Bjorn Lomborg, The Skeptical Environmentalist: Measuring the Real State of the World

(Cambridge University Press, Cambridge UK, 2001 ISBN0-521-01068-3, 515$B%Z!<%8(b)

2002$BG/(B4$B7n(B10$BF|(B
$B;37A9@@8(B

1. $B35MW(B

$B<+>N4D6-J]8nO@uBV$K4Y$C$F$$$F!"$$$^$9$0J8L@$N$"$jJ}$r(B 180 $BEYE>49$7$J$1$l$PAaHUCO5e$OLG$S$k!"$HC<:(b......$b$@$,!"$=$&$7$?

$B$3$&$7$?4D6-J]8nO@

$B%m%s%\%k%0$OK\=q$G!"4D6-J]8nO@'$($k$N$K;H$C$F$$$k$N$H$^$C$?$/F1$8E}7W$r;H$C$F!"BgI}$K$A$,$&CO5e4D6-$rIA$-=P$9!#CO5e4D6-$O!"$=$s$J$K0-$/$J$$!#?M!9$N@83h$O$I$s$I$s$h$/$J$C$F$$$k!#$=$7$F$3$l$^$G?M!9$,-Mh$N4m5!$r>'$($k3F

$B$=$7$F$=$l$r$b$H$K!"%m%s%\%k%0$O$b$C$H@55$$J4D6-J]8nO@$r>'$($k!#%&%=$r$D$$$F$^$G4D6-4m5!@b$r@z$k$N$O!"D94|E*$K$O?.MQ$r$J$/$7$F<+j,$n$N@/:v2]Bj$H$N%P%i%s%9$d!"J]8n$N$?$a$N%3%9%H$H$N%P%i%s%9$G9M$($J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$!#$=$7$F4D6-J]8n$N$?$a$N$$$A$P$s$$$$J}K!$O!"%i%$%U%9%?%$%k$rBg$-$/JQ$($?$j!"H/E8$r$"$-$i$a$?$j$9$k$3$H$G$O$J$/!"$=$l$J$j$N7P:Q@.D9$rES>e9q$K$b$?$i$7$F$"$2$k$3$H$@!"$HO@$8$F$$$k!#(B

---

2. $BCx

$BCxThe Structure of Solutions in the Iterated Prisoner's Dilemma (Center for International Relations Series) $B$,$"$k!#$b$H$b$H%0%j!<%s%t!<%9=jb0$ng.?4$j4d6-j]8no@

---

3. $BK\=q$N9=@.$H3F>O$N35N,(B

$BBh0lIt(B:$B$h$/J9$/OC(B

1. $B@$$NCf$h$/$J$C$F$$$k$N$@(B

$B4D6-GK2u!";q8;8O3i!"?)NA4m5!!"CO5e29CH2=!"4D6-%[%k%b%s$H!"0-$$%K%e!<%9$p$+$j<*$k$9$k!#$g$b

$B0-$$%K%e!<%9$r$r$m$a$f$$$k3fu$@!#$?$@$7!"$^$@$^$@$@$a$J$H$3$m$O$"$k$N$G!"$=$l$O:#8e$b2~A1$9$kI,MW$,$"$k!#$?$@$7!"$=$N$?$a$K$Ou$r$-$A$s$HGD0.$7!"$^$?$d$l$P2~A12DG=$@$H$$$&$3$H$rG'<1$9$k$y$-!#(b

2. $B$J$<0-$$%k%e!<%9$p$+$j<*$kf~$c$f$/$k$n(b?

