to homebrew. I would try that before
spending bucks on a commercial offer. Depending on
price, that is. Homebrew for under 100ドル.
Dont get seduced by claims in adds. For specs on
a particular antenna system consult the handbook. 
The handbook sometimes has misprints but it does
not lie.
I have found that the best way of deciding quality
is to evaluate the hardware. If it is stainless,
that is good. If they cant claim stainless, that
is not so good. That does not mean the
non-stainless is a bad deal. It all depends on
price. If you can get it for 'cheap', you can
always supply your own stainless hardware.
Good luck on your decision. Let us know what you
decide.
Regards,
Frank Kamp
K5DKZ