$B$^$:!"4D6-CDBN$,$9$G$K8"1WCDBN$K$J$C$F$7$^$C$F$$$k$3$H!#%a%G%#%"$O!"%;%s%;!<%7%g%j%k$j5-;v$p$+$jjsf;$7$?$,$k$3$h!#$=$7$f$=$l$k$"$o$;$f8&5f

$B$3$&$7$?798~$K$OCm0U$,I,MW$@!#(B

$BBhFsIt(B $B?M4V$NJ!;c(B

3. $B?M4V$NJ!;c$r$O$+$k(B

$B@$3&$N?M8}$O$=$b$=$b$$$m$s$J$b$N$r9M$($k4pHW$@$+$i=EMW!#B?$/$N$H$3$m$G?M8}GzH/$N4m5!$,$$$o$l$F$$$k!#$G$b

4. $B4|BT

$B@h?J9q$G$bES>e9q$G$b!"J?6QM>L?$O$N$S!"F};y;`K4N($O7c8:$7$F$$$k!#$^$?!"IB5$$b$b$A$m$s@N$h$j$O$k$+$K8:$C$?$7!"<#nek!$ba}$($f$$$k!#8=be?m$o%9%h%l%9$d%"%l%k%.!<$dg@lt$dltj*$k$h$j$i$s$i$sit7r9/$k$j$c$f$$$k!"$h$$$&@b$r>'$($k?M$O!"$I$&$_$F$b4V0c$$!#(B

5. $B?)NA$H522n(B

$B%^%k%5%90JMh!"$$$:$l?)NA4m5!$,$d$C$F$-$F?M$,$I$s$I$s52$(;`$K$9$k!"$H$$$&$N$,DL@b$K$J$C$F$7$^$C$F$$$k!#$G$be9q$b%+%m%j!<@]

6. $BK-$+$5(B

$B@$3&Cf!"(BGDP $B$O$0$s$0$s>e$,$C$F$$$k!#%i%F%s%"%a%j%+$H%"%U%j%+$O3N$+$K>e$,$j$+$?$,CY$$!#$^$?J,G[$NLdBj$O$J$$$o$1$8$c$J$$$,!"$=$l$G$b@$3&Cf$GIO:$AX$O:o8:$5$l$D$D$"$k!#$5$i$K@$3&Cf$N@$BS$O!"2K$bA}$($F!";v8N$d:R32$b8:$C$F$$$k!#(B

7. $BBhFsIt$N7kO@(B:$B?M4V$O$+$D$F$J$$$[$IHK1I$7$F$$$k(B

$B

$BBh;0It(B $B?M4V$NHK1I$O7QB32DG=$+(B?

8. $B$o$l$o$l$O

$BBh;0It$N%$%s%H%m$H8!F$FbMF$N@bL@!#(B

9. $B?)NA$O$3$N@hB-$j$k$N$+(B?

$B?)NA$,B-$j$J$/$J$k$H$$$&5DO@$O!"%o!<%k%i%&%)%c%a8&5f=j$,9%$s$g=p$9$1$l$i!"$o$:$l$f$p$+$j$$$k$7!"%g!<%?$nfc0[e@$@$1CHq$,A}$($?$i4m5!$,$/$k$H%o!<%k%i%&%)%c%a8&5f=j$oa{$$$@$1$l$i!"$^$c$?$/$=$s$jc{8u$o$j$$!#i=ezn.=p$k$h$kg@cogk2u$b!"$=$s$j$3$h$,5/$-$?$i:$$kg@l1<+?h$,bp:v$r$h$c$f$$$fbg>fIW!#?e;:;q8;$b:OG]5y6H$,$+$J$j$&$^$/9T$C$F$$$k!#$@$+$iEvJ,B-$j$k!#(B

10. $B?9NS!=!=$J$/$J$j$D$D$"$k$N(B?

$B?9NSA4BN$r8+$k$H!"2a5n(B50$BG/0J>e0lDj?e=`!#G.BS1+NS$O3N$+$K8:>/$7$D$D$"$k$1$l$I!"0lIt$N?M$,L@F|$K$b>C$(5n$k$h$&$KA{$0%"%^%>%s$@$C$F!"G/(B0.5%$BDxEY$N8:$jJ}!#(B

11. $B%(%M%k%.!<(b

$B@PL}KdB"NL$N?d7W$O$$$m$$$m$"$k$,!"$^$@7k9=$"$j$=$&$@$7!"$=$l$KCMCJ$,$"$,$l$P$_$s$J>J%(%M$9$k!#$"$HFs!;!;G/$/$i$$$OBg>fIW!#IwNO$dB@M[EECS$J$I$N:F@82DG=%(%M%k%.!<$k@z$jbx$($m$h

12. $B%(%M%k%.!<0j30$n;q8;(b

$B6bB0;q8;$G$b$J$s$G$b!"2a5n?t==G/$K$o$?$C$F$"$i$f$k;q8;$d9[J*$O2A3J$,BgI}$KDc2<$7$f$$$k!#:n7!5;=q$b8~>e$7$F$$$k$7!#$7$?$,$C$F!";q8;8O3i$N?4G[$O$J$5$=$&$@!#(B

13. $B?e(B

$B?e$b!"@dBPNL$H$7$F$OBg>fIW$@!#$?$@$7!"0lIt$N9q$G$O?e$X$N%"%/%;%9$KLdBj$,$"$k!#$=$l$O2?$H$+$9$kI,MW$,$"$k!#$,!"B?$/$N9q$O$3$NE@$G$b2~A1$,B3$$$F$$$k!#$^$?!"?e;q8;$r$a$0$C$FCO0hJ6Ah$,A}$($k$H$$$&8+2r$b$"$d$7$$!#@N$+$i?eMx8"$O=EMW$G!"$7$?$,$C$F%3%_%e%K%F%#$O$=$l$r$a$0$kJ6Ah2r7h

14. $BBh;0It$N7kO@(B:$B$3$N@h$bHK1I$OB3$/(B

$B$H$$$&$o$1$G!":#8eBg$-$JLdBj$,5/$3$j$=$&$K$O8+$($J$$!#(B

$BBh(B4$BIt(B $B8x32$G?M$NHK1I$OBfL5$7$K$J$i$J$$(B?

15. $BBg5$1x@w(B

$BBg5$1x@w$,:G0-$@$C$?$N$O!";:6H3WL?:"$N%$%.%j%9!#$=$N8e!"Bg5$$O5^B.$K2~A1$5$l$F$$$k$N$@!#%m%s%I%s$N8=:_$NBg5$$N>u67$O!"(B16 $B@$5*$HF1$8$/$i$$$N?e=`!#ES>e9q$N>l9g!"3N$+$KBg5$1x@w$O$@$s$@$s$R$I$/$J$C$F$$$k!#$7$+$7!"Bg5$1x@w$r$J$/$9$?$a$N$b$C$H$bM-8z$JJ}K!$O!"K-$+$5$rA}$9$3$H$N$h$&$@!#(B

16. $B;@@-1+$H?9NS$N;`(B

$B;@@-1+$O(B1980$BG/Be$KBg$-$JLdBj$H$5$l$F$$$?$1$l$I!"$I$&$b$=$s$J$KLdBj$G$O$J$$$_$?$$!#;@@-1+$K$h$k?9NS8:>/$bBg$7$?$3$H$O$J$$!#(B

17. $B20Fb6u5$$N1x@w(B

$B$3$l$O20Fb$G$?$-2P$r$9$kES>e9q$G$O$-$o$a$FBgLdBj!#@h?J9q$G$O!"%i%I%s1x@w$,LdBj$K$5$l$k$3$H$,B?$$$1$l$I!"$=$3$=$3!#$^$?!"5J1l$bBg$-$J20Fb6u5$1x@w$N8;$G$O$"$k!#$=$NB>!"%"%9%Y%9%H$d%[%k%`%"%k%G%R%I$NLdBj$J$I$O3N$+$K$"$k!#(B

18. $B%"%l%k%.!<$hscb)(b

$B%"%l%k%.!<$o?mn`$rlg$\$9e*$j%k%e!<%9$ob?$$$,!"$=$b$=$b%"%l%k%.!<$n860x$,$h$/$o$+$i$j$$$n$g!"$3$l$o$j$s$h$b8@$($j$$!#$3$l$o8&5f$ra}$d$9$7$+$j$$!#$?$@!"jl$k4d6-$,0-2=$7$f$$$k$+$i$h$j$b!"20fb$g2a$4$9;~4v$,a}$($f$$$k$3$h$n$[$&$,=emw$n$h$&$g$o$"$k!#(b

19. $B?e

$B$3$l$O$+$J$j$^$7$K$J$C$F$-$F$$$k!#$^$?!"2sI|ITG=$H8@$o$l$?%(%/%=%s%t%!%k%G%9$N%?%s%+!<:b>L$dOQ4_It$N=EL}N.=P8=>l$G$b!"@8BV7O$O40A4$K2sI|$7$F$*$j!"3$$N<+>t:nMQ$OHs>o$K6/$$$3$H$,$o$+$k!#(B

20. $BGQ4~J*(B:$Bl$,$J$$$+(B?

$BCO0h$K$h$C$F$O!"$3$l$OBg$-$JLdBj$@$1$l$I!"$G$b%"%a%j%+$N>l9g!"$3$l$Ol$O$=$3$=$3$"$k!#%j%5%$%/%k$O!"$$$^$/$i$$$GD`$j9g$$$,$H$l$F$$$k$h$&$J$N$G!"L5M}$7$F$3$l0J>e$d$k$H$+$($C$F$D$i$$2DG=@-$,$"$k!#(B

21. $BBh(B4$BIt$N7kO@(B:$B8x32$NIiC4$O8:$j$D$D$"$k(B

$BJlF}Cf$N(BDDT$B$b8:>/$7$F$$$k$7!"8x32$K$h$k1F6A$O@N$h$j$+$J$j%^%7!#8x32$G?MN`$,LG$S$k$H$$$C$?@b$O$*$+$7$$!#$^$@LdBj$O$"$k$1$l$I!"7hDjE*$G$O$J$$!#(B

$BBh8^It(B $BL@F|$NLdBj(B

22. $B2=3XJ*

$B2=3XJ*!#$?$@$7$=$l$r;H$&$H$-$K9bG;EY$GMa$S$kG@L1$OLdBj!#$3$l$O$J$s$H$+$9$kI,MW$"$j!#(B

$B$^$?!"4D6-%[%k%b%s$J$k$b$N$N1F6A$O<+a3%[%k%b%s$khf$y$l$poc$k$j$i$j$$$/$i$$

23. $B@8BV7O$NB?MM@-(B

$B@8J*$,$I$s$I$s@dLG$7$F$$$k$H$$$&$N$O!"8XD%$,$9$.$k!#4D6-J]8nO@8:$H$$$C$?OC$O$^$C$?$/ITE,@Z!#2a5n(B50$BG/$G@8J*/$7$?!#$3$l$OLdBj$G$O$"$k$7!"2r7h$O$7$?$$$1$l$I!"$G$bL$A=M-$N4m5!$G$O$J$$!#(B

24. $BCO5e29CH2=(B

$BLdBj$G$O$"$k!#/$7%3%9%H$HJX1W$r$-$A$s$H$O$+$j$K$+$1$k$Y$-!#(B

$B$D$$$G$K%*%>%sAX$N>C<:$b!";_$^$c$?$h$&$@!#%*%>%s%[!<%k$b>C$($?$_$?$$!#$3$l$O%U%m%sGQ;_$N8z2L$@$H$5$l$F$$$k$1$l$I!"

$BBhO;It(B $BK\Ev$NCO5eGr=q(B

25. $B5gCO$+?JJb$+(B?

$B5gCO$G$O$J$$!#?JJb$OB3$1$F$$$k!#4D6-LdBj$O=EMW$@$7!"4D6-$,GK2u$5$l$?$i?M$O@8$-$F$$$1$J$$$+$i!"@dBP$KJ]8n$OI,MW!#$?$@$7!#$=$l$O$[$+$N$3$H$H$-$A$s$HM%@h=g0L$r$D$1$F9T$*$&!#@h?J9q$N!"$[$H$s$I2?$N1F6A$b$J$$%@%$%*%-%7%s:o8:$H!"$=$N$*6b$G8e?J9q$K3X9;$r:n$k$N$H$I$C$A$rM%@h$9$k$Y$-$+!"$H$$$&A*Br$,I,MW!#(B

$B$^$?!"0dEA;RAH$_BX$(?)IJ$b!":#8e$-$A$s$HZ5r$O$^$C$?$/$"$,$C$F$$$J$$!#6H3&05NO$G8&5f$,$b$_>C$5$l$?$J$s$F$3$H$b$J$$!#(B

---

4. $BK\=q$N8+=j(B

$BF|K\$G$b4D6-LdBj$O$+$J$jOCBj$K$J$C$F$$$k$7!"4D6-%[%k%b%sA{$.$d!VGc$C$F$O$$$1$J$$!WA{F0$J$I!"0lHL?M$N4D6-$KBP$9$k4X?4$O$=$3$=$39b$$!#K\=q$O$=$l$KBP$7$FNd@E$+$D$-$o$a$F2:7r$J8+J}$rDs<($g$-$k!#mwe@$o0j2<$ndl$j(b:

$B!&$3$l$^$G$NWx3e7?4D6-J]8nO@

$B$^$JHD$K>e$,$C$F$$$k4D6-J]8nO@ $B$+$l$i$N5DO@$,o$K$-$l$$$J7A$G<($5$l$f$*$j(b($b$?$h$($pj]8no@C<:!w$h$$$c$?%;%s%;!<%7%g%j%k$j8+=p$7$k$d$$$f$b!"cx

$B!&@5$7$$

$BDL>o!"$3$NfIW!W$H$$$&?e3]$1O@$K=*;O$7!"0lHLFIl9g$,B?$$!#$7$+$7%m%s%\%k%0$,;H$&%G!<%?$o!"4d6-j]8ncdbn$,;h$c$f$$$ke}7w%g!<%?$=$n$b$n!#$7$?$,$c$f%g!<%?$n=p=j$g$=$7$f%m%s%\%k%0$oe}7w3xe$G!"$=$N2ru$,Hs>o$KL@2w$K$o$+$k$7!"$^$?%G!<%?$n=p=j$k$h$k?e3]$1o@$k$j$i$:!"%g!<%?$r$i$&8+$k$+$h$$$&oc$k$7$\$k$3$h$g!"fi

$B!&%O%k%^%2%I%sO@$K4Y$i$J$$4uK>$N$"$k>-MhA|(B

$B4{B8$N4D6-J]8nO@$NB?$/$O!"4D6-$r$H$k$+J8L@$r$H$k$+!"$H$$$C$?5f6K$NA*Br$r$D$-$D$1$?$,$k!#B?$/$N?M$O!"$=$s$J$3$H$r8@$o$l$F$b:$OG$9$k$@$1$@$,!"K\=q$G$O!"$=$s$JA*Br$OI,MW$,$J$$$3$H!"?M$OLdBj$r2r7h$G$-$k$7!"$=$l$O$$$^$NJ8L@$N$"$j$+$?$r:,K\E*$KJQ$($J$/$F$b2DG=(B($B$H$$$&$+B?$/$O$9$G$K$d$C$F$$$k(B)$B$H$$$&$3$H$,<($5$l$k!#$3$l$^$g$n0e$$>-MhA|$G$O$J$$!"4uK>$N$"$k8=:_$NA|$H>-MhA|$,IA$+$l$F$$$F!"5$;}$A$,$$$$!#(B

$B!&%3%9%H$HJX1W(B($B8z2L(B)$B!"$*$h$S$=$NB>$N@/:v$r$O$+$j$K$+$1$m$H$$$&@55$$J5DO@(B

$BK\=q$,:G=*E*$KDs0F$9$k$N$O!"%3%9%H$HJX1W$N%P%i%s%9$N$H$l$?;\:v!"$=$7$F4D6-$@$1FCJL;k$7$J$$!"$[$+$N;\:v$H%P%i%s%9$N$H$l$?4D6-J]8n!#6qBNE*$J8DJL;\:v$^$G$O$b$A$m$s=P$F$3$J$$$1$l$I!"%3%9%H$HJX1W$N%P%i%s%9$H$O$I$&$$$&$3$H$+!"$[$+$N;\:v$H$N%P%i%s%9$dM%@h=g0LIU$1$H$O$I$&$$$&$3$H$+$r$-$A$s$H@bL@!#(B

---

5. $BK\=q$N4m81@-(B

$B!&4{B84D6-CDBN$+$i$N967b(B

$BCxl9g!"$^$"$=$NScientific American $B$d(B Nature $B$G!"$3$&$7$?%M%,%F%#%V%l%S%e!<$,$+$j$j=p$f$$$k!#$=$l$kbp$7$f%m%s%\%k%0$o$-$a$s$hh?o@$7$f$$$k$n$g!"$=$&$7$?$"$?$j$k$d$$$f$b2r@b$g?($l$f!"$1$s@)$r$+$1$f$*$/$n$,k>$^$7$$!#(B

$B!&!V2?$b$7$J$/$F$$$$!W$H$$$&8=>uMFG'O@$H$N$9$j$+$(!#(B

$B$=$N0lJ}$G!"JQ$J;:6HCDBN$H$+$,8=>uMFG'O@$K;H$C$F$7$^$&$N$b$*$b$7$m$/$J$$$N$G!"$3$l$OK.Lu;~$N2r@b$J$I$GE#$r$5$7$F$*$/I,MW$"$j!#(B

---

6. $B4|BT$5$l$kFI

$BK\=q$O!"4D6-LdBj$N4X78OE*$K$bFI$_$d$9$/!"0lHL8~$1$K=q$+$l$F$*$j!"%?%3%D%\O@AhE*$JItJ,$b$J$$!#4D6-$K4X?4$N$"$k0lHLFI

---

7. $BK]Lu$K$"$?$C$F$NCm0U(B

$B2?$h$j$b!"$h$_$d$9$/$o$+$j$d$9$$K]Lu$,K>$^$l$k!#0lHL8~$1$K!"Wx3e7?4D6-O@u$K$D$$$FL@3N$JM}2r$r@8$8$5$;$kI,MW$,$"$k$+$i$G$"$k!#(B

$B$^$?F1$8M}M3$G!"@53N$JK]Lu$,I,MW!#$"$2$"$7$r

$B$*$=$i$/0lHV$NLdBj$O!"K\=q$,$+$J$jD9$$$3$H!#(B500 $B%Z!<%80j>e$H$J$C$F$$$k!#$3$N$&$A!"Cm$H;29MJ88%$,(B 150 $B%Z!<%8$r@j$a$f$$$k!#$?$@$7$3$nitj,$o@dbp$k:o=|$g$-$j$$!#;2>H$7$F$$$kJ88%$J$I$,JP$C$F$*$i$:!"%U%'%"$J5DO@$,E83+$5$l$F$$$k$3$H$r;Y$($k$N$,$3$NItJ,$@$+$i!#$?$@$7K.Lu;~$K$O$3$3$NItJ,$NK.Lu=q$J$I$rD4$Y$k$N$,7k9=D$,I,MW$+$b$7$l$J$$!#(B

$B::FI%j%9%H(B $BF|K\8l(B Top Page

---

Valid XHTML 1.0! YAMAGATA Hiroo (hiyori13@alum.mit.edu